3 ms·
It hasn't much helped the local stores, either; I think it was too late. As you say, allowing cars on the promenade hasn't helped. And big box stores have bea
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
It hasn't much helped the local stores, either; I think it was too late.
As you say, allowing cars on the promenade hasn't helped. And big box stores have beaten the smaller local businesses in plenty of other towns.
So why do you attribute the failure of the downtown to the pedestrian only zones rather than to competition?
- w1ntermute 16y agoLike he said, it was too late. You don't know that the results would have been different if the stores on the promenade had been able to compete with the big box stores.
- blahedo 16y agoNo, but you can run a natural experiment: look at towns of similar size (let's say 30k-50k) that had shops downtown and competition from big box stores on the outskirts, but did not block cars from the downtown stores, and see what happened there. Answer: there are a few towns that retained or have regrown a vibrant downtown (I live in one), but not many. Most small cities have a downtown that is either functionally a ghost town, or that has been converted to low-traffic uses (like lawyers' offices). Though not a certainty, it's a pretty fair conclusion that the bricked pedestrian mall is not what killed Richmond's downtown.
- Vivtek 16y agoWell, that's hard to say, really, and I'm certainly not saying it was the only factor. But if I look at other small Indiana towns I know, I can think of several with central squares that are still doing well (Paoli springs to mind, or Winchester), and New Castle's downtown died when the state closed down the street for construction for a year. (Statewide mandates for width of state roads - they took out trees along the street, one of which my kindergarten class had collected money to pay for. Oy.) And certainly Richmond's overall economic decline started in the 30's and hasn't really gotten any better since then. But my overall point is that pedestrian zones don't automatically turn into cafe-laden paradises, as much as we'd all like that to happen, and in America in particular that's less likely to happen than in Europe, largely (imho) due to our much lower density of population - itself due in part to automobile addiction.