3 ms·
Why generate symbols that are not permitted anyway? You'd lose nothing by emitting the base16 encoding of the symbol.
by kqr 9y ago
Why generate symbols that are not permitted anyway? You'd lose nothing by emitting the base16 encoding of the symbol.
- notacoward 9y agoThe problem is that there is no character-type pattern - most especially not your base16 suggestion - that will satisfy every site. Many sites require special characters. Others forbid them. It's literally impossible to satisfy both with a single non-parameterized generator, and as soon as you start adding parameters those effectively become hidden parts of the domain name. Worse, many sites don't even tell you what the requirements are on normal entry (only on change). If you can't remember what particular tweaks were necessary then it's back to the good old "forgot my password" dance - making your email password your effective password for all such sites. It's easy for app developers to be careless or "clever" about their password rules, but it's a pain for users and it's bad for security.
- natch 9y agoHave you even used the internet much? Some sites do require symbols. And some sites have ridiculous rules that your suggestion would also not help with. Also, restricting yourself to the 16 characters in hex encoding makes your passwords that much easier to guess.
- kqr 9y ago> Also, restricting yourself to the 16 characters in hex encoding makes your passwords that much easier to guess. No. Entropy does not change by adding redundant bits.
- natch 9y agoThe bits are not redundant. When you have a larger alphabet, you get more possibilities for the same length of password. Sure you could also have a password that consists only of 1 and 0, but then you would have an unreasonably long password. Just as you would also have for a hex password, to a lesser degree. To carry it to an extreme you could have your password consist of just one character repeated a secret number of times, and yeah, sure, in your little theory world the amount of entropy could still be the same, but practically speaking it's a stupid idea, just like using hex characters. You really are confused about this stuff. You also seem completely unaware that many sites have password rules that require special characters that don't exist in your scheme... lol!