4 ms·
I know I'm being downvoted for political reasons, but this seems a clear-cut case where you can reason your way around here. Please explain. Let's use my circu
by DanielBMarkham 16y ago
I know I'm being downvoted for political reasons, but this seems a clear-cut case where you can reason your way around here.
Please explain. Let's use my circumstances for an example.
I live an hour from any city. I do well enough financially, so parking taxes will not effect me one way or the other (neither would a gasoline tax). Within an mile of where I live, there are probably another 100 families. Most of them do not do so well. I live in a very rural and poor area. One family I know is a single mom and teenage daughter. While their housing is provided by family, each of them makes minimum wage and have to drive to the city to work. They barely keep one car running and the lights on at home.
Now I believe you are saying we should tax them for parking in the city. Then give everybody the money back from the tax. Perhaps at the end of the year when they file their taxes.
This would be devastating to these folks. Sure, you'd cut down on car use, but at what cost? For every middle-income person who took a few less trips, how many low-income people did you just kick out of work?
Did I understand that correctly? And please, no "but those folks are living the wrong way!" comments. These people are living as best as they can. One social engineering event per conversation, please. The point is to defend, explain, or analyze the article in question. The essay seemed to me to be the kind of pontificating that looks good from the ivory tower living in the city, but has very limited real application to the rest of the country, aside from hurting people for a noble cause.
- tedunangst 16y agoThey are living as best they can in their current circumstances. Local maxima. If no free parking meant better public transit, they wouldn't have to struggle to keep the car running. Of all the many possible subsidies the government could or does provide, do you really think free parking is the most beneficial?
- SoftwareMaven 16y agoThere is NO way you are going to cover every semi-rural and suburban area in the US with public transportation even during business hours (much less during the shift periods of lower wage earners). The cost of free parking is trivial compared to what that would cost.
- sprout 16y agoWhat do you mean by >One social engineering event per conversation, please. Wasn't the central 'event' of the article social engineering? The central point of the article seemed to be the assertion that people who are that poor and should not be living so far from their place of employ would be better off if we did this. Yes, they would lose their jobs if they stayed where they are. But the taxes on parking would discourage borderline-poor from owning cars in the city, which in turn would bring down housing costs in the city, making it possible for your neighbors to live more cheaply and healthfully by biking/busing to their now nearby job. Yes, there would be hardship involved. But the alternative is waiting until fossil fuels rise to such a cost that they can't afford to drive to the city anyway. We've then destroyed their chance of earning a livelihood by chasing their short-term comfort.
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoI'm done here, but let me explain. Too often the pattern in "what do do about problem X" is to write an essay espousing that we do "A" Usually these essays gloss over, ignore, or belittle side-effects because a discussion of all the edge cases and results doesn't make a good essay (or a good book). In addition, most things in life are complicated, and authors need to make a succinct point, quickly. The problem is that what makes for good essays, what makes for good political talk, very rarely is as clear-cut as the essayists make out to be. So along comes some schmuck (I volunteer for this role in my story) and points out the half-dozen or so unstated implications of A. No problem, the supporters say, we'll just add B and C in there. Now, that fixes all your concerns. Well yes, but are we talking about A, or A, B, and C. You're just adding in more stuff. Because now we need to talk about the implications of B and C, which you probably haven't thought that much about and are probably worse than the ones for A. "No problem," folks say, because when we do B and C, obviously D, E, and F come along. They're needed to take care of C. This can continue ad infinitum, with each addition of terms being less and less thought out, and the implications more and more unpleasant. The thesis of the article, if I understood it, was that the cost to society for parking in the city (and he seemed to be saying the suburbs as well, although I might have misread) outweighs the benefits. A tax, or elimination of some parking would produce more good than bad. I take issue with that conclusion, although I grant his premise -- costs of stuff keep going up -- to be true. I take issue with it for many reasons: cost to the rural poor and middle-class, cost to the urban poor, view of the problem from an academic standpoint instead of a practical one, using a long-term problem without clear costs (fossil fuel issues) to directly hurt people living today. There are all kinds of reasons I take issue with his thesis. In addition, the premise was trite. Mundane. The conclusion I found supercilious. It was just really bad. I'm sure the author is a great guy and wonderful and all, and I agree with his cause, but that doesn't mean I have to like this essay. I don't.
- cabalamat 16y agoOne solution used in Britain is park-and-ride schemes: people drive to the edge of the city, park their car, then take a bus/train into the city center.
- pwim 16y agoIn your example: * there are about 100 families within a mile or so of you * they need to spend an hour or so to drive into the city * they can already barely afford a car and "to keep the lights on" To me, this screams out for car-pooling, or some other shared transportation solution, as it would be better for the environment and cheaper for them. Also, economies are complex systems. If low income people can't afford to commute into the city, the jobs wouldn't disappear, as the work wouldn't disappear. So someone closer who was previously unemployed might get the job. Or in response to the shortage of workers, the wages of these jobs might be raised.
- cabalamat 16y ago> To me, this screams out for car-pooling Didn't someone mention on HN a startup that intends to do for taxis what airbnb is doing for hotels? This could be at least part of a solution.
- sigstoat 16y agoPoor families like that are probably doing shift work spread across the day, so only a third of them are trying to get into town at any given time (and another third is coming back). Also, just from a practical standpoint, telling some people "your jobs won't disappear... other people will have them!" is, uh, problematic. At best.
- flatulent1 16y agoThere are cities that have trouble finding workers at the lower wage end of the spectrum because the cost of living for those people is just too high. A good example is Santa Barbara California. The poor are taxed enough already. If you think employers are somehow going to cover this cost, see how anxious they would be to pay for it directly. Perhaps customers and employees should be treated as a form of pollution, just another toxic resource used by business. Wouldn't that justify business having to pay?? If given only enough wealth to survive, aren't we saying that employees have no function except to work and consume? How far do we have to tax people before it becomes institutionalized slavery? Cars have been a part of the American dream for a long time. Unless/until our cities are made where everyone can easily function without them, pricing some people out of them equates to a serious impairment and loss of freedom. Taxing things that impact society isn't always the answer. Try taxing children and see how far that goes. The wages of city employees keep going up more than that of the poor in the communities they "serve". What do some cities do to fuel that? Bring in more people, more box stores, tax it all. Perhaps there is a fundamental conflict of interest in the way some city/county/state/national taxes and spending are handled?
- yason 16y agoI think what's more relevant is the fact that the motorized way of living simply cannot continue forever because it's not based on any kind of sustainable economy and given that, the whole thing is going to come down crashing either now and slowly, or later but with a big bang.