4 ms·
> HTML is a pain for things that aren't documents. Indeed it is but there seem to be no relevant alternative. The only thing that is better [for apps] is XAML
by qwerty456127 9y ago
> HTML is a pain for things that aren't documents.
Indeed it is but there seem to be no relevant alternative. The only thing that is better [for apps] is XAML (WPF) but it is Windows-only.
- javajosh 9y agoSVG + JS is really quite good. You will need a few abstractions to work comfortably with the SVG DOM, but you can easily write these as you need them.
- qwerty456127 9y agoSounds reasonable. Why don't people use it then? Are there any frameworks already available so one won't have to invent a GUI toolkit from scratch?
- Someone 9y agoOne of the “few abstractions to work comfortably with the SVG DOM” that “you can easily write […] as you need them” would be a layout engine. You need one to adjust your UI to the user’s screen size. Another, I think, is that, to add scroll bars to a view, you have to write SVG scroll bars, make them respond to the mouse scroll wheel, be accessible, etc. Even if we will get them, eventually, it won’t be “easily”. I think it is easier to use HTML for layout, and SVG (or canvas) for those views that need it. You can do that now.
- javajosh 9y ago>layout engine Absolute positioning gets a bad rap! And yes, if you want widgets then you have a lot of work ahead of you. But it's a lot of fun to just work with the primitives - don't believe them when they tell you always need a GUI toolkit!
- fastball 9y agoWhy not use something like Pug[0], which compiles to HTML? [0] - https://pugjs.org/api/getting-started.html https://pugjs.org/api/getting-started.html
- pjmlp 9y agoNo, there are other XAML variants, like Avalon and Xamarin.Forms. JavaFX also follows the same design ideas. And there is QML as well.
- qwerty456127 9y agoXamarin.Forms is cool but still doesn't work on Linux so it seems the same story as XAML to me - cool but of little use, unlike to HTML which is less cool but absolutely useful as it works everywhere. JavaFX - doesn't work on mobiles/tablets (there was a prototype in 2011, seemingly abandoned), sadly it seems to be about as dead as Flash and Silverlight now. As for QML - search results suggest it works everywhere but still hardly a popular choice for some reason, worth taking a closer look perhaps (but I still doubt it can compare to HTML as using Qt means producing binary builds for every platform to support AFAIK).
- pjmlp 9y agoAvalonia (which I mistyped as Avalon) works in Linux, so XAML works on Linux. JavaFX surely works on mobile. http://gluonhq.com/ http://gluonhq.com/ HTML is useless without a binary build of a running browser, that doesn't expose platform specific APIs.