4 ms·
Start a cooperative enterprise, owned by the workers at all levels, not just the techno-elite founders. With all given an equal vote. Establish small limits on
by Robotbeat 9y ago
Start a cooperative enterprise, owned by the workers at all levels, not just the techno-elite founders. With all given an equal vote. Establish small limits on pay disparities (say, never more than 2:1 to compensate for different schooling/certification requirements for doctors or the like).
I second the open source suggestion.
- fogzen 9y agoGreat point. We can start more cooperative enterprises. Are there good templates and software for the founding and unique management issues of a cooperative enterprise? If you or anyone else has ideas on that, please share them :)
- kiwicopple 9y agoThis is in no way battle-ready, but I have been thinking about this throughout the year and jotting my ideas - http://madebykade.com/manifesto/profit-sharing/ http://madebykade.com/manifesto/profit-sharing/
- mooneater 9y agoRelated: Golder Associates is a canadian consulting engineering firm that is employee owned, Ive heard good things from people who worked there. Being employee owned really changes the politics. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golder_Associates https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golder_Associates
- Robotbeat 9y agoMondragon Corporation, but probably not a good example as it's huge and formed a long time ago. That's where I got the idea for pay ratios. Theirs is 4:1 for doctors, I believe. Here's a better example, a worker-owned engineering and manufacturing cooperative in Wisconsin: http://www.isthmuseng.com/company/worker-owned-cooperative/ http://www.isthmuseng.com/company/worker-owned-cooperative/ ...interestingly, they specialize in automation equipment. The way to make it possible to pay everyone well is to use automation. The only way to achieve that shiny Star Trek future is through replicators (which are a stand-in for general automation tech), although you could always be like the Ferengi and charge for use of the replicator... Tech ENABLES high wages even for janitors, but it doesn't guarantee it. That requires an actual choice.
- kiliantics 9y agoCheck out platform.coop it's a movement based specifically around forming co-ops in tech. I think co-ops are the best approach right now to shifting our economy in a direction that is fair and equitable, rather than the capitalist economy of exploitation we are stuck with now.
- bufferoverflow 9y agoSo you want to pay janitors way above the market rate or the doctors way below the market rate? And where did the 2:1 ratio come from? It takes decades to become a surgeon. It takes maybe 20 minutes of training someone to mop a floor.
- wagecuck 9y agoIt is fine to pay doctors way more than the janitors, but only if the janitors are given an equal vote when it comes time to determine salaries.
- weddpros 9y agoAgree... in this case, you'll have lots of janitors apply to the job, and no surgeon. The market does regulate these things normally, if there's no coercion. That's why socialist countries are oppressive, to enforce a vision that goes against the will of some individuals, to the benefit of other individuals. You can't have freedom if you refute freedom of choice.
- kiliantics 9y agoYou'll get surgeons who are motivated by things other than just money, which is who you want applying.
- bufferoverflow 9y agoThat's delusional. When a surgeon sees he can make $2M at one place and $40K at another to subsidize the janitors, only a complete moron would choose the second option.
- SethRich 9y agoThere is never a situation in which it's a good idea to give every employee an equal vote. Employees of various seniority and talent provide varying levels of value to the enterprise. 1. Why should the newly hired janitor have equal voting rights to the CTO that envisioned and built the product or the Machine Learning PHD whose education cost him 10 years and half a million dollars? 2. Personnel counts grow at an exponential rate. If you double your personnel count over a year as plenty of startups do, what's stopping all the new employees from mutinying and kicking out the early employees that have been been working on the business for 5 years? 3. Where's the incentive for founders who face disproportionate risk in the startup stage to build an enterprise that they may eventually own 0.1% of? If you have ever even thought of starting a business on your own, you would not think this is a good idea.
- gnopgnip 9y agoIf you specialize on your core competencies you can avoid a lot of these issues. Does every 10+ person business need to have janitors, and other support personnel as employees? Does every large business need to own real estate?
- weddpros 9y agoIf janitors work in a janitors company, and developers work in a developers company, and accountants in an accountants company, then there's no point in seeking equality anymore: because janitors conditions will be different to others conditions anyway. You'll achieve nothing but a caste system.
- kiliantics 9y agoThere is a cooperatively run janitors company in NYC that manages to pay its worker-owners much more than the going rate yet still gets enough business to survive. I believe this is probably due to not having overpaid management overhead in their costs.
- mbid 9y agoPersonnel counts grow at an exponential rate. Wrong usage of "exponential" seems to grow exponentially these days.