4 ms·
It is 1/2 if the host just randomly opens one of the doors, irrespective of the things behind them. It is 2/3 if the host always opens one of the remaining doo
by yorwba 9y ago
It is 1/2 if the host just randomly opens one of the doors, irrespective of the things behind them.
It is 2/3 if the host always opens one of the remaining doors with a lemon.
It is 0 if the host only opens a door with a lemon if he can't choose a door with a car.
- oliv__ 9y agoIn my mind, when you take out one lemon, you end up in a new situation with two doors: one with a lemon, the other with a car. I still can't see how having picked one of those two doors in a previous setting changes the current situation of two doors, one pick.
- yorwba 9y agoThe host's choice depends both on your choice and the things behind the doors. Therefore he is revealing information about them. Even if you didn't pick which doors the host must choose between; if he only ever opens a door with a lemon, you should choose one of the doors he had a chance to open but didn't.
- oliv__ 9y agoI get it. Framed this way, it makes more sense. Thanks for bearing with me!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mrob 9y agoSome presentations of the problem leave it ambiguous, but this article makes it clear that the host always opens a door to reveal a lemon. In this correctly stated version of the Monty Hall problem, switching always improves your chances.
- yorwba 9y agoThe description in the article is > The contestant must pick a door, and then the host opens one of the two doors the contestant didn't pick, to reveal a lemon. I'm not a native English speaker, but I think this is ambiguous between "to reveal a lemon" specifying the reason or the outcome. At least I seem to remember constructions like "They tried again and again, only to fail each time.", which obviously aren't about motivation.
- mrob 9y agoI retract my statement that it's unambiguous. The article leaves the possibility that the host didn't know where the car was and revealed a lemon only by chance. In this case there's no reason to switch doors. The host has to know where the car is and always reveal a lemon.