6 ms·
There is a much steeper cost to parking - the effects on public space. The provision of surface-level parking reduces urban density, making cities less walkable
by jdietrich 16y ago
There is a much steeper cost to parking - the effects on public space. The provision of surface-level parking reduces urban density, making cities less walkable, bringing with it an array of other social problems.
In the parts of Europe where people walk and cycle, there has necessarily been an aggressively anti-car policy. In London there is a daily charge of $12 just to drive into the city. This congestion charge has strong public support due to the obvious and substantial quality-of-life improvements it has brought. A well-located car park can easily charge $70 a day. In denser parts of London, residents are charged fees by the local government for the right to park in front of their own houses, many people lease out driveway space and a single car garage in the most prestigious areas can sell for as much as $300,000. Many towns and cities in Italy have completely banned non-essential motor vehicles from the city centre - often the old city walls form a natural division. Of course, gasoline in most of Europe has cost in excess of $6 a gallon for years.
I'm not arguing that this is a superior way of running things, it is simply a difference in priorities, but the costs of car use are far greater than I think most Americans would recognise. To many of you, our high gas prices, expensive parking and restrictive regulations must be quite shocking. Our small towns must seem almost unreal in their quaintness, in the age of their infrastructure, in their density. Most of us drive vehicles of comically small proportions. By the same token, many of us find cities like LA and Houston to be frightening, Ballardian places. We are shocked at the priority given to cars, at the lack of sidewalks and the sheer sprawl of such cities. By the standards of most European governments, the average American city is practically uninhabitable and would be torn down and started anew. We both pay a steep price for our cars; The price we pay is more obvious to you, but the price you pay is more obvious to us.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- altano 16y agoParking and also other infrastructure, mainly highways and larger roads that cut up the city. The largest benefactors of the Big Dig in Boston (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Dig http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Dig) were not those driving on the newly improved road or those benefiting from the reduced traffic, but rather those who could now enjoy the green way, those living in or visiting the North End (hey I can walk there now!), those benefiting from the improved air quality of having a filtered highway, etc.
- cabalamat 16y agoWhile I don't live in London any more, I'm sure that policies to reduce car use and increase public transport are the way to go for London; the alternative would be for everyone to drive (because public transport isn't good enough) and end up sitting in a traffic jam for 4 hours every day! Fun fact: London has over 600 railway stations.
- elblanco 16y ago> public transport isn't good enough > London has over 600 railway stations. But if London can't do public transport properly with over 600 stations, what would it take? The tube system is simply massive. Just some system comparisons (sorry, I love subway systems, it's a rare obsession of mine): London Underground - 270 Stations, 250 mile total length (mtl), ~3 million daily riders (mdr) Métro de Paris - 300 stations, 133 mtl, 4.5 mdr The Moscow Metro - 182 stations, 187.2 mtl, 6.55 mdr Seoul Subway - 291 stations, 188.4 miles, 5.6 mdr Tokyo Subway - 282 stations, 204 mtl, 8.7 mdr New York Subway - 468 stations, 229 mtl, 5 mdr D.C. Metro - 86 Stations, 106 mtl, .8 mdr Chicago L - 144 Stations, 106 mtl, .6 mdr Barcelona - 164 Stations, 77 mtl, 1 mdr Of these cities, I've never been to London, or Tokyo. But I've been to the rest and ridden the systems in those cities. I found all the systems provided great coverage near the city center and excellent walkability of the city (except for maybe big chunks of Moscow and Chicago outside of the loop). Things thin out a bit in the burbs for any system, but that's to be expected. The real problem is that cities can grow out fast. Cost of living in the centers of any of these cities can be insane. So people naturally move out, and the systems simply aren't as good there. The key seems to be rapid and aggressive expansion of the systems. But that just simply doesn't seem to be happening.
- ugh 16y agoMany towns and cities in Italy have completely banned non-essential motor vehicles from the city centre - often the old city walls form a natural division. And in Germany. Spain. France. And so on. I was actually surprised when I first heard that walkable and car-free city centers are practically unheard of in the US. How could you even go about getting to know a city or exploring a town without some character defining and walkable center? Those car-free city centers are of course also in Europe a rather recent development. The market square in my town – nowadays used by cafes, restaurants and pedestrians – was a parking lot until the seventies.
- Vivtek 16y agoRichmond, Indiana is a case in point for the American view. In the late 60's there was a huge gas explosion here, destroying three blocks of the downtown. (It was unfortunate that the gas leak was under the sporting goods store that sold ammo, and no I'm not making this up.) During the reconstruction, they decided to make the main drag a pedestrian-only zone; lots of beautiful old storefronts and so on, and so they bricked it in and called it the Promenade. About ten years ago, they gave it up for a failed experiment. Due to the lack of parking, the stores there failed one by one (the big boxes on the edge of town didn't help). More recent studies showed that the only pedestrian zones that worked in smaller American cities are the ones adjacent to college campuses, where you've got lots of free-range money whose cars are elsewhere. It was freaking weird getting back to town a couple of years ago and driving down the Promenade. It hasn't much helped the local stores, either; I think it was too late. But the European ideal of the nice leafy pedestrian zones with cafes and stuff didn't happen here, unfortunately.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoIt hasn't much helped the local stores, either; I think it was too late. As you say, allowing cars on the promenade hasn't helped. And big box stores have beaten the smaller local businesses in plenty of other towns. So why do you attribute the failure of the downtown to the pedestrian only zones rather than to competition?
- 16y ago
- Silhouette 16y agoIt seems there is at least one good point in the article, if US regulations require that property developers also provide certain minimum levels of parking whether they want to or not. On the other hand, as someone who comes from England, where some of our local authorities very much have that "aggressively anti-car policy" you mentioned and it's more likely that local regulations will prohibit a property developer from providing the expected (by customers) level of parking at a new property, I would like to give some other perspectives. For one thing, there is an entitlement culture here, because motorists are arguably the most over-taxed group in our population. The bottom line is that motorists pay around £50B/year in direct motoring-related taxation, while only around £10B/year is spent on maintaining and developing our road network. Slapping obviously punitive charges for parking on roads we've already paid for five times over is, understandably enough, politically unpopular. You mentioned London several times, but London is something of a special case because of its population density and the viability of providing a comprehensive public transport system as an alternative. Most cities in the UK do not have the level of bus service that London does, or any alternatives at all like the London Underground. In the end, people drive because it is useful. It saves time compared to other modes of transport, other than walking or cycling over relatively short distances. It allows you to take plenty of physical goods with you if you need to. And of course it is much more pleasant to ride in your own vehicle than to sit in an uncomfortable seat, next to someone stinking of whatever they just ate or drank, in a cabin that is so humid the windows have all steamed up, in the middle of winter when several other passengers have kindly brought colds and other bugs with them to share in the fertile breeding environment that public transportation typically provides. If you think you can reduce the amount of driving we do without taking this usefulness into account, you're crazy. This was summed up neatly in a post on another forum I saw recently, which observed that in one small town centre, a key retail site went through this transition once the local council decided to make money off parking: Waitrose -> Safeway -> Kwiksave -> empty -> Poundland For those not in the UK, that starts with one of the nicer general stores with a reputation for selling good quality food and so on, then moves through progressively cheaper stores selling products that aren't as good, finally reaching a store where they basically sell everything at £1 to people without the money to shop anywhere else. Apparently two other big name supermarkets moved out of town to where they could still offer free parking, so those who drive could still go there but anyone living locally in the town centre who didn't have a car lost out. Public transport can be a sensible alternative where a critical mass of passengers exists, triggering economies of scale in financial cost, environmental impact and land use. However, apart from in really big cities like London, that is rarely the case outside a fairly narrow window of time around the average working day. Running a bus service in the evening is madness in environmental and financial terms, but if you advocate a modal shift from car use to bus use it becomes a political necessity. Did I mention that a lot of the pro-bus propaganda is outright lies in environmental terms, since it typically assumes far higher than average bus passenger numbers vs. single occupany car journeys, and it tends to focus on specific carbon-based pollutants (where buses are better per passenger-mile than cars) while ignoring much nastier things like particulates and sulphur-based pollutants (where buses are typically much worse, as anyone living in the centre of bus-friendly cities here in the UK is now learning to their cost). Public transport advocacy also typically talks about effects "per passenger-mile", while conveniently ignoring the indirect nature of public transport that means a passenger travelling between the same origin and destination might go a lot further along the way. As for trains, they have their advantages, but economics isn't one of them: I'm not sure there is any heavy rail network in the world that would actually be profitable without massive government subsidies that directly or indirectly support it. It's already far cheaper to drive or to fly(!) than to get the train to most places here in the UK, regular rail passengers are always complaining about high fares, yet they aren't even close to paying the true cost of their journey on the ticket price. If you want to make a serious argument about market forces driving transport provisions, start by abolishing trains entirely (and then discover that these things do not operate in a vacuum and there are consequences to that decision beyond the direct operating budget of the railway network). Do we drive too much today? Yes, we do. Many people lose a huge amount of time they could be spending being productive or enjoying themselves, just sitting in a car instead. Lots of land is devoted to road space, even in densely populated areas like big cities, that could have been put to other uses. There is a significant amount of environmental damage any way you look at it. But why do we drive too much? That is the real question. It's all very well having critics claiming that building new roads only results in higher traffic demand, but cars don't appear from nowhere and people mostly don't drive for no reason. The extra traffic appears when new roads are built because people want to make a journey, and the latent demand was not adequately served by the existing transport options before the new road. The solution to all of these problems is "simply" to reduce the number of journeys we need to make. In a modern world, we have communication options that were not available even a few years ago. If you work in a customer-facing role or doing any sort of manual labour, then of course you need to be physically present where the work is. However, how many people are getting into their cars and driving for an hour or more every day just to be in the same office as their colleagues, to whom they will only speak on a few occasions during the day while otherwise keeping to themselves and getting on with their work anyway? There is obviously a need for both communication and socialising even in these jobs, but there are many other arrangements that could provide time to do these things -- and probably in much more efficient or satisfying ways -- than the daily drive to work at a central office with fixed or near-fixed hours. Maybe, instead of trying to artificially reduce demand for car journeys, we should be looking at the lifestyles we lead today and why people need to make all those journeys in the first place?
- w1ntermute 16y agoYou can't take European philosophies and apply it to America. Things are completely different over here. You spend so much time worrying about congestion, but we have so much open space here that it's simply not an issue. The population density in Europe is 70 ppl/sq km. In America, it's 32.
- masterj 16y ago>You spend so much time worrying about congestion, but we have so much open space here that it's simply not an issue. Ever been to LA, Houston, Atlanta?
- hugh3 16y agoThe provision of surface-level parking reduces urban density, making cities less walkable, bringing with it an array of other social problems. There are all sorts of social problems associated with high-density housing as well. 1. Crime is rampant in high-density areas all over the world. 2. Children have nowhere to play. You can't just let your children wander freely. 3. Noise. One jerk with a subwoofer can spoil the night of a hundred people instead of just three. 4. And so forth. I'm sure if you looked at statistics you'd find all sorts of horrible social problems (mental illness etc) correlated with population density, even once you correct for income and so forth. Cramming too many people into too little space just has bad consequences. Personally I couldn't stand to live in Houston's outer suburbs, nor in central London, but there's plenty of middle-way that lets people have their own cars plus be able to walk places plus catch public transport when they need it. Give each family of four a quarter-acre block and you've still got ten thousand people per square mile. But hey, different strokes et cetera. People who think Los Angeles should look more like Paris should go live in Paris instead of trying to turn Los Angeles into Paris. And vice versa.