4 ms·
I’m dubious about basic income because, having done the math on how much it would cost, there are certainly better ways to spend that much money. If we give ev
by philwelch 9y ago
I’m dubious about basic income because, having done the math on how much it would cost, there are certainly better ways to spend that much money.
If we give every American $1,000/mo basic income, that’s $12,000/yr times 300 million, or about 1.2 trillion per year. For that much money, we could fix all our infrastructure, build better subways in every American city, build a Loftstrom-style launch loop to keep space launch costs down, land on Mars, replace the entire military arsenal, invest billions into basic science, expand health coverage, and still have some money left over. Plus, building all of that shit will probably get the country to full employment, give people meaningful things to do with their lives, and we get a lot out of it.
Or we could just mail people checks so they can sit around at home playing video games.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI don't think actual universal basic income is ever going to happen, in part because of the cost. The reality is that most people envision it as a replacement for welfare, not genuinely a check for everyone, including Bill Gates and other ultra rich citizens. I think the biggest problem is that it amounts to squandering wealth, not creating more. It envisions most ordinary people as mere consumers. It's a little like saying "Our body would be healthier if we made sure to adequately feed the leeches." Yeah, no. We need to not actively turn people into leeches. We need to stop treating them like they can't do anything but consume. It is a terrible way to treat people and it creates a very unhealthy and unsustainable system.
- luk32 9y ago> It envisions most ordinary people as mere consumers. It's a little like saying "Our body would be healthier if we made sure to adequately feed the leeches." > Yeah, no. > We need to not actively turn people into leeches. We need to stop treating them like they can't do anything but consume. It is a terrible way to treat people and it creates a very unhealthy and unsustainable system. What the heck are you talking about... If it's universal, then everybody gets it. How can anyone be a leech? And if you think some people consume more than they produce it's the same problem as with any other welfare. I don't see a problem with UBI being a replacement for welfare to some extent. Giving people dedicated restricted help is like treating them like incapable of decision making. Give them money and let them buy food themselves. What's the difference between a food stamp and food money? Pardon my ignorance. Regarding creating new leeches, about every experiment with this shows that on average by great margin it activises people. So this in practice shows the exact opposite of what you say. People usually feel empowered and regained control over their lives and try to do something with it. I am not a real proponent of universal basic income, the results seem too good. Maybe not being used to, and suddenly being given cold cash under monitor has this effect. Nevertheless, in my opinion your logic is completely reversed to what is being published.
- mobilefriendly 9y agoYour math is wrong, such a program would cost $3.6 trillion per year
- philwelch 9y agoEven furthering my point! An entire Mars program could be done for a tenth of that!
- T2_t2 9y agoThat's not really the cost. The cost is $12,000 * 300 million minus income taxes raised. Most plans have a slight increase in personal income tax attached, that leads to a breakeven at around $36K -> $40K. And the comparative cost in the budget is the cost of the program minus all existing welfare programs this replaces. $1,145 billion was the guesstimate for welfare, so for the USA at $3.5 trillion, it would be a cost of $2 trillion. I wonder too if there aren't more cuts than just welfare that can be made as a flow on of this. The proposal I saw from a conservative economist was $13K, with $3k reserved for healthcare. That would replace a lot of the medical schemes that exist, which many states likely pay for as well. Still, it is gonna be hella expensive for the first country that does it at scale.
- philwelch 9y agoYou could raise income taxes regardless, though. And I don’t know how much welfare you would be able to eliminate, since the bulk of those costs are Medicare (which you would have to maintain) and Social Security (which you would also have to maintain but might offset UBI). Regardless, you’re still introducing a large amount of net new spending—an amount that could be productively invested in infrastructure, research, and other productive projects.
- ataturk 9y agoYou're just looking at numbers--that's a mistake. The real "cost" is in the unmeasurable factors of how such a policy would change social behavior. For example, if I'm guaranteed $1K/month, I could take that and, using the other passive income I have, quit my job and never work again. I'm 44, it would be a dream come true. Part of me says "bring it on" but the adult part of me realizes that you can't run a nation where everyone wants to retire early and produce nothing or next to nothing. I reminds me of Firefly and planet Miranda where everyone was drugged for "their own good" but they all just laid down and died!