3 ms·
I completely agree with your assessment. Further, this last election cycle changed my metaphor, from Right vs Left to the No Caucus vs the Yes Caucus. To your
by specialist 9y ago
I completely agree with your assessment.
Further, this last election cycle changed my metaphor, from Right vs Left to the No Caucus vs the Yes Caucus.
To your point about consensus.
Our local hot button issues this cycle were (are) affordable housing and homelessness. We interviewed ~40 candidates. Frankly, I was shocked by the discord, disagreement on "the left" about how to address these issues. I was further shocked by the stubborn opposition the simple obvious fixes (build more housing, so supply meets demand). And the opponents couldn't be cleanly divided into conservative vs liberal. One candidate has solid left wing bonafides (champion for LBGTQ) but was vehemently NIMBY. Our endorsement committee was gobsmacked.
After much pondering, I've decided that for any given issue, even when the majority are Yes (recognize that there is a problem and conclude some kind of change is warranted), there's no consensus. Therefore, the No Caucus (defenders of the status quo, whatever the reason) usually wins. The exception is Stephen Jay Gould style punctuated equilibrium, when the Yes caucus temporarily coalesces around a plan and overrides the No Caucus.
In short, the Yes Caucus is temporary, fragile. Whereas the No Caucus is durable.
Which at least partially explains why the regressives (today's GOP) is able to punch above its weight. And why that will always be true.
Now the question is what to do about that reality. For me, it means placing more emphasis on issue-based organizing and policy work, vs campaigns.
- rdtsc 9y agoI like your No Caucus vs the Yes Caucus idea. Interesting to think about. Had to look up Gould's punctuated equilibrium to understand it better. I read "Bully for Brontosaurus" by Gould, that's where I heard the term first but then forgotten its meaning. Leaving a link here for others: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punctuated_equilibrium https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punctuated_equilibrium