3 ms·
Was this a closed system? As in: the money was taken from richer members of the community and given to poorer members? Or was the money brought in from the outs
by exabrial 9y ago
Was this a closed system? As in: the money was taken from richer members of the community and given to poorer members? Or was the money brought in from the outside?
- juicyfroot 9y agoThis.
- neilwilson 9y agoIt's not the money that is brought in from the outside. It is the stuff. In any ubi system you will find a set of people who don't get paid but who produce the stuff for the money. That's the slave class you need to make it work.
- Matumio 9y agoThe U of UBI stands for universal. If this "slave class" gets the same UBI, then they are not slaves. (At least not to the people who have no income in addition to UBI. They may be doing work for them, but they could easily stop and be no worse off than their "owners".)
- dragonwriter 9y ago> The U of UBI stands for universal. “Unconditional”, usually.
- AdrianB1 9y agoOpen system.
- SubiculumCode 9y agoThe largest complaint against basic income or government social programs generally is that most people will not use the income productively, and that it would lead to increases in vice and decreases in productivity. This, not being a closed system, does mean that the local economies are getting outside money injected into circulation, but it is a stretch to think that people would act differently (i.e. become less productive) in a closed system. In terms of rights or wrongs of income redistribution, I'd note that a lot of laws (laws that allow rentiers) and taxes (corporate tax cuts) are designed to redistribute wealth upwards too.
- AdrianB1 9y agoCan you explain how corporate tax cuts redistribute wealth upwards? Such a redistribution would imply that someone is paying taxes and some wealthy guys would receive those money, which does not happen anywhere, at any time.
- SubiculumCode 9y agoWell usually when building these kind of tax structures, governments think on how much "revenue" they want to generate, and who to tax to get it. If lowering the taxes for one guy, another guy gets to pay more in taxes.
- exabrial 9y agoSo, that's a long way of saying no, not a closed system, but an artificial economy