3 ms·
There are many Stack sites. Stack Overflow with its 6k questions/day has (by necessity) a different moderation approach than Computer Science.SE that has 16 que
by shagie 9y ago
There are many Stack sites. Stack Overflow with its 6k questions/day has (by necessity) a different moderation approach than Computer Science.SE that has 16 questions/day.
That difference of several orders of magnitude in incoming questions results in very different moderation approaches. You can spend 15 minutes reading every new question and answer every day compared to trying to filter the 90% of crap that gets posted on SO in a few seconds. This means that new users can be given more guidance in crafting a question and getting answers... though again that depends on a user putting the time and effort into writing the question and making sure they understand the scope of the site first.
Each site has a different set of users who are using the moderation tools to make the site into the one they want to see. The highest rep user on CS.SE has substantial rep on CS, Math, Theoretical CS, MathOverflow, and TeX (not Stack Overflow). The next highest has rep on CS, Information Security, Cryptography and Theoretical CS (again, not Stack Overflow). The next highest is CS, Theoretical CS, TeX and then 2.7k (not even enough for a close vote) on SO. Followed by a user who has CS, Academia, Aviation, Travel, and English Language Learners (not SO). This is a different community with different goals - in particular, this one is about the mathematical underpinnings of computer science... and that shows in its user base.
- gbacon 9y agoThe different sites have different personalities as well. The main SO can be brutal just because the herd responses can be so swift. Niche categories tend to be friendlier, Aviation.SE for example. Gaming, Movies, and Sci-Fi all seem really friendly for the fairly large volume they see. I have heard that chicken farmers have to monitor young chicks carefully for injuries that produce bleeding because when the other chicks spot one, they will relentlessly peck, which is likely to quickly kill the bleeder. Regardless of whether this is true, it’s a decent model for how drawing a bad initial response to a question can be fatal as the other chicks pile on. I once made the mistake of asking on Workplace.SE whether the HR profession had empirical support — as opposed to the usual conflicting folk wisdom — for whether including personal interests on a resume is helpful[0]. An early answer clearly failed to comprehend the question at a basic level, but it nonetheless was the initial spot of blood. Comments from multiple moderators saying the question was reasonable were not enough to stave off the pecking. [0]: https://workplace.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4888/question-asks-for-fact-based-resume-strategies-supported-by-the-literature-put https://workplace.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4888/ques...
- shagie 9y agoAviation gets 9.2 questions/day. Arqade gets 23. Movies gets 16. SciFi gets 31. Combined that is 80 questions/day. About 1/4th of what the Java tag on Stack Overflow has gotten today. You've got a higher percent of users who are more willing to invest the time necessary to help new users and a larger body of "good questions" that serve as examples. Niche categories tend to be friendlier because you will see the same people more often and and have interactions with them more frequently. The vast majority of users on Stack Overflow ask a question (toss a bunch of text in a text area) and disappear. Pulling up the front page, you get questions where the entirety of the body of the question is: > "i need to scan part of page by ImageEn in delphi for faster scanning like window7 paint scanner dialog! (screenshot)" ( https://stackoverflow.com/q/48050760 https://stackoverflow.com/q/48050760 ) and > "Hi I have the promblam the I want to sent with volley post a string to my php script on a server and get a Jsonarray. But I search a long time but didnt get an answer. Can sombody help me with that." ( https://stackoverflow.com/q/48050744 https://stackoverflow.com/q/48050744 ) And remember that every minute there are 10 new questions asking for help in a similar fashion. When there are 10 questions a day, people can spend 1/10th of the time they're going to spend on moderation on the site commenting, editing, and helping every question. Lets say that's 6 minutes. Where there are 6k questions/day, or several hundred in the preferred language tag/day - you (and other people) making judgement calls on the order of seconds. Down vote and move to the next? Comment about how to improve? It is very difficult to spend sufficient time to get people to update their question for it to be helpful. When I participated, I was hesitant to spend any more time doing community moderation than was evidenced by the person drafting the question. If they spent 10 seconds writing it, I'll spend 5 seconds reading it and 5 seconds voting on it. If they spent 10 minutes writing it, crafting a MVCE and getting the punctuation and grammar correct... I'll spend 10 minutes working with them trying to get it into the best question it could be. But if I'm only going to spend an hour... that's 1/6th of my time budget. It works when there's only a dozen questions/day but fails miserably when there are a few hundred.
- mcguire 9y agohttps://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/251758/why-is-stack-overflow-so-negative-of-late https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/251758/why-is-stack...