7 ms·
Show your work: The new terms for trust in journalism
- hugo0384729109 9y agoNot sure I agree with the general premise that what the vast majority of consumers of journalism want is proven transparency versus reinforcement of what they already agree with and tribalism. The article seems to completely ignore many real world factors of human psychology present in people’s relationship to consuming news as well as the complex financial forces involved, or propagandist motivations of some state controlled media. Also doesn’t account for news sources shifting dramatically to being mediated by social media gatekeepers rather than direct relations between publisher and consumer so it doesn’t account for pervasive filtering and how well researched and transparent journalism is pushed out for tribalist click bait anyway. Nice utopian vision but too far removed from key real world factors to be practical I think.
- CM30 9y agoThese points are valid, though I feel what's more dangerous than social media filters reinforcing existing beliefs is those sites and their algorithms putting such a high focus on speed rather than quality. Face it, doing a lot of careful research and producing a well written article does worse in a lot of cases than just kicking crap stories out the door as quickly as possible to show 'consistency' and ride hype trains. The technical setup meant to provide 'relevant' content seconds after something happens discourages anything more thoughtful by design.
- hugo0384729109 9y agoAgreed. I think fast food vs eating healthy is a good comparison. The message in this type or article strikes me as sugesting better labeling for healthy food assuming that’s what people want while discounting the fact that fast food is cheap and easy and people buy it most often to satisfy a subjective feeling of hunger (while they have a ton of other stuff to focus on) rather than treating each meal as an objective assessment. A lot of articles with suggestions posted here (HN) for making “things” better often focus on the mechanics of the thing and technical or procedural changes but a lot of the time ignore the reality of human behaviour and motivations. I think that relates to engineering/programming culture and focus on STEM with a lot less value placed on humanities which is then reflected in products and opinion pieces and people being frustrated that things can’t just be “fixed” through clever changes to objective mechanics and approach. That’s drifting into other bigger topics but it’s a frustrating trend.
- harlanji 9y agoI wholeheartedly agree that focusing on lower level mechanics is the way to solutions and am at times frustrated by their dismissal in preference for some higher level debate across a seemingly arbitrary division. In my case health debate terms are basically down to gut flora and conditions that cause me to crave french fries. Well, I don't crave french fries anymore (or meat, and decreasingly dairy except the Super burritos :). I've had this particular OP debate about journalism with a coworker, that maybe such a publication doesn't need mass appeal if the thought leaders would be willing to pay more for it. I throw money at thought leaders whenever I can, eg. "this album on Soundcloud is good, I'll send a dollar per track. CRAP it's 25 tracks..." and still send it all. (in retrospect, they must know people behave like this... or at least, I do now :). BUT... if it weren't authentic work, I wouldn't get that impulse, so it's not really a secret that can be exploited. It's not the most popular thinking mode. Put the body into a healthy state, and it will crave healthy things. Like math class or starting strength training, you might just have to endure it for a little bit. But to myself, perhaps many, salad was iceberg lettuce and veganism was boca burgers. Couldn't be farther from the truth, in reality. There's even bigger money in some food industry sectors than green/vegan, I wonder who might have incentive to say being healthy is sooo expensive when the alternative is lots of their own products.
- mike_hearn 9y agoI'd very much like to find a news outlet that takes a STEM and systems oriented approach to news gathering, but as far as I'm aware no such thing exists. In my view the humanities oriented population has certainly failed to produce trustworthy news, or at least, failed to do so reliably over the long term. I attribute this to lack of systems designed to recognise that journalists have power, power corrupts and therefore journalists should expect themselves and others to become corrupted with time. News organisations seem to have little or nothing in the way of systems designed to keep them in check. Fact checkers? No, never encountered any sign of them. And I would have done given that in the past I've been a go-to source for major news outlets on a technical topic. References to primary sources? Journalists are by and large allergic to links, although I've noticed that the more modern the news source, the more linky they tend to be. When they use links they typically link only to their own coverage; presumably they value hits and ad views more than making it easy for people to double check their work. Systematising how stories are selected and publishing that system? No. Making it easy to follow a story and discover if previous stories were retracted? No. Stories are sometimes updated post publication to reflect that they were wrong, but such retractions are never publicised anywhere and short of manually polling previously visited URLs you can't find out that this has happened. Unfortunately I believe that the lack of action taken to increase trust by the mainstream news outlets is deliberate. Journalism doesn't pay well, journalism thus attracts people for whom power is a part of the compensation package. Namely the power to influence the direction of society in ways more to their liking. I frequently encounter journalism in big league western outlets that is flatly misleading or fraudulent in ways that can only be deliberate. It has reached the point where I maintain a mental blacklist of topics, on which I automatically assume anything I read in the media is a lie designed to manipulate me (current number 1 position: anything Russia related, but there are others). It's for this reason that I don't believe that existing mainstream media publications will ever be able to increase trust in themselves - being untrustworthy is literally a part of the job appeal. It will take a new generation of companies built along entirely different values, with different business models and which select their writers from different parts of the population (probably that means no 'professional' full time journalists, just lots of part time specialised writers).
- CM30 9y agoFor all the talk about transparency, there's not much about actually providing a source for your claims. That's something a lot of media outlets are failing at, with both offline sources and online often lacking proper source links or references and those that do have them preferring to link to secondary and tertiary sources rather than the original. Still, transparency is getting better, and both source links and the other things mentioned in the article (like claims for comment, disclosing financial ties/free products, and talks about what they know/don't know) are becoming more common now.
- aalleavitch 9y agoA problem with this is regarding anonymous sources, in which it's often necessary to protect the identity of the source. Perhaps some sort of verification network, in which one news outlet is randomly assigned another outlet who must also independently verify the anonymous source?
- CM30 9y agoTrue, never thought about anonymous sources. In that case, some sort of verification network could work okay, though it's always going to be tradeoffs regardless of what route is taken. However, there's no excuse for stories based on public sources not to link to or provide a reference for those sources. If your source is another news site, blog, wiki page, forum post, video, etc... then you should damn well be linking to the original. Doing otherwise is like taking ownership of someone else's work, especially if you do what some sleazy sites do and rehost the original work as well.
- TheAceOfHearts 9y agoThis is one of my biggest complaints with online articles. If you mention a new research paper making a wild claim, why not share the publication info? By omitting the source, they make it harder for people to verify the veracity of their claims. There's going to be cases where it's not feasible to provide all sources, but they could still make an effort. It doesn't have to be all-or-nothing.
- horsecaptin 9y agoJournalism by peer review and open access and open data.
- jancsika 9y agoOne cost would be that this would make a special case out of investigation journalism, where the journalists often cannot reveal their sources. Especially in cases where retribution against the source could end in death. Since that is probably the most important and consequential type of journalism, I'd expect facile attacks claiming investigative journalism "isn't transparent" if this takes off. The obvious and easy protection against such an attack is to critically read multiple sources and be familiar with journalists' track records over time. So I'm afraid we don't have workable protections against this attack atm. :)
- ams6110 9y agoDon't anonymous sources need to be confirmed independently? Otherwise it's just somebody making a claim.
- aalleavitch 9y agoAs I was suggesting in another post, perhaps there could be some sort of system for peer review of anonymous sources? So when news outlet A wants to use an anonymous source, they request a reviewer who'll be randomly assigned from another news outlet B, then this person will independently verify the anonymous source and give their approval. Just spitballing here.
- mtgx 9y agoLearn from the dark market vendors, in other words.
- Spivak 9y agoWhy would they need to claim it? The way you've set it up it's vacuously true. The difference between Pizzagate and investigative journalism as you've defined it is reputation. And when trust in the press is lost what separates the curds and the whey is evidence which a fabricated story cannot provide. The protection you offer even in the ideal case is worthless when there isn't trust that a journalist will bend to political pressure, financial incentives, threats, or to push their own or their publisher's agenda. Saying that people need to "crtitically read" is just intellectual grandstanding.
- ThomPete 9y agoJournalisms biggest Achilles Heel is its insistence on the concept of quality journalism and the idea that normal people care and especially care enough to pay for it. Let's not forget that fundamentally, journalism is little more than verified gossip (Have you heard that the UN Secretary is involved in a scandal) and its primary value is not in how it's written but the revelation of the piece of information in itself. Sure we have investigative journalism, but most people aren't going to pay for that. So at the end of the day, the only people who really care about journalism are journalists themselves. The biggest change in journalism IMO is that it's finally become clear that the postmodernist was correct. Context and perspective define truth. And so all transparency in journalism will ever do is attract the people who already agree with the context and perspective of the individual journalist as loyal readers. Helping journalism it wont.
- aalleavitch 9y agoWe generally perceive peer-reviewed science as being capable of approaching objectivity. Why can this not be true for the reporting of events as they occur as well?
- ams6110 9y agoPeer-reviewed science is targeted at other scientists. Journalism is targeted at the general public, who (accepting the premise of the GP) don't care.
- colatkinson 9y agoThe goal of science is for experiments to be repeatable. If I were to build a copy of the LHC under my house, presumably I would be able to verify any of CERN's results. But I can't verify anything in journalism. If two reporters watched something happen and their accounts differ, who is right? No one knows, and both will be accused of bias.
- maxerickson 9y agoIs water wet? Maybe! The point being that there are plenty of journalistic enterprises that are not especially sensitive to bias.
- loteck 9y agoIt's a new model of journalism in search of a rare breed of news consumer: one who cares to read reporters' profiles, source documents, and descriptions of how reports are gathered. Lofty goal, to say the least.
- kybernetikos 9y agoI'd love to see more linking to primary sources in news stories. Academic writing normally has lots of references that allow you to follow things for yourself. It's understandable that newspapers wouldn't want their stories to be 30% references, and it seems that many major news sources write their online stories in the same way they would write newspaper stories, but on the internet it's actually quite possible to provide all kinds of extra detail, such as notes from the fact checkers, external references that corroborate or contest, relevant reference material, documents, perhaps even links to summaries of digested information where it wouldn't be ok to publish the raw details. On the web, stories can still be quick and easy to read for those that want that, while providing a huge wealth of information for those that want more background or a better understanding of where a story came from. I like the slogan 'show your working', I just think that it can be done in an even more radical way online than even this article suggests (and might also make people more prepared to pay for the work, when they can see what they're getting for their money).
- jawns 9y agoFormer news editor here. When I was working for a daily metro paper, we had toyed around with ways to expose some of this "show your work" information as metadata in the online editions. Sort of like EXIF data for a photo, but for a news story. If a story mentioned an event at a particular location, the metadata might include coordinates for that location. The benefit of the metadata approach is that it's much more easily consumable by machines, but we can still use it ourselves on the frontend (e.g. show a map of the location). Google tried getting publishers to do the same thing, but I think it eventually realized that they weren't going to get buy-in if it meant reporters and editors had to do the extra work of compiling the metadata, so they decided to just automate everything and use natural language processing to extract the metadata.
- ShabbosGoy 9y agoWould a project like Po.et work for establishing “trust” in content. I use that term loosely, because trust means different things in different contexts. For example can you trust the movie you downloaded was licensed?
- hellbanner 9y agoGood writeup and I agree with the sentiment that news sources need to disclosure their sources & biases. However, we are entering into a strange age where information can be fabricated so well that we won't be able to reliably trust any information on a screen, especially as the timestamp exceeds what a Desktop computer would take to generate such data. On AI Generated fake porn - video editing with face swapping. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16040463 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16040463 https://medium.com/@samim/obama-rnn-machine-generated-political-speeches-c8abd18a2ea0 https://medium.com/@samim/obama-rnn-machine-generated-politi... -- Audio & Visual imitation of Obama according to a script. http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-37899902 http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-37899902 - Adobe Voco 'Photoshop-for-voice' causes concern Now tell me, why should I trust anything on this screen? I shouldn't and I won't.