7 ms·
Tiny, weird online communities made a comeback in 2017
- sago 9y agoI am a member of three (admittedly weird) niche communities. These have been orders of magnitude more impactful in my life than Facebook. The friends I met there have become real-life friends. We've flown around the world to visit each other, we've laughed and cried, we send each other quirky gifts, and cheer on each other's kids. These are the only close new friends I've made in the last 10 years. Two of those communities are based around subreddits, the other a 90s era web forum. The thing that makes them work where Facebook groups simply don't, I think, is pseudonymity. One of those groups has been particularly powerful, and it is a group that inherently involves being mutually vulnerable, so I certainly would never have joined under my real name, and I enjoy being part of the community even though only a handful of people know my IRL identity. Reddit has some big problems, but is the best platform I have found so far for these niche communities. And my experience totally chimes with this article: big social media is as shallow as a puddle. Small niches are where real communities form.
- dorfsmay 9y agoI agree with your last paragraph, and IMO the reason is reddit is based on common interests, like Usenet used to be, while Facebook is based on random ways you met people in life and twitter is based on people trying to boost their ego.
- LV-426 9y agoI agree about Reddit being Usenet-like. Unfortunately it's a really horrible version of Usenet, partly thanks to the number of unpleasant people who use it, but also due to the karma system - in theory a way to collectively highlight good posts, but in reality often simply becoming an end in itself (karma whoring, playing to a gallery) and a weapon (people burying legit posts they simply don't like/agree with). On Usenet you could filter anything you didn't want to see, which is reasonable, but you could not - as on Reddit, or HN - make it more difficult for other people to read it too, which is not reasonable, and simply helps to create a hostile, cliquey, poisonous echo chamber. Cliques did exist on newsgroups, but they had less tools at their disposal. In fact one of the reasons people left Usenet for inferior moderated web forums is because while they could (quite rightly) control their own experience, they (quite rightly) had no ability to control the group. Ironically, although Usenet is considered to be dead these days, it's in some ways in better shape than ever. 20 years ago it suffered from its popularity, under attack from spammers and trolls attempting and often succeeding in destroying newsgroups. These days it probably has more users than it had before the mid 90s internet explosion, whereas spammers and trolls have largely moved on to bigger audiences elsewhere. It's strange for me to read people talking nostalgically about how the internet was better in the past, about online forums they were a part of 15 years ago, or Reddit or 4chan, and seemingly have no experience or even knowledge of Usenet. And that something as similar and simple to use as email is ignored by people who rue the loss of old (web) forums. Unlike web options Usenet is no-nonsense, free, has no admin headaches, no advertising, no Evil Corp owner (or potential sell out to Evil Corp when the community grows enough), it's anonymous, private and allows unrestricted speech (within applicable law, obviously). All it requires is for people to use it.
- etherealG 9y agoI agree about usenet, but must admit it’s not very accessible to people unfamiliar with it. I think a good web interface would go a long way to helping adoption. Perhaps one exists and I’m just not aware.
- LV-426 9y agoThe company providing the world's most popular email web interface should have been the prime candidate to provide web Usenet, but instead they saw Usenet only as a means to get people on to their own terrible Google-only groups (while producing such a monumental amount of spam, trolling and abuse to Usenet, many people to leave altogether). A better idea than a web interface IMO is Usenet access simply built into a browser by default. It makes sense to have Usenet in an email client, because they are closely related, but not many people use email clients any more, so not many people are going to find Usenet that way. If Firefox had an option to open newsgroups, with proper filtering (not just on the overhead headers, but on the HEAD of each message), I would use it all the time, and I believe many thousands of other people would too.
- kakarot 9y ago> If Firefox had an option to open newsgroups One part of me believes this would be the best native addon coming from Mozilla in years. The other part of me worries it would bring on a new age of Eternal September to Usenet, which has been isolated long enough again to form a particular kind of culture that would seem fragile in the face of sudden mass immigration given the size of the Usenet community today.
- ghaff 9y agoGoogle makes some IMO very weird decisions about seemingly low effort/cost offerings, even if a bit niche, that would seem to be very complementary to products/services that it does put its full weight behind. Dropping Reader didn't make a lot of sense to me for this reason. The lukewarm support for Scholar is another.
- pzone 9y agoYou really hit the nail on the head describing the uses of these sites, lol
- stinos 9y agoTwo other reasons Facebook really doesn't work, at least for me: a) the UI is not that of a proper forum or chat (small amount of characters per row, lack of controls for embedding content including quoting, content burried in between a ton of no-related content, etc). Actually, in my opinion the UI is abysmal when it comes to conveying information which is more than a picture of video or few words. b) when you're not in a closed group there's virtually an unlimited amount of people you don't even know who ca chime in and want to present their idea (which is almost like you're trying to have a serious discussion in real life and there's constantly a bunch of drunken people interrupting you st start spitting out whatever is on their mind). It just does not work for me for having proper discussions (it does have a ton of other features which do work great, but not that). Reddit is sort of ok, if you find the right community. And many of the forums I already visited before there even was a Reddit or Facebook stil exist nowadays and some of them are even more alive than all those years ago. Most of them are specific (eg. one sport, one music style), the general ones are mostly gone.
- maneesh 9y agoI believe that Facebook Groups are one of the most powerful features of FB, but I agree that the UI is limiting and the admin controls are lacking. Have you found any online communities with excellent interfaces? Ideally open-source?
- nsomaru 9y agoI've been testing Discourse out and it seems pretty cool. Really fast UI too.
- supergreg 9y agoIf you are looking for open source, I think Discourse is the best out there. We tried to move a community from an old phpbb forum to a newer software some years ago and checked several projects and most projects are either unmaintained or old (with old style PHP programming) or new but lack features we needed. We ended up using NodeBB because the person who was going to maintain it was more comfortable with Javascript than Ruby.
- 9y ago
- taurath 9y agoI agree with this despite probably talking about different communities. It is night and day different than communities based around school and childhood.
- Filligree 9y agoDitto. I wonder if anyone else here spends time on Sufficient Velocity? It's an unusual place in many ways, not least for having been built by an idealistic (but pragmatic) lawyer who's been using it for, hmm, nation building?
- Crontab 9y agoBeing able to find and converse with people who share my niche interests is one of my favorite things about the Internet. It was depressing to be interested in something and having no one to talk to about it.
- pokemongoaway 9y agoSounds cool. Can you mention the 3 communities?
- xor1 9y agoI'm the opposite of this. I spent most of my life up to my mid-20s on internet communities -- first Usenet as a child (8 years old), then SA, then Reddit/4chan. I mostly read Reddit and HN now, but do not read and post compulsively like I did previously. I would easily clear 200+ posts a day on SA and 4chan. There's also the different pockets of people that I met through gaming. It's been hard, but I've finally broken away from relying on the internet for friends and community. 2017 was the first year that I can remember where I spent more time with RL friends than internet friends.
- heedlessly2 9y agoPeople are too busy "playing boring politcian" on Facebook. But Reddit allows you to geek about certain topics without getting judged. If i make 50+ posts on FB about my favorite tv show on Facebook, i get called "obsessed" or get defriended
- kindfellow92 9y ago“Weird” Actually niche online communities aren’t weird. Just because a topic isn’t repeated over and over again on big media doesn’t mean it’s weird. Big media doesn’t dictate what is normal.
- nils-m-holm 9y ago> Big media doesn’t dictate what is normal. Actually, it does. Unfortunately! :(
- throwanem 9y agoWhat's wrong with "weird"? It means: fateful, uncanny, magical. It's never properly been an insult, and those who misbelieve otherwise and deploy it in a pejorative fashion accidentally do that which they so label a favor by avoiding it - nothing ruins a small, special space like an influx of people who neither understand nor care what makes it special.
- kindfellow92 9y agoNothing is wrong with it, it’s just subjective. Being subjective is usually not the domain of journalism (outside of op-eds).
- Spearchucker 9y ago2017 was the year in which I pruned my Facebook friends down from ~350 to 46. It was also the year in which I solidified friendships IRL that started in 1:10 scale truck modelling forums in Canada, the UK and Germany. I still check Facebook daily, but it's now down to once a day when I get up, rather than 100's of times a day. I only check in on Twitter once every couple of weeks or so, when I'm bored. For me this trend seems to be... a trend. One of my plans for this year is to build Clone Trooper armour, which will probably open up new friendships in the cosplayer world. So I, as a single datapoint, love the trend. It's how I meet people who are absolutely, completely commited to the same things I am.
- exergy 9y agoSounds like a great direction to be moving towards. Much more grip on your social media, and you using it rather than the other way around.
- dzhiurgis 9y agoThis was the year I started to frequent 4chan and derrivate groups on Facebook (birbs for nice frens). Unfortunately, many of those groups got zucc’d and people who used fake accounts there - bannned from Facebook. Reddit has gotten a bit likie mainstream Facebook lately - too normal, full of fake news, emotional and full of SJW’s. Not that I am against it, but I come there to be entertained, not informed (this is what HN is for). Also, it’s mobile version push seems to be a new way to declare war against it’s users. What’s most ironic about real name policy on Facebook is that people are often plain rude, racist, etc using their real names.
- aceofspad3s 9y agoThe default subs of reddit are utter garbage, but the rest of stuff is not that bad.
- dzhiurgis 9y agoI agree. Anything you can recommend aside from programmerHumor?
- petepete 9y agoReally depends on your interests. I frequent several programming language/platform specific and photography subs, plus r/mechanicalkeyboards, and several from my local area. Reddit's multisub feature makes grouping them easy (so I visit six places instead of 40).
- qrbLPHiKpiux 9y ago/r/netsec
- exergy 9y agoThe ones I frequent include financialindependence, headphones, coffee, mealprepsunday, running, bicycling. They all tend to cater to their audience fairly well.
- 0xcde4c3db 9y ago
- pmlnr 9y agoI thought the article would be about something like the rise of SSBC, maybe a reprise of diaspora*, and I wish this was true - but in reality most of these are still groups within the larger systems, let that be instagram or tumblr.
- htormey 9y agoThis article is very anecdotal and it doesn’t talk about the underlying reasons for why niche communities are making a big comeback. It mentions that Patreon has risen in popularity but doesn’t talk about the YouTube adpoocalypse or the reasons why that occurred. The adpocalypse and it’s impact on everything from news commentary to comedy channels is one of the biggest factors driving creators and hence users onto YouTube alternatives. It doesn’t talk about said Youtube alternatives such as minds, steemit etc or why vidme shut down. It doesn’t talk about their differences or why one is better than the other. It doesn’t talk about the economics of video hosting or how sustainable these platforms are. It mentions the alt right but it doesn’t talk about twitter giving tons of those guys the boot or the rise of gab. It mentions the alt right & Patreon but it doesn’t talk about how many of those people and other right wingers got booted off of that platform. It doesn’t talk about the cottage industry of Patreon alternatives that sprung up to cater to those people. It also doesn’t mention mastodon or anything that’s going on with similar technologies. It doesn’t mention why mastodon got big in Japan or talk about any similar niche services. It also doesn’t talk about the possibility of advertising on twitter/Facebook/google being regulated by the USA/EU. It doesn’t talk about the testimony all three companies gave in front of congress nor its implications for the future of niche communities. In summary this article provides neither a survey of the niche community landscape nor an explanation for why 2017 was the year niche communities made a comeback.
- hudibras 9y agoEvery article doesn't have to mention every thing.
- 1337biz 9y agoWould you mind writing some answers to those questions? I would love to read these a lot more than the author's weak attempt to force politics on an otherwise really interesting topic.
- htormey 9y agoSure. I had been waiting for someone else to do this as it seems very obvious to me. In the above comment I didn’t even get into the big war that’s looming between Facebook, YouTube and Snapchat for video ad revenue. I also didn’t talk about how crypto currency factors into all of this either. I think 2018 is going to see some pretty big shifts in the online media landscape.
- zitterbewegung 9y agoWeird communities never disappeared they just got overshadowed by the rest of the social networking place. It’s like saying everyone goes to wal mart and home depo .
- y_tho 9y agoI would say your analogy applies, but in a different way: walmart and home depot arrived and mom&pop hardware and general stores didn't all disappear, but their numbers did diminish. Where 8 minimarkets were open, half may have closed (YMMV).
- kakarot 9y ago2017 was the year I left Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, Twitter, etc. Nuked my old reddit account and came back to a fresh start with only a few niche subreddits and of course HN. I don't even frequent 4chan as much because it's losing its ground as a first-party source of internet subculture and information dissemination I've significantly cut out the time spent engaging in communities that don't give me anything in return, and while it makes it very hard to date other people in my generation and at times fills me with a lonely sense of disconnection from society, I feel so much healthier.
- deadmetheny 9y ago>I don't even frequent 4chan as much because it's losing its ground as a first-party source of internet subculture and information dissemination Like it or not, /pol/ is exactly that for the alt-right. It's also started to seep out into the other boards, which is something of a problem to be solved.
- kakarot 9y ago> It's also started to seep out into the other boards, which is something of a problem to be solved Pretty much why I left. /pol/ is good to follow during important events like elections but in general the toxicity is unbearable... and the rest of 4chan culture has been suffering lately as well.
- jrcii 9y agoLike lobste.rs, way better than HN with the wacko-fascist mods on this website that force their political views on the users.
- krapp 9y agoI hope one of the effects of this movement away from mass social media is a resurgence in self-hosted content and forum software.
- kris-s 9y agoI've been thinking about this sort of thing a lot lately and I even briefly made an experimental message board that limited the amount of posts the users could make. The idea was that it would slow down the pace of the board and encourage more people to post. The idea never really took off, almost entirely due to marketing - I have no idea how to promote such a thing. The site is currently down but if anyone has ideas how to regularly promote it (and maybe keep out jerks who post bad things) I'd love some ideas.
- bencoder 9y agoI'm a member of several 'weird' communities on discord. It feels like the old internet I loved of irc + forums, with voice and video chat bringing it into my modern times
- yakitori 9y agoRather than the size of the community, I'd really prefer if we had more distributed and decentralized communities. The pendulum has swung markedly from distributed to centralized communities in the last decade. Would be nice if it finally swung back somewhat in the other direction. I'm feeling a bit nostalgic for the internet of the early 2000s.
- Noos 9y agoYes, I think VRchat is becoming one of those, with very high emphasis on the weird. Do you know the way, my bruddas?
- tareqak 9y agoTechmeme summary: Kaitlyn Tiffany / The Verge: Niche online communities and media grew in 2017, through Patreon, TinyLetter, “finstagrams”, and more as people looked for alternatives to Facebook and Twitter Could those who downvote this comment please explain why you did so? I try to provide extra context for those who come across this submission, which I get from Techmeme.