11 ms·
Terminal: How the airport came to embody our national psychosis
- jack9 9y agoThe intimation that the Trump travel bam, is somehow evidence of how airports embody a national psychosis is a silly jab. Throwing out absurd comparisons...what about the different classes of tickets at Disneyland? This article is devoid of intellect and filled with musings.
- throwanem 9y agoThe article is indeed of middling quality at best, and prone to malapropisms. The phenomenon it struggles to describe is real nonetheless.
- jack9 9y agoIs it US society or the US Federal government, which has been divested from the people?
- rhizome 9y agoWhat difference would an answer to that question make?
- jack9 9y agoWhat is confusing about it? It is an attempt to hear any assertion about how the people support the process rather than the process (the tsa or travel ban) being PRIMARILY about us govt self serving, regardless of the citizen interests. Sheesh
- rhizome 9y agoThe US airline industry was effectively nationalized on 9/11, so no, society didn't push for this, if that's what you're asking.
- noonespecial 9y agoBanning a whole class of people because some of them might do (or even have done) bad things is an extraordinarily dangerous idea that can cause some serious problems if it becomes considered fully acceptable. It's also a perfect example of where this "psychosis" is leading us and how its a much bigger problem than an extra hour at the airport spent playing pretend.
- verroq 9y agoYou don’t want them in America anyway because their religion is largely incompatible with western ideals and culture. Their treatment of women, lgbt groups, free speech, for example are conflict with a harmonious western society. People don’t hate them for believing in their religion, the problem is that they believe in a religion that openly calls for the death of cartoonists, gays and jews or anyone that insults it. If you are one religion that interferes with other people’s ability to practice their faith then that one religion is the problem.
- mLuby 9y ago>You don’t want them in America anyway because their religion is largely incompatible with western ideals and culture. Their treatment of women, lgbt groups, free speech, for example are conflict with a harmonious western society. You're talking about Christians, right?
- dang 9y agoResponding to a religious flamewar comment with another religious flamewar comment is exactly the wrong thing to do here, and will get your account banned as well—regardless of how wrong and provocative any other user was. Please read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and don't post like this again. If you do, you'll see that the guidelines say exactly what to do, and not to do, in cases like this.
- 549362-30499 9y agoMuslims, just like Christians, range from so-secular-they-don't-even-pray to fundamentalists eg Wahhabism. So regardless of the blatant unconstitutionality of such a law, it's also just laughably ignorant to suggest that all Muslims believe the same thing and have the same attitude about "western ideals and culture" (whatever that means).
- tempodox 9y agoAn apt commentary. The Home of the Brave is no more. It has become the Home of the Hysteric and the Paranoid, up to and including the POTUS.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- beamatronic 9y agoSome trace it back to Clinton. He would have gone after UBL but was distracted by the impeachment proceedings against him.
- mschuster91 9y agoI remember when flying as a little kid from Munich to London that little me was allowed to sit on the pilot's chair - I believe my parents even have a photo of it. Note, this was before 9/11.
- linkregister 9y agoI have seen a child sitting in the pilot's seat on a U.S. domestic flight while boarding a plane a few months ago. Before the plane is away from the gate, there is probably no restriction. Disallowing passengers access to the cockpit is likely the most meaningful post-9/11 change to preventing aircraft hijackings.
- tehwebguy 9y agoSure but no change was even required. Once the public realized the intent might be to use the plane as a bomb the attack vector became meaningless. No one will ever hand the plane over again, even if the attacker claims to have a bomb.
- erric 9y agoSecurity theater at its finest. The TSA is failing 90% of the security reviews for smuggling in weapons. How many of us would still have a job if we were failing that often?
- justinhj 9y agoIf your job is to prevent very rare events (the number of people willing or capable to take down a passenger jet is apparently very small) then I guess you could get away with it for a long time
- saas_co_de 9y agoThe irony is that if there were a terrorist looking to create a maximum loss-of-life event they would now only have to target the security screening line and wound't even have to bother with getting on the plane.
- ceejayoz 9y agoI've stood in a three hour TSA line at O'Hare and had this thought about half way through. Rather uncomfortable.
- AJ007 9y agoAm I the only one who finds vanishing leg room a larger disturbance than TSA lines? The big airport crybabies are usually those who expect weather or mechanical problems to vanish by voice command. Unless you fly Spirit, I've seen minimal problems with airline staff or TSA agents. Most are fairly friendly.. of course this may vary by airport. I usually fly in and out of the same handful.
- Zak 9y agoIt's not TSA agents that are the problem, but TSA policy. Unless you pay the TSA for precheck to abuse you less, the process is pretty invasive. To give just one example, in Europe, passengers are not routinely required to remove shoes.
- c22 9y agoLast time I flew in the US (3 weeks ago) I didn't have to remove my shoes. The security process was actually quite streamlined. The biggest indignity was provided by Alaska Airlines, where one self check kiosk had run out of receipt paper, causing a massive deluge of people to line up at the only human agent available. (Other kiosks claimed you were already checked in and couldn't reprint your boarding pass.) I, and I'm sure many others, alerted the agent to the problem, but she was too busy servicing the growing line of increasingly late passengers to do anything about the root cause. It wasn't even clear if replacing the tape was her responsibility.
- decebalus1 9y ago> Last time I flew in the US (3 weeks ago) I didn't have to remove my shoes. That means either someone was not following protocol, they were running an experiment or you were in business class. Shoes need to come off in standard screening (1). Such anecdotal evidence means nothing. I for one had to take off my shoes a month ago (a long with all other passengers) but I never had to remove my shoes when flying inside the EU. (1) https://www.tsa.gov/travel/travel-tips/travel-checklist https://www.tsa.gov/travel/travel-tips/travel-checklist
- burgerdev 9y agoA post about airport depression without a single reference to Douglas Adams? Welcome to 2018, I guess.
- throwanem 9y agoTeatime has many fewer fans than Hitchhiker's.
- justinhj 9y agoI thought of this quote while reading the article: It can hardly be a coincidence that no language on Earth has ever produced the expression "As pretty as an airport." Airports are ugly. Some are very ugly. Some attain a degree of ugliness that can only be the result of a special effort. This ugliness arises because airports are full of people who are tired, cross, and have just discovered that their luggage has landed in Murmansk (Murmansk airport is the only exception of this otherwise infallible rule), and architects have on the whole tried to reflect this in their designs.
- noobiemcfoob 9y agoMake a helpful comment by giving at least one reference to Douglas Adams to address the absence you're talking about (as your child posters have done)
- jballanc 9y agoI, too, have noticed the decline in airports. Both status and comfort are severely lacking from even the 1980s when, as a child, my family and I spent many a flight delay waiting for my father to return from a business trip. But something the article fails to mention: this seems to be a uniquely American phenomenon. The airports I've interacted with elsewhere in the world have been head-and-shoulders above anything in the US.
- GlennS 9y agoPersonally, Kona Airport in Hawaii is by far the nicest airport I've been to. In general I agree with you though.
- beamatronic 9y agoAgree 100% about Kona. Very casual feel. Be sure to check out the Onizuka Space Museum if you have kids.
- glandium 9y agoKona airport feels doesn't feel like an airport at all. That's why it's nice. But there aren't a lot of international flights getting there, which helps.
- Fnoord 9y ago> The airports I've interacted with elsewhere in the world have been head-and-shoulders above anything in the US. Which ones have that been, and when? The most hilarious things are the lithium ion conundrum. 1) People being required to hand over their mobile electronic devices, to have Customs logging in and 2) the thing where they were illegal to be carried in hand bagage forcing them to non-hand bagage where its arguably less safe. The other funny hysteria (for a non-NT) I remember is the liquid/water hysteria. But that one was active in EU as well! I feel like EU isn't that far behind US in these matters. However, I'm unsure if the VWP for US people coming to EU also asks whether the person was an enemy combatant in WWII. The questionnaires on the VWP are... peculiar, to say the least.
- 9y ago
- Girlang 9y agoHe mentions ‘racism’ several time and stratification but gives no examples. I don’t get it.
- dawhizkid 9y agoTravel hacks I live by: TSA Precheck/Global Entry (a must!), Amex Platinum Card/Priority Pass for Amex Centurion Lounge/airport lounge access, T-mobile for free unlimited international data/1 hour free Gogo in-flight WiFi, and usually co-branded credit card for airline I fly with for priority boarding and free checked bag when I need it. Side note: Pre-check is getting more popular and hear Clear might be even faster now.
- vinay427 9y agoFor those who are unaware, NEXUS is a cheaper and better alternative to Global Entry and PreCheck for those close to US/Canada border crossings.
- mmagin 9y agoIt's extra confusing how there are so many different programs :)
- Zak 9y agoSomething really rubs me the wrong way about paying the government to mistreat me less. It really seems to me like it was created to make sure that wealthy, and therefore politically influential travelers don't get too upset about the TSA and demand reform.
- dawhizkid 9y agoIt’s $100 for 5 years for both programs...I think anyone who can afford a plane ticket could afford this if they wanted to. If anything you’re agreeing to speedier service in exchange for reduced privacy through greater surveillance on your travels.
- Zak 9y agoYet most people don't. I don't think it's necessarily intended to discriminate by income, but I do think the intent is to avoid political pressure to back off on general screening procedures.
- makecheck 9y agoKnowledge of statistics is severely lacking, and airports are just a prominent example of this (people freaking out over what is an incredibly unlikely threat). Another example would be, leaning way too heavily into what a handful of people say in comments, when there’s no way you could ever read enough comments to form a statistically significant sample of what “people think” of you. The incredible rarity of these events should have shut down most spending from the beginning, and a new government department should never have been allowed to form around it (any more than we should have allowed a “Department of Lightning Safety” to be created). Then they compound the problem by allowing rare events within rare events (such as “shoes may kill us!!!”) to drive entire policies and waste even more time and money. Heck, if we understood statistics we’d be marching in the streets demanding a far larger number of representatives, since having approximately one million people “represented” by a member of the house means they could never possibly know what their constituents want even if they spent every free hour trying to find out. What I want is for people to be educated enough about statistics to not be fooled, and not to overreact to things based on what a few poor samples tell them.
- ams6110 9y agoIf people worked this way, terrorism wouldn't be a thing to begin with.
- perseusprime11 9y agoYou’re talking about data driven decision making as opposed to fear based decision making. If we are so smart, we would have hired psychometricians to advice every aspect of our government.
- noobiemcfoob 9y agoexcept you'd somehow have to elevate those psychometricians to a point of not having any sort of political beliefs or goals themselves.
- solotronics 9y agoI remember reading that Ross Perot wanted to do this if he became president. He also wanted direct voting at electronic voting stations so people could vote on specific laws.