6 ms·
There’s one simple answer to such claims, whether they are made by Smalltalk, Erlang, Haskell, or whatever. The answer is: where are the accomplishments? Show
by dmitriid 9y ago
There’s one simple answer to such claims, whether they are made by Smalltalk, Erlang, Haskell, or whatever.
The answer is: where are the accomplishments?
Show me the Kafkas, the Cassandras, the Hadoops, the Kuberneteses, the nginxes, the jettys, the (a myriad of other projects)s.
After literally tens of years of claiming/boasting that they are the best, and that other languages suck, I’ve yet to see any of these claims turn into anything but empty posturing.
- crispinb 9y agoA big red flag for lacking real accomplishments is when the only 'real world' examples proffered are (1) run of the mill web apps (which can be thrown together using just about every programming environment on the planet); and/or (2) 'enterprise apps' (a good working definition of which is: 'apps which are only ever launched by order of the boss').
- Apocryphon 9y agoIn today's age, aren't those the two major businesses cases for software that aren't embedded or aren't desktop or mobile apps?
- crispinb 9y agoYes there's some truth to that. But what I meant to express (perhaps not very clearly) is how mediocre the showcases usually seem to be. Maybe this is OK if claim is that the lionised language/platform in question is highly productive for mediocre web & enterprise apps. Indeed that may be a decent sell for managers, but perhaps less inspiring for technologists?
- throwaway7645 9y agoThere's actually a ton of business software written in Smalltalk. I think 2/3 of the world's shipping industry is controlled via Smalltalk for example. It isn't super low level like C, so I wouldn't use it for something that needs to be blazing fast. I believe Smalltalk pioneered the JIT technology that Java uses (hotspot...if I recall correctly). It isn't a silver bullet, but seems like a neat language.
- dmitriid 9y agoA lot of business runs on top of weird languages. Quite often they are simply stuck with those languages. Because a non-IT manager got some consultants who promised them 100x results for 1/100 money. As research/test beds these languages are rather invaluable. Their other values are frankly overrated.
- Apocryphon 9y agoSmalltalk specifically inspired both Objective-C and Java.
- aryehof 9y agoIn terms of object-orientation, then Java, like C++, was not inspired by Smalltalk. Certainly aspects of Smalltalk's execution environment including VM, and supporting language libraries have been influential. According to James Gosling, Java's object model is entirely based on Simula (http://bit.ly/2xc1XTA http://bit.ly/2xc1XTA) and the concepts it introduced:- objects, classes, inheritance and virtual functions. Smalltalk's main differentiation in terms of object-orientation:- "messaging between objects, all the way down", is not reflected in major modern languages, other than perhaps Ruby.
- dmitriid 9y agoIt's argued that Erlang can be viewed as OO in Smalltalk's terms if you model your system entirely around processes: you have a process black box, and you communicate using messages with it.
- akhilcacharya 9y ago>I think 2/3 of the world's shipping industry is controlled via Smalltalk for example Which system?
- nunb 9y agoIt's on this page in the shipping section [1]. I remember it had something to do with live object databases too, back when Avi Bryant of DabbleDB [2] was heavily pushing the Ruby world towards Smalltalk in the 2007-2010 timeframe with Maglev [3]. [1] http://www.cincomsmalltalk.com/main/successes/ http://www.cincomsmalltalk.com/main/successes/ [2] https://techcrunch.com/2006/03/11/dabbledb-online-app-building-for-everyone/ https://techcrunch.com/2006/03/11/dabbledb-online-app-buildi... [3] http://pragmati.st/2007/05/19/avi-bryant-keynote/ http://pragmati.st/2007/05/19/avi-bryant-keynote/
- vbuwivbiu 9y agothat's like arguing that English is a better language than say Welsh, simply because more great literature has been written in it because it's more popular. But by all accounts Welsh is a great language that happens to be spoken by fewer people.
- jacquesm 9y agoFor the Erlang case in your list: every time you pick up a phone and you get a dial tone or your cell phone connection goes through you will have interacted with Erlang code at least several times. The financial world has a ton of Haskell. Smalltalk has its successes but most of them are in the past.
- dmitriid 9y ago> For the Erlang case in your list: every time you pick up a phone Yeah, yeah, yeah. AXD301 is the only thing that keeps E going. It was the poster child 20 years ago, it still is the poster child today. Quite sad if you consider Erlang's claim: Build massively scalable soft real-time systems. Hint: you can't build a massively scalable system in Erlang any easier than in any other language. For reasons see the RELEASE project > The financial world has a ton of Haskell. The financial world has much more than a ton of other languages. > Smalltalk has its successes but most of them are in the past. Indeed.
- EdwardCoffin 9y agoCan you cite something you consider comparable to AXD301 in another language? The fact that AXD301 is still going is an accomplishment, is it not? With respect to Smalltalk: there's a long history of superior technologies losing the market to inferior technologies. The fact that it got displaced by Java is not really much of a criticism.
- dmitriid 9y ago> Can you cite something you consider comparable to AXD301 in another language? Why though? A one-time wonder that gets displayed as the project for 20 years hardly constitutes a proof. > losing the market to inferior technologies. The fact that it got displaced by Java is not really much of a criticism. I keep hearing about these inferior technologies. However, the only ones talking about "inferior technologies" are these marginalised languages that are so full of themselves: Smalltalk, Erlang, Haskell... It comes down to a very simple thing: these languages are supposed to be superior to basically anything else. And yet... There's hardly anything made/built in these projects that can show the world that these claims are true. Except maybe some closed-source business cases. Having been on the inside of one of such a case, I now take these stories with a grain of salt the size of Jupiter.