11 ms·
One of the problems with Tinder is its nebulous ethos. Is it a dating app or is it a hookup app? It seems to pretend that it's both without committing to eith
by ravenstine 9y ago
One of the problems with Tinder is its nebulous ethos. Is it a dating app or is it a hookup app? It seems to pretend that it's both without committing to either one, which muddies the water and I don't think that works terribly well.
Tinder is brilliant in that it focuses entirely on vanity, ego, and lust, far more so than any of its predecessors. Thus, it has taken a large portion of the dating market away from sites like OKCupid, which had virtually nobody on it in the LA area when I last used it nearly a year ago. Once upon a time, I was an overweight nerd with no money, yet I somehow got dates through OKC. Those days are long gone.
The only alternative I can recommend is real life. Nothing beats it, and it's the only way you can know you aren't wasting your time. Go to meetups and actually talk to people and figure out how to improve when you screw up. Being able to get to know people, even if they don't end up being dates, is pretty awesome. It means actually having to grow as a person, but I would bet on a higher success rate than with any dating app/website.
All dating apps I know of are a joke. Bumble is hilarious because it actually makes an existing problem worse and sells that as a solution; women don't want hundreds of messages from random penises, and they're very unlikely to initiate a conversation.(i don't blame them) Match, Chemistry, PoF, and all those old-school sites are borderline scams that charge a fortune. Match will send you daily emails telling you how many likes(is it "winks"? i can't remember now.) you're getting, but none of that seems to manifest on the site itself. It's the ol' bait and switch.
- k__ 9y agoYes. I'm using dating apps for over 10 years now. Dated 3 women via them. In "real life" I found 12 in that time. But I still do it, every few years I get some nice surprises :)
- mathattack 9y ago3 dates in 10 years? With that kind of yield, I would’ve given up much sooner!
- k__ 9y agoWell, like I said I met about 1.5 women a year and most of them for >1 years so it was okay.
- cableshaft 9y agoI always had much better luck with online dating. At least on those sites you are reasonably certain they are available and wanting to date and/or hook up with people. I went to a ton of meetups and group events in real life over the course of three years (and to a lesser extent for years before that), met a lot of women through that, but very few of them were either not in a relationship or emotionally available at the time (either too focused on their career, in an 'it's complicated' situation, going through crap with family, not very financially stable, waiting for their unicorn and would accept nothing less, etc). Many of these women I never saw with anyone or spoke about being with anyone over the course of many years in successive meetups. To be fair, I was in a similar situation through a good chunk of my 20s when I was either working my butt off for startups or completely broke, so I understand. But online dating was much less frustrating for me.
- fencepost 9y ago> I went to a ton of meetups and group events in real life over the course of three years (and to a lesser extent for years before that), met a lot of women through that, but very few of them were either not in a relationship or emotionally available at the time Don't go to events and activities looking for love. Go to events and activities looking for interesting people to get to know and be friends with - and let them be a filter of "Hey, I know someone you should meet" when they know you're single. Similarly, if you have friends who've never met but who are single and have similar interests, don't be afraid to introduce them to each other.
- cableshaft 9y agoIt wasn't specifically looking for love, I was mainly trying to get out of my shell and meet more people. I made a ton of friends from it, more than I can keep up with, and some of my closest friends today came from that period of time, so it was still very valuable. But I was also hoping it would help my dating prospects and it didn't seem to help much with that.
- fencepost 9y ago
- lgas 9y agoIt's a hookup app.
- cableshaft 9y agoOkCupid, Match.com, Chemistry.com, PlentyOfFish, and Tinder are all owned by the same company. They like to hide that fact and pretend they're all separate entities to end users, but it's true. Some of them were once separate, then purchased later, but Tinder was part of them from the very beginning. So they're not really "losing" users, just shuffling them around from site to site. http://iac.com/brand/match-group http://iac.com/brand/match-group https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Match_Group https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Match_Group
- qeternity 9y agoThe good ol' illusion of choice.
- j_s 9y agoI appreciate the reminder! Now that you've said this I remember this being mentioned here before: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9884518 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9884518
- ravenstine 9y agoYikes, I knew that OKC, Match, and Chemistry were owned by the same company, but I had no idea they'd become such a monopoly. Thanks for enlightening us!
- nunez 9y agoIAC is kind of like a private equity firm for internet properties; they own a lot of random stuff
- Kadin 9y agoYou can pretty much chart the downfall of OkCupid as a result of selling out to Match. When it was a sort of overgrown hobby project run by a couple of data geeks, it was fun. (Hell, even if you weren't necessarily interested in, or comfortable with the idea of, "online dating", the extensive quizzes were a great signup engine.) When the founders sold to Match, and presumably also got less involved in the day-to-day, suddenly I stopped hearing anything good about it anymore. I can't personally vouch for it, being out of the market at the time, but it went from being a pretty reliable recommendation that I'd often hear friends talking about, to quickly developing a reputation for having a high creep factor, lots of low-effort and fake profiles, etc. As with many businesses, I think the demand for growth uber alles killed it. If they had been content being a niche service, they would have survived and served that niche well. But too few businesses (especially startups that get sold) are allowed to do that; their management requires they either shoot the moon or burn up trying. In particular, I think there is a solid niche for an OKC-like dating site that actively rejects "mobile first" low-word-count design in favor of the desktop (check your messages when you get home, no "swiping" from the shitter, etc.), emphasizes profiles with lots of information and underlying data to construct matches on something other than photos, and basically serves a very literate demographic. Basically OKC circa 2004. Though today, a modern version would also need tools to aggressively block users that are abusive or just plain "creepy", because there's an Eternal September aspect to the Internet today that didn't really exist back then, that you'd need to combat -- spam-type adaptive filters would probably do the job ('is this spam' is a pretty vague question for a machine, so is 'is this creepy', but you could teach the filters over time given a good dataset and feedback mechanism).
- paul7986 9y agoAs almost average looking guy living in Baltimore I found Match.com to be the best dating app and worth the money. I at least had one date a month with average looking women. POF was 2nd while Eharmony was the worst. Though in 2010 to about 2014 Christian Mingle was the best as there weren't many guys on it and I dated a dozen average to attractive looking women in a few months. Not many use it like before as they didnt jump to mobile quick enough.
- sgt101 9y agoI got married to someone I met on match, been married for 10 years. My coz is in a long term relationship with someone he met on tinder. Your mileage may vary...
- geekamongus 9y agoFor my wife and I, it was OKCupid where we met. Been together over 7 years, married over 5 of them (all in a row).
- pmoriarty 9y ago"The only alternative I can recommend is real life. Nothing beats it.." The problem I have with meeting people from "real life" is that they're mostly random people that I usually have little to nothing in common with. At least on some dating sites I can list my interests, and the people who reply can self-select to have some or even many of these things in common with me.
- fencepost 9y ago> The problem I have with meeting people from "real life" is that they're mostly random people that I usually have little to nothing in common with. What meeting people in real life means is basically just getting on with your life and doing things that interest you. Like comics? Go to a comic shop. Fascinated by chainmail bikinis? Start spending time at Renaissance Faires - or learn to make them and build a community around yourself. Enjoy mountain biking? Go biking, then go grab coffee or drinks with some other people doing the same. Don't focus on doing these activities to meet potential romantic partners - do them to have fun because you enjoy them and meet other people who enjoy the same things. Don't expect those people to be possible partners, expect them to be friends or acquaintances and to be people through whom you may meet a possible romantic interest. To quote Ben Carson, "I don't have facts to back this up," but I feel pretty sure that a huge percentage of relationships come from either having some common activity (e.g. "high school," "college," "coworker") or from knowing someone in common (e.g. "friend's brother/sister/other friend"). The one thing I can pretty much guarantee for you is that sitting at home and hoping for a date with an interesting delivery person (or service person if something goes out) is not going to be a successful approach - and if you're that delivery or service person instead, remember that asking out someone whose home or office you've just gone to would be just as creepy as being hit on by the people you've been sent to.
- YuriNiyazov 9y ago"Don't focus on doing these activities to meet potential romantic partners - do them to have fun because you enjoy them and meet other people who enjoy the same things." I can't disagree with this enough. If you want a job, are you going to continue going to the activities you've always been going to and hoping to meet someone that gives you work? If you want an apartment to live in, are you going to go to the same activities you've been going to and hope that someone there is a landlord? Maybe you would. But most people would check a jobs site or a rental site. Why would romantic relationships be any different?
- kevin_thibedeau 9y ago> Is it a dating app or is it a hookup app? I thought it was a Facebook data mining app.
- morgante 9y ago> One of the problems with Tinder is its nebulous ethos. Is it a dating app or is it a hookup app? That's a feature, not a bug. For many/most people, there's not a strict binary division. Dates can turn into hookup and hookups can turn into real relationships. I know multiple friends in long-term relationships which started as Tinder hookups.
- malandrew 9y agoThis. I've been dating someone I met through tinder for two years now. It's started out as friends with benefits and evolved into a relationship where we are planning our future together.
- mathperson 9y agoData point of 1: probably 70% of the people I match with on bumble initiate a conversation. I think I'm slightly above average in terms of attractiveness
- dlandis 9y ago> One of the problems with Tinder is its nebulous ethos. It's not a really a problem though because people can indicate for themselves in their profiles, either explicitly or implicitly, what type of relationship they are looking for; it can be different things for different people. > Tinder is brilliant in that it focuses entirely on vanity, ego, and lust, far more so than any of its predecessors. But I think that misses the main appeal of Tinder, which is that once you match with someone you basically have an invitation to start a conversation with them, and hence are less likely to be wasting your time (or someone else's). IIRC, on other sites, you can simply message any random user and thus are much more likely to spend time messaging someone who has absolutely no interest in you.
- alpha_squared 9y ago> It's not a really a problem though because people can indicate for themselves in their profiles, either explicitly or implicitly, what type of relationship they are looking for; it can be different things for different people. In my anecdotal experience (which means feel free take with a handful of salt), it never really worked out that way. I've gone on dates via Tinder where a profile explicitly stated "no hookups" or something to that effect that did, indeed, turn into hookups. Also, and this is the more obvious thing, I think, is that a dating platform designed to not require you to actually read a profile before deciding if you're interested isn't going to be the ideal place for stating "preferences". Hence, my anecdotal experience.
- raverbashing 9y agoYup, "no hookups" -> wants a hookup So, it is indicated
- 1337biz 9y agoIt is a hookup app. Tinder can't say that as it gives users not plausible deniability and feel shallow. Very smart on Tinder's side!
- heedlessly2 9y agoi would advise against meetup.com for most people depending on your city. It's filled with 45+ year year olds. Among the younger meetups, its going to 9 guys - 1 girl ratio. The guys are typically all out-of-shape and awkward nerdy types and the the one girl will be similar to them too.
- borplk 9y ago> One of the problems with Tinder is its nebulous ethos. That's a "feature". It makes it mainstream enough for people to be there without being embarrassed or ashamed. Then people can turn it into more of a dating thing or a hookup thing as they prefer. Few people would want to publicly create a profile on "just-here-strictly-for-hookups.com". That's also why a huge percentage of profiles, especially female ones, insist so strongly that they are not there for hookups. It's a facade and a bit of virtue signalling ("I'm not a slut like those other girls!").
- slavik81 9y agoI'm not much of a believer in real life. While I don't know about most people, I never joined hobbies to find a date until I realized I had to get serious about finding someone. Until that point, I just did whatever was most fun. If I was in a badminton league, it was purely because I wanted to play badminton. So, when I started picking hobbies and going to events based on gender ratio first and fun second, it felt kinda awkward. I figured most people were like what I used to be. If they were in a badminton league, it was probably because they wanted to play badminton, not to get hit on by some guy. On a dating website, everyone is at least in the same ballpark of expectations. It's straightforward. And, ultimately, it worked. I got engaged after 4 years with a great girl I met on OKC.