7 ms·
> You may or may not be aware, but FreeBSD runs your movies on Netflix, your games on PlayStation, your files on FreeNAS and ZFS, your friends on WhatsApp and O
by jcelerier 9y ago
> You may or may not be aware, but FreeBSD runs your movies on Netflix, your games on PlayStation, your files on FreeNAS and ZFS, your friends on WhatsApp and OpenBSD runs everywhere else as OpenSSH. ;)
so... let us get that straight.
* Netflix had a revenue of 8.83 billion dollars USD last year.
* Sony had a revenue of 68 fucking billion dollars.
* WhatsApp is owned by facebook which will have around 40 billion dollar revenue this year it seems
and all these guys put together aren't arsed to contribute enough for paying for a few full-time devs, in addition to keeping a part of their modifications to the BSD source closed, but us, the users, should additionnally roll out some bucks to help these companies make even more money ? What's wrong with you people ?
What next ? Should we also donate to tanenbaum to help Intel (59 billion $ revenue) conceal its next iteration of the management engine better ?
- tachion 9y agoI don't think there's anything wrong with us. First of all, no one says you should do anything. We're asking kindly because we can, and you can do all range of things from ignoring us completely to donating $1M like WhatsApp founder. Because you can too. Second thing is that's its much easier to ask open source aware HN reader for $50 than a huge megacorp hive mind for 50c. Not to mention every 'end user dollar' is worth much more for the foundation given the regulations, where to keep the tax status we need to show up numbers supporting in people, rather than businesses. And finally, many of these companies do give us money and code, some in the open, some anonymously due to the reasons known only to them. Just a food for thought for you when you'll be thinking about these donations :)
- int_19h 9y agoI think it's not so much about donating in and of itself, as it is about this "it runs Netflix!" argument. I do donate to FreeBSD regularly - in fact, I have a matching paycheck donation set up. But that's because I personally use it in my projects. When it comes to Netflix, I already pay for Netflix, so the notion that I should also pay to FreeBSD because it makes Netflix possible is kinda ridiculous.
- ianai 9y agoThere’s also the argument regarding existence. Without the BSDs there would be much fewer ways for people and companies to use great, legitimately industry standard software/hardware technologies. Where would people cut their teeth programming and administrating the same tech that will land them work? Sure, Microsoft’s OSes exist, they’re not economically available for everybody. To say nothing about the realities of which OS offers a better developer/admin experience.
- lcampbell 9y agoFWIW, Netflix and Facebook each donated gold-tier (25-50k USD) this year[1]. I would be very surprised if none of those companies employ engineers submitting patches upstream -- obviously for some things it doesn't make sense (proprietary drivers for PS4 hardware, etc). A cursory search turned up this[2], for example. [1] https://www.freebsdfoundation.org/donors/ https://www.freebsdfoundation.org/donors/ [2] https://people.freebsd.org/~rrs/asiabsd_tls_improved.pdf https://people.freebsd.org/~rrs/asiabsd_tls_improved.pdf
- protomyth 9y agoPlus, US tax law has some requirements around nonprofits and number of contributors. The single or few large donors is great, but the org needs to show wide support. So a twenty $5 donations is better than a single $100 donation.
- squaredpants 9y agoI have no ties to the FreeBSD project or its foundation, but it seems very cheap for companies that profit billions of dollars yearly to only donate $25k to projects and foundations that support part of the software backbone of their infrastructure... Regardless of regulatory barriers, if this got a bit more exposure it could actually be a PR liability, IMO...
- greenhouse_gas 9y ago>but it seems very cheap for companies that profit billions of dollars yearly to only donate $25k to projects and foundations that support part of the software backbone of their infrastructure.. That's the free rider problem, one that the GPL (and the AGPL) was designed to avoid. It's true that many of those companies which use FreeBSD wouldn't touch a GPL codebase (and all the more so an AGPL codebase), but that't the point - while some chose FreeBSD because it's fast/stable (NF and WhatsApp), others chose it because they don't have to contribute back.
- nitrogen 9y agoAt some point we have to acknowledge that our modern technological society relies on having a common, free foundation of tools available to everyone. Sometimes really big companies will get more value out than they put in, but so does everyone else and that's kind of the point of a foundational tool. All of this free, open, etc. software works in part because of a "pay it forward" approach to the community. If people shame big users for not "paying back" enough, rather than finding more productive means of encouragement, the whole system of free tools becomes less tenable because future users will pick other tools that don't have PR risk attached.
- pabloski 9y agoThis is BSD at work my friend. And this is why every serious opensource fan should prefer GPL and similar licenses. The thing who shocked me the most, was to learn that Sony uses FreeBSD on the PS4 and yet no Radeon driver has been given back to the community. Obviously they have a bad ass device driver in the PS4 with some serious 3D performance ( after all it is a gaming console ). Yet the only thing you have in mainline FreeBSD is a hacked driver ported from Linux! BSD at work!
- deaddodo 9y agoOrbis doesn't work the way you think it does. The kernel is based on FreeBSD, but the entire gfx stack (and everything else above the kernel) is custom. It's not even OpenGL compatible, instead running their custom GNM library (Metal/Vulkan/Mantle equivalent) and GNMX (OpenGL/DirectX equivalent). Nothing they've built in their stack would translate to an Xorg driver, beyond the kernel shim (the smallest and simplest portion of the code, in most video drivers).
- tachion 9y agoIt's a difference in perspective, I rather prefer situation where no one isn't forced to anything, and that's why I think BSD license is 'better'. I want you, me and everyone else, including companies like Sony, to be free to take the code and benefit from it in every possible way, and if they choose not to share back, it's again their freedom to make this decision. I will use my freedom to make the decision of sharing back, despite all other decisions made in that regard, because this is what I consider a truly free software, unlike the GPL.
- willtim 9y agoGPL is about enabling freedom for end-users. An end-user could be anything from an individual to a corporate entity. Your definition of freedom appears to be just "permissive licensing". Unfortunately, permissive licensing like BSD, could mean that one's code ends up being wielded by a corporation to remove end-user freedoms, typically to lock them in as paying customers. I am a Free Software Foundation (FSF) member because I believe that end-user freedoms are becoming increasingly under threat as of late and they appear to be among the few that are taking the problem seriously.
- sureaboutthis 9y agoNetflix contributes code back to FreeBSD including kernel contributions via Netflix own in-house FreeBSD committers that have greatly improved streaming and other improvements. Netflix also contributes monetarily. https://openconnect.netflix.com/en/software/ https://openconnect.netflix.com/en/software/ "All code improvements, feature additions, and bug fixes are contributed directly back to the open source community via the FreeBSD committers on our team. We also strive to stay at the front of the FreeBSD development process, allowing us to have a tight feedback loop with other community and partner developers." WhatsApp has also contributed monetarily and with software. You need to know that Facebook only recently bought WhatsApp.
- kogepathic 9y ago> WhatsApp has also contributed monetarily and with software. You need to know that Facebook only recently bought WhatsApp. Coming up on almost 4 years now since the WhatsApp acquisition was announced (Feb 2014) and over 3 years since the acquisition closed (Oct 2014). [1] [2] I wouldn't call either date "recently" [1] http://money.cnn.com/2014/02/19/technology/social/facebook-whatsapp/index.html http://money.cnn.com/2014/02/19/technology/social/facebook-w... [2] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-10-28/facebook-s-22-billion-whatsapp-deal-buys-10-million-in-sales https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-10-28/facebook-...
- Crontab 9y agoThe decision to donate to a BSD project shouldn't have anything to do with what other users are donating but with how useful you personally find it to be. Your whole comment is sad.