5 ms·
Maybe I'm naive but isn't this something Amazon, for example, should be doing? Why aren't they concerned about the integrity of their community?
by chiefalchemist 9y ago
Maybe I'm naive but isn't this something Amazon, for example, should be doing? Why aren't they concerned about the integrity of their community?
- dvt 9y ago> Why aren't they concerned about the integrity of their community? Amazon has virtually no competition, ergo is not incentivized whatsoever to be concerned with the integrity of their community. Further, Amazon will charge you for return shipping so, again, they couldn't care less if a positively reviewed product actually sucks. Now that I think about it, the whole system is pretty brilliant because they're double dipping: charging the customer for returns but charging the vendor for warehouse space. It's the definition of a win-win.
- manojlds 9y agoOh, you have to pay for returns? That's not case (yet?) with Amazon.in.
- arbie 9y agoReturn shipping is free if the product is defective or the website description is inaccurate.
- user5994461 9y agoMost people choose to bin and forget the $10 shit they got, instead of sending back and asking for refund.
- beamatronic 9y agoJust don't buy anything that isn't explicitly sold by Amazon.com. Or a few trusted others like AnkerDirect
- mattpavelle 9y agoThis is a common misconception. As has been stated before on similar threads, Amazon comingles inventory. So if you as a third party seller have a bunch of fake widgets for sale on Amazon and anyone else (including Amazon themselves) sell the same widget (same by name) then Amazon has no control over whose inventory a buyer receivers, regardless of the Sold By label on Amazon.com https://www.wsj.com/articles/on-amazon-pooled-merchandise-opens-door-to-knockoffs-1399852852 https://www.wsj.com/articles/on-amazon-pooled-merchandise-op... Relevant paragraphs if you can't get past the paywall: "As more third-party sellers have signed up to offer products through Amazon and use its order-fulfillment services, the Seattle-based giant has allowed many to pool their inventory with supposedly identical items supplied by other sellers—in essence commingling products from third-party merchants with those supplied directly to Amazon by the brands themselves. In other words, a product ordered from a third-party seller may not have originated from that particular seller. If the bar code matches, any one that is on the shelf will do."
- j_s 9y agoPer this discussion https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13040084 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13040084 "FBA vendors appear to have control [...] But I still don't think the amazon customer can see if an fba vendor allows commingling"
- leggomylibro 9y agoYeah, but when you have enough money, why not take the Pfizer model and let someone else do the hard work/risk/etc? Ten-to-one a company like Amazon buys them in a year or three. Assuming that they don't pivot to the 'extortion' business model instead.
- InternetUser 9y ago> Yeah, but when you have enough money Imagine you are appointed the new CEO of Amazon.com. Please define "enough money," even a loose ballpark estimate.
- civilitty 9y agoEnough money === so much that even a wildly successful version of the product would at best increase revenue for a few percent long term. We're talking billions of dollars a year for a company like amazon
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Why aren't they concerned about the integrity of their community? Because consumers aren't imposing sufficient costs on them for not being concerned to change that attitude. Amazon is interested in making money as efficiently as possible, period.
- always_good 9y agoKinda like how everyone leaves positive reviews on Airbnb because you don't want to look like a dick to future hosts. In fact, there really is no upside to leaving a negative review. For example, "great place if you're a dog lover" = gang of intimidating street dogs on your doorstep. "Great eco-friendly washing machine" = one of those vibrating buckets. "Great place if you're a morning people" = loud train or church bells at 4am, or just next to a loud highway. I've lived in some dumpy places in my life without issue so I'm not just some picky tourist expecting a Four Seasons experience in someone's guest house. But the reviews/ratings are pretty useless and Airbnb really has no reason to fix them.
- mgkimsal 9y ago> In fact, there really is no upside to leaving a negative review. There's a downside - you get reviewed yourself, as a guest. My wife had an OK experience with airbnb, then a shitty one. airbnb did nothing helpful, and the host threatened my wife with a negative review if she left one. The fact that we had documented evidence of things like * a completely broken shower * missing curtains in the living area, exposing your entire room to an office block across the street, with no way to walk between bathroom and bedroom without being seen by office workers day and night * broken television * moldy refrigerator * and - as trivial as it sounds - 1 hanger in a closet for someone who booked a 10 day stay airbnb hung her out to dry, no refund, no partial refund. "it must have been acceptable because you stayed". There was no guarantee of getting any refund during that time, and we were already out over $2k for just the accommodations. Horrible horrible experience, and I will not be giving them our business again any time soon. Again, the host threatened to leave a "negative guest" review. Given that my wife would only have that one review (despite a previous airbnb stay), this has more of a damaging effect on her ability to use the service in the future than it does on the host with dozens of "fabulous/great place!" crap reviews. She declined to leave a negative review out of some odd fear, against my suggestion, but what's done is done. The airbnb team makes it pretty clear how they resolve issues, and it was not even close to being fair, from my perspective. Of course, looking at things "objectively", yes, my wife could have come in and broken the shower, added mold to the refrigerator, broken the television and stolen the curtains just to try to wrangle a few bucks from the host. There is always that to consider, I suppose.
- thisisit 9y agoBecause Amazon needs to tread carefully. Lot of people depend on Amazon for their bussiness. This site has a very low bar for showing false positives. It can mark majority reviews as fake without consequences. If Amazon does something similar it will be like YouTube de-monetizing videos all over again.
- dayaz36 9y agoBecause they have fake reviews for their own stuff: https://www.fakespot.com/product/fire-tv-stick-with-alexa-voice-remote-echo-dot-white https://www.fakespot.com/product/fire-tv-stick-with-alexa-vo...