3 ms·
I'm skeptical Fakespot works well. Consider this product: > https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0064EKNKI https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0064EKNKI Where do
by mehrdadn 9y ago
I'm skeptical Fakespot works well. Consider this product:
> https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0064EKNKI https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0064EKNKI
Where do they get the idea that 25% of the reviews are unreliable/deceptive? I bought it and it works just fine, which is pretty consistent with 87% of the reviews being 4+. Why should I think otherwise?
- Zak 9y agoIt's attempting to spot sponsored reviews, not bad products.
- mehrdadn 9y agoTo quote itself, it's spotting "unreliable" and "deceptive" reviews, not merely sponsored ones. And even in the latter case: do those look like sponsored reviews?
- Zak 9y agoNo, but I imagine sponsored reviews aren't supposed to look like sponsored reviews. The three it flagged as suspicious for the ethernet cable above were all very short, like "Great product!" or "A++++". I'm not sure what to think of that. I write reviews (of flashlights) as a hobby and wouldn't call something that doesn't describe how the product was tested or include any technical or performance analysis a review. On the other hand, the average buyer doesn't usually have the knowledge to write a useful technical review and just wants to report that the product met their expectations.
- mehrdadn 9y ago> No, but I imagine sponsored reviews aren't supposed to look like sponsored reviews. I mean, yes, but that wasn't the point. If the sponsored reviews seem to blend in with the normal reviews and and seem to be at least as accurate as normal reviews then how in the world are they "fake"? Where is the tangible distinction for me as a customer? (Why in the world would I avoid such products?) > I write reviews (of flashlights) as a hobby Funny you mention that! Flashlights seem like just about the worst-marketed products I've seen on Amazon, so they indeed definitely need great reviews. At the risk of going off-topic, do you have any tips on figuring out what the lumen output of a flashlight actually is (or even what LEDs they use)? I keep seeing Cree LEDs being claimed to output 2-3x as many lumens as they're even capable of.
- Rapzid 9y agoYou are probably correct to be skeptical. Anyone engaging this company for real business would likely question how they determined fake/not-fake for the training data, what the performance of the model is, etc.
- Zak 9y agoFlashlights on Amazon are mostly horrible. Thrunite and their offshoot Wowtac are the only brands I'd buy there, because they sell direct. It's usually better to order from specialty dealers. It's often cheaper too, as they tend to do outreach on forums, /r/flashlight, etc... and offer standing coupon codes. Visual identification is usually the best way to tell what LED a light really uses. Here's a chart with photos of a bunch of common ones: http://budgetlightforum.com/node/26665 http://budgetlightforum.com/node/26665 While the lights you find on Amazon making extreme claims about output are almost certainly lying, LED manufacturer datasheets tend to be conservative about how much power LEDs can handle. Typical mains-powered fixtures don't have the sort of heatsinking and thermal paths good flashlights do, and LED manufacturers base their limits on a service life of tens of thousands of hours. You will not use your flashlight for 50,000 hours. Overdriven LEDs aren't rare, especially in enthusiast-oriented lights. Measuring lumens is hard because you need a way to collect all the light, or at least average it, then put that average on a sensor. Commercial integrating spheres for this purpose cost thousands of dollars. It's possible to estimate using a shoebox and a smartphone though, assuming you have a light source of known output with which to calibrate it. I wrote an app for that: https://github.com/zakwilson/ceilingbounce/ https://github.com/zakwilson/ceilingbounce/
- mehrdadn 9y agoThat's awesome info, thank you! :)
- Zak 9y agoI should also mention that a lot of reviews of flashlights found on Amazon praising things I would rate as absolute junk are probably entirely honest. If your last flashlight used alkaline batteries and an ancient LED, or even an incandescent, anything using an LED from this decade and a Li-ion battery is going to look pretty impressive. That Li-ion cell might well be taken from a laptop battery sent in for recycling, and the charger it comes with might burn your house down, but it's still impressive to the average person. On the other hand, I've seen a one-star review for not including a battery. It never said, or even suggested that a battery might possibly be included. My conclusion is that Amazon reviews for most kinds of products aren't useful for much more than determining if a product has an unreasonably high failure rate.
- abawany 9y agoI looked at the critical reviews and it seems that there was an uptick of fake products sent to customers. Perhaps such an uptick triggers this fakespot behavior? My observation for this and other products is that when something is shady, the reviews consist of a lot of date-clustered reviews that are positive followed by a trickle of critical reviews that seem to point out specific issues with the product.
- mehrdadn 9y agoMerely having fake products doesn't imply fake reviews though? If anything the fake reviews would seem to be more genuine. I also don't really see any particular uptick or date-clustering like you mention. There are a total of 7 reviews that say "fake" or "counterfeit" out of 177 critical reviews, out of 1382 total reviews... and I'm not really noticing a particular clustering of good reviews preceding these the most prominent critical review [1] (haven't checked the rest). [1] https://www.amazon.com/Tera-Grand-Ethernet-Retractable-Playstation/product-reviews/B0064EKNKI/ref=cm_cr_arp_d_paging_btm_next_101?pageNumber=100&sortBy=recent https://www.amazon.com/Tera-Grand-Ethernet-Retractable-Plays...