6 ms·
I hate to make a meta comment and I'm not trying to slander the author at all, but dang dude, we got it all here: newsletter signup on site entry, press relatio
by DanielBMarkham 16y ago
I hate to make a meta comment and I'm not trying to slander the author at all, but dang dude, we got it all here: newsletter signup on site entry, press relations button, request for speaking, ebooks. I almost expected a free chance to win an iPod somewhere while I was reading.
I found the material lacking in quality, but it had its moments. My biggest impression was just being overwhelmed with the way the blog was integrated. Hats off.
- baguasquirrel 16y agoI agreed with you up until the "I found the material lacking in quality". Not all "smart people" are alike, and you may be one of the fortunate ones to not have the problems that he describes. Specifically, from what I've read of your previous posts, you seem like a practical person. That said, the tweet thing on the left side was annoying enough that it warranted firing up the javascript debugger to make it go away.
- rajesh301 16y agoI am looking at the tweet thing (tweetboard) to see how to eliminate this completely. Cheers.
- rajesh301 16y agoPoint noted. None of the items you mentioned ( newsletter sign up, eBooks ) are required to access the content on the blog. In fact, none of the eBooks require you to enter an email address. I am sad to see that you focused on these things rather than 1500 other articles on the blog. C'est la vie :)
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoTrying to stay positive, I think you should use the newsletter popup on something like the 3rd or 4th visit. By that time, users have read some of your material and could form an opinion about subscribing to a newsletter. From my personal perspective, if you punch me in the nose with a sign-up form the first time I visit, not only am I going to dismiss it without any consideration at all, I am going to be suspicious of the subsequent material you present. Changing the timing of this popup could help you a bunch, I think.
- prs 16y agoExactly my thoughts. This post will generate a decent amount of visitors from HN. The vast majority of these visitors including myself will be first-timers to your site and unable to tell whether they are interested in subscribing to your newsletter in the first place. If I have not seen your site, I will not subscribe to your newsletter. If I have read through n items on your website, chances are good I might be interested in your newsletter offer, though.
- rajesh301 16y agoPoint noted and thank you.
- rajesh301 16y agoThanks for the great feedback here. Noted it and will act on it. Unfortunately I can't do that until Monday as the person who can fix it won't be available until then :(
- thwarted 16y agoThe popup/overlay that tells me I'm a new user to this blog was keeping me from reading the content, so I just closed the tab.
- rajesh301 16y agoThe popup was not a gatekeeper and you can easily switch that off without signing up to the newsletter. Having said that, I have made a note of the feedback on the popup and will take action to fix that. Thanks.
- thwarted 16y agoThe popup was not a gatekeeper and you can easily switch that off without signing up to the newsletter. It may not have been a physical gatekeeper, but things that overlay the main content while I'm reading them (even if it was meant to show quickly, before I started reading and was delayed because of download or javascript execution times) communicates that the author/maintainer of the website considers their content to be less important than whatever the overlay's content is. I don't have time for this, the internet is quite vast. There are a bunch of other hacker news entries to review. The only advantage you have now is that I don't even remember the name of the site that I so quickly closed due to annoyance, and my browser is now flagged as having visited it previously, so if I happen across it again, I presumably won't get a popup/overlay telling me I'm a new visitor. I'm not sure why a new visitor needs to be told that they are a new visitor.
- rajesh301 16y agoYour argument is so right that it would be foolish to argue against it. You make a very good point and I will discuss this with my team to get this fixed. THANKS.
- bluishgreen 16y agoI did find many articles with original content on your site. But the density is less, you are perhaps focusing on the article count? Maybe bringing the count to say 100 but with the same content will save peoples time trying to wade thru the site. And this can only increase traffic to the site. As per your own theory smart people cannot solve their own problems, so instead of taking the "C'est la vie" stance, try "I see, let me see what I can do about it" attitude.
- rajesh301 16y agoThanks for the comments. The "C'est la vie" comment was specifically about another comment which focussed on things totally outside the article - like newsletter sign up etc. I will definitely think about your comment and discuss it with my mentors. There are people who I take advise when it comes to these aspects ( blogging, writing ). Thanks for the advice in any case.
- filmschool 16y agoThe content of the article was ok. One opinion in an ocean full of them. The pop-up even before I've even read a single line is just so glaringly ill-timed that it kinda ruins the whole experience before the actual experience. IMHO.
- rajesh301 16y agoThanks for the note. Will get the popup fixed soon.
- jules 16y agoThe popup saying "you're new" is in practice equivalent to saying "go away".
- srinivasnjay 16y agoCome on guys, give me a break. It was a welcome note which said, what can be found on the website. I agree if you would have said, it is not required for the people who are visiting it for the first time as you don't know the quality of content provided. But definitely it dint say or meant "go away".
- jules 16y agoOf course it didn't. But it has the same effect.
- rajesh301 16y agoThanks for all the feedback about the popup. Will get that fixed right away. I am not tech-savvy enough to fix it myself so it has to be on Monday :( Cheers.
- icco 16y agoMy biggest problem is that I have a small screen and the tweet button blocks the left side of the content the whole way down. Really annoying.
- rajesh301 16y agoWhat browser are you using? I checked it with Safari, Firefox and Chrome on a Mac and the tweetboard plugin was working fine. Please let me know.
- adammichaelc 16y agoThe marketing-stuff-that-you-think-is-lame aside, I'd be interested to hear which parts of the article were lacking in quality. Do you disagree with some of the content? If so based on your previous HN comments I'd love to hear your thoughts so we can start a discussion. Or did you not like the writing style, and are simply pointing at that and saying, "You suck" but using bigger words?
- bobbyi 16y agoThe whole premise of the article is false dilemma. It's asking why "smart people" haven't solved "their own problems" when by definition "their own problems" are whatever problems they haven't solved.
- Natsu 16y agoWhile what you say is true of the article, I have noticed that mistakes seem easier to find when someone else is making them.
- jerf 16y agoPart of the reason for that isn't just your outsider perspective. Part of it is that you don't have any obligation to verify your diagnosis. A lot of "mistakes" you see people making probably aren't actually mistakes, a lot of things they are doing right are equally also not doing it right. Without getting into specifics, how many people would look at, say, a government following $YOUR_PREFERRED_ECONOMIC_SYSTEM and call it a long series of "mistakes"? But of course you know that $YPES is not a long series of mistakes, it's the way any right-thinking person knows it should be done. In fact they are making a mistake for preferring some other system over yours!.... or are they? It's very easy to inaccurately diagnose problems and prescribe solutions, but it doesn't mean much without validation.
- rajesh301 16y agoYou definitely bring up a very good point. I should phrase it properly. Yes, their own problems are problems they haven't solved - when in fact, they could have solved them. If their "unsolved problems" were brought to them by someone else, they would have had a solution very quickly. That is precisely the reason to have mentors and personal advisors. My $.02
- humblepatience 16y agoI find everything except the popup on entry fine. But that caused me to bounce.