3 ms·
> But the person most at fault here is the one who lied and called in SWAT in the first place. It completely mystifies me how people can think that people with
by StavrosK 9y ago
> But the person most at fault here is the one who lied and called in SWAT in the first place.
It completely mystifies me how people can think that people with guns were justified in fatally shooting someone with no guns. That kind of thing should just never happen, either subdue them or let them get away, why are you shooting them? What could they possibly have done, short of ran to the kitchen to get a knife and then ran back and tried to stab someone? How can you mistake anything someone unarmed does for a deadly threat?
- MikkoFinell 9y agoIt mystifies me why you believe anyone thinks the shooting was justified. Literally NO ONE has said that. Please try to engage with the actual debate instead of making up strawmen to attack.
- StavrosK 9y agoThe grandparent said that the person most at fault was the person who called it in. I disagree, the people most at fault were the police, by far.
- reificator 9y agoI get where you're coming from, but the person who called it in named themselves SWauTistic and makes a hobby of this behavior.
- StavrosK 9y agoYes, the guy is definitely guilty of some degree of murder, because he knew what he was doing. However, I'm contrasting it with my country, where calling in such a situation would be very unlikely to get someone killed, because the police are much more reticent to shoot people. In such a case, the caller could be guilty of wasting resources, but not of murder. The only difference is the handling of each situation by the police, hence my reasoning above.
- MikkoFinell 9y agoHow many gun-related homicides are there per year in your country?
- StavrosK 9y ago1.5 per 100k (most of which are suicides), gun culture isn't big here.
- MikkoFinell 9y agoThat's why it seems a bit unreasonable to compare how the police in your country would react to how American police unfortunately reacted in this scenario. Because the situations those officers face on a daily basis is completely different. American cops can reasonably expect to regularly deal with armed and hostile psychos, unlike the cops in many other countries. Again, that's not to say that the shooting was in any way justified, but try to put yourself in the life of American police officers.
- StavrosK 9y agoYes, that's another good point, and a big factor in why the police there acts the way it does. Yet, even with all the needless deaths, gun culture remains widespread.
- reificator 9y ago> However, I'm contrasting it with my country, where calling in such a situation would be very unlikely to get someone killed, because the police are much more reticent to shoot people. Yeah, but I don't think that's reasonable to do. If you live in the U.S. you know this is a problem, choosing to still do it is more damning.
- StavrosK 9y agoI think the disagreement here lies in that people think "given that the police is likely to kill someone, the person who called in an innocent man is a murderer", and I agree. However, I contend that the police should not be likely to kill someone, exactly because they might be killing innocent people. The police are the ones with guns and ostensible training.
- anigbrowl 9y agoThere are people right here in this thread who think the shooting was justified because the guy at the house didn't follow instructions carefully enough and the police (supposedly) had to assume the worst.
- ryanwaggoner 9y agoThe obvious answer is: because you think they ARE armed, and if you wait until they start shooting at you, it’s too late.
- StavrosK 9y agoAnd if it turns out they weren't armed, you were way, way too early.
- joshuamorton 9y agoThe US military rules of engagement disagree.
- Silhouette 9y agoThis was apparently a SWAT team that initiated a confrontation in response to a report of a situation involving firearms. Why weren't they already behind cover so that if the guy really did come out of the door shooting at them, they were protected? And if they were, why was it necessary to shoot first when the situation obviously wasn't clear at all? Nothing about this adds up.
- valuearb 9y agoToo late for what? What do you think will happen if a shirtless man on a porch a pulls a pistol, while you have your high powered rifle's scope locked on their chest while you are wearing body armor, positioned behind a police car, a few hundred feet away?
- anigbrowl 9y agoWe have 1 possibly-armed-with-a-handgun guy of unknown intent and ability on a porch, vs 5+ SWAT officers who are definitely trained in shooting people, are in cover, have body armor, rifles (presumably good ones with scopes and whatever else), and high-powered lights trained on the house. So yeah, I would say they should wait until a suspect starts shooting because they have an overwhelming tactical advantage. Yes, that's a risk because the guy on the porch might be John Wick or Jason Bourne or the Terminator, but most people, even most professional criminals, are not expert marksmen under any circumstances, let alone ones where they're at a large tactical disadvantage. Next time you meet a cop socially, ask them if criminals are smart or supervillains 'like in the movies' The cop will laugh and regale you with stories of how dumb and inept most criminals are. Police know perfectly well that most people don't have a clue, are easily intimidated by police, and not super-skilled. Sure, they have to consider the small number of dangerous exceptions, but overstating the risk factors is also a really convenient way to get off the hook for their own poor firing discipline.
- chrismcb 9y agoHow do you know he didn't have a gun? You were told her has a gun, you get to the house and the person letters his arm and then raises it and starts pointing it at a fellow officer... What do you do? I don't think this particular incident is as cut and dry as you think it is.
- ams6110 9y ago> How can you mistake anything someone unarmed does for a deadly threat? A person's bare hands can represent a deadly threat if he is close enough. Not that that was the case in this situation.
- learc83 9y agoNot to multiple trained, armed, and armored men it doesn't, which is normally the case with police shootings.