4 ms·
What kind of investigation would you suggest take place before hand about a situation where there is supposedly a person with hostages who has already killed on
by oh_sigh 9y ago
What kind of investigation would you suggest take place before hand about a situation where there is supposedly a person with hostages who has already killed one?
- rbetts 9y agoA situation that doesn't include the "supposedly" qualification you make. A single anonymous source on a non-911 number without corroborating reports of gunfire is not sufficient cause to shoot a man on his porch. Here's an idea -- fly a drone around the house and look in some windows. Knock on a neighbors door and ask if they heard a gunshot. Establish the identity of the reporter - how does the reporter know what is happening? Is the reporter physically proximate to the area?
- oh_sigh 9y ago> A single anonymous source on a non-911 number without corroborating reports of gunfire is not sufficient cause to shoot a man on his porch. No one is arguing that. > Here's an idea -- fly a drone around the house and look in some windows. Knock on a neighbors door and ask if they heard a gunshot. That sounds great. Until there is an actual hostage situation, and police waste their time doing this and a hostage is killed, at which point people will be asking why they didn't kick the doors down if they knew someone was being held in there. > Establish the identity of the reporter - how does the reporter know what is happening? Is the reporter physically proximate to the area? The reporter claimed to be the person who killed his father and was holding other people hostage. How would you confirm if the reporter was physically in the area? E911 includes location reporting, but this can be spoofed(I don't know if it was in the situation)
- valuearb 9y agoThis isn't the movies, cops should never be kicking down the door in a hostage situation. They should be guarding the perimeter and trying to talk to the perpetrator.
- isostatic 9y agoWhich is exactly what happens in the movies - die hard for example.
- valuearb 9y agoIt was the only realistic part of the film.
- oh_sigh 9y agoI'm curious - how much training do you have in SWAT tactics? Where did you get it from? Assuming it is zero, would you in whatever field you are in accept advice from someone who has zero experience in the field?
- valuearb 9y agoDo you think SWAT tactics are designed with minimizing civilian casualties? Or SWAT team casualties?
- alkonaut 9y agoCould be a simple as calling the suspects phone or knocking doors at neighbors. If the suspect answered the phone and said he was asleep and said he would be happy to show the officers around his house, maybe things would have gone differently.
- oh_sigh 9y agoDid you listen to the audio? The person calling 911 was the supposed suspect he claimed to have killed his father, so I'm not sure how you would contact the suspect without just getting the same 'prankster' again. Knocking on doors of the neighbors sounds great, but does it give you any useful information if no one heard a gun shot? What if he shot his dad in the basement, or the walls of the house are thick enough to block the sound. You still need to go in and check even if every neighbor said they didn't hear anything. Also, knocking on doors wastes what may be valuable time in a real hostage situation.
- leesalminen 9y agoI still don’t see how calling a phone number associated with that address and seeing who picks up could hurt anything. This phone call could’ve occurred while SWAT was deploying to the scene. They only could’ve gained by doing this.
- oh_sigh 9y agoIf it was real, and the hostage taker picked up, he could say everything was fine. What do you do then? Calling seems like a good idea but I'm not sure it provides any actionable information.
- valuearb 9y agoThen you tell your team there is a high likeylhood of a false call, and maybe they don't keep their fingers on hair triggers.
- leesalminen 9y ago
- jdietrich 9y agoThe video below shows how the British police handled a high-risk incident - a report of a mentally ill man wandering the streets in his pyjamas, brandishing a handgun. The suspect is believed to have returned to his flat by the time they arrive on scene, so the officers literally knock on his door and politely ask if he has a gun. With the right training, American officers can behave in exactly the same manner. https://youtu.be/LKVyu1sodOU?t=3m35s https://youtu.be/LKVyu1sodOU?t=3m35s