7 ms·
I'm surprised the author spent so much money building on top of a base bike of such low quality. That department store bike is what bike snobs would call a "bi
by CydeWeys 9y ago
I'm surprised the author spent so much money building on top of a base bike of such low quality. That department store bike is what bike snobs would call a "bicycle-shaped object". You certainly shouldn't not be cheaping out on the actual bicycle for an e-bike, as you're putting the bike (and particularly the brakes) through forces they were not properly designed for. The author even admits such:
> The brakes are often too soft to handle continuous elevated speed. What ends up happening is that I spend more money overtime to upgrade the bike to my desired state. So far I spent about $1500, including parts and tools, this is accounting for a fairly cheap used bike on craigslist ($200). Had I bought a new bike, I would have had to spend probably close to $1900. To make it exactly the way I want it, I estimate that I have to spend an additional $800 to get install IGH, bigger brakes, and more efficient tires with less rolling resistance.
Frankly, the author's setup just sounds dangerous. The several-$K all-in-one bicycles that they refused to get on grounds of cost are expensive because they are actually built to handle the rigors of e-bike usage, and have incredibly useful features like hydraulic disc brakes. The brakes on that department store bike are "disc" brakes, but they're certainly not hydraulic, or even good, at that price point.
- username223 9y agoThis. For the $1500 the author spent, he could have bought a decent bike instead of strapping a motor on a $200 piece of cast-iron junk. Plus, a 1000-watt motor is ridiculous: that's the kind of power generated by a pro sprinter, and over twice what a pro climber generates on average. A 100-watt boost would be enough of an advantage to make most hills easy, and would probably weigh and cost far less.
- jordache 9y ago> $200 piece of cast-iron junk. He used an alu bike... mechanical disc brakes worked for a decade before hydraulics.
- username223 9y ago> He used an alu bike... My bad -- the name "IRON HORSE" threw me off. Still, the thing supposedly weighs 37.75 lbs., which is terrible for a bike. For $1500, he could get something with much better parts weighing 20-25 lbs.
- jordache 9y agoIn an e-bike assisted context, the extra 10-15 lb, most of which is non-rotational weight is negligible. A 20-25 lb steel bike with sufficient robustness does not really exist for $1500. Something like a surly ogre is about 30lbs. To shave off that extra 5-10 lbs you're looking at some very performance oriented parts and/or construction with extremely elevated prices.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoIt wasn't that hard to find 20 pound aluminum road bikes before CF took over.
- jordache 9y agouhhh you don't want to electrify a 20lbs alum road bike. when electrifying you value robustness over light weight. The energy from the motor more than makes up for the few extra lbs it has to haul.
- CydeWeys 9y agoYeah, some people don't realize that what you want to electrify is more akin to a hardtail mountain bike. You want big sturdy tires that can handle hitting an imperfection in the road at high speed, and front suspension helps for the same reason. Bigger tires allow for better braking, too. Riding an electrified road bike at 30 mph all the time sounds terrifying and potentially dangerous.
- eesmith 9y agoAhem. Speaking with mock outrage, as someone who goes bike camping with front and back panniers and a tent, I'll point out that my bike is about 40 lbs, unloaded. Eg, https://www.koga.com/en/bikes/trekking/collection/worldtraveller.htm?frame=H https://www.koga.com/en/bikes/trekking/collection/worldtrave... . ;) 'Course, my average speed is about 8mph. I like to stop, look at things, and read the signs, and sometimes travel along hard-pack dirt roads. Their e-trekking bike is about 54 lbs. I know what I'm going to get for myself when I get older.
- dmurray 9y ago100 watts would turn it back into a manual bike with some electrical assist. There's a place for that, but it's clear the author was looking for something more.
- mantas 9y agoE-bikes are bicycles with electrical assist. Fully motorised bikes are mopeds or, well, motor bikes.
- dmurray 9y agoYeah, I'd count the author's bike as being pretty close to being a moped. Except that it might get regulated as an e-bike, and it is possible to use it as a normal heavy bicycle if he wants or if the motor fails.
- ebikelaw 9y agoThe law in many US states and most European countries views the machine in this article as a moped or motorcycle. It is throttle-operated, instead of being proportional to pedal torque, and it has no speed limiter. If it was limited to 20MPH, it could be a "class 2" or "type 2" e-bike in many jurisdictions. If it was pedal-operated and limited to 28 MPH, it could be a "class 3" e-bike. But as built, it's a moped. You need a license, registration, insurance, and a helmet to operate it.
- iamnothere 9y agoMaybe the author lives in a state where this is fine? Not all places have the same laws. The author made a cool thing and did everyone the service of documenting the process. Why is everyone so quick to crap on his project?
- Fricken 9y agoIf you can pedal it, it's a bicycle.
- amiga-workbench 9y agoI don't think you have tried out an eBike before, 1000W is just about enough to make most inclines easy. If I drop my BLDC controller down to 250W it makes things rather difficult. Remember you are carrying around the extra weight of a battery pack and motor.
- revelation 9y agoMost humans can't sustain 250W on a simple ergometer for 20 minutes. At 1000W, you are a motorcycle, not a bike. If that is what you want, fine, but then stick to roads, stay off bike paths.
- CydeWeys 9y agoAre those two figures comparable though? Is an electric bicycle motor measured by its power draw or by its output? And either way, it's still not the same because at most that'd be measuring at the crank, whereas an ergometer measures at the pedal. So if I had to guess I'd say that a 1000W electric motor is roughly equivalent to, say, 500W output from a human on an ergometer (which of course is still way better than the average person can perform for any length of time).
- revelation 9y agoIt's hard to build an inefficient electric motor, and I'd think the headline figure is the motor power rating. But even if we assume it's the power draw and the motor itself is terribly inefficient, we're still talking 80% efficiency? Chain drive is 95% efficient if badly maintained, but then the human power loses that, too, so we don't need to consider it. So we're still talking 800W, which is 3-4 times as much as needed to sustain 20 mph on flat ground, and utterly out of range of any human for any time period beyond a minute. The power and speed limit of normal ebikes is a feature. It keeps us from making the same mistake we have with cars, which only ever got faster while driving discipline declined and were at any point beyond human ability anyway.
- 9y ago
- yilunzh 9y agoYup, the brakes is definitely the limiting factor currently, but other parts of the bike have held up surprisingly well. I didn't really know anything about bikes before starting this, so it was a cheap way to learn. I figured I can always upgrade the parts over time if needed. I had set a max budget of $1500 for the initial purchase and had to make tradeoff somewhere.
- fjsolwmv 9y agoIt's a cool project but it's not about "(riding) e-bikes", it's about "learning e-bike design by experiment"
- quickben 9y agoI've been getting interested in e-bikes recently. Work is 15km away, but I do weight near 0.1 [t] :) Hows the battery holding if you carry extra weight? How much does the total setup, you included, weights?
- alfla 9y agoI can comment on the range. I have a similar bike with a 540Wh battery. Total weight close to 20 kg, maximum practical range approx 30-40 km. Slightly less when sub zero C temp. Edit: I would consider an extra charger and charge at work for that range, in case you want to stop by somewhere on your way to or back from work.
- yilunzh 9y agoMy bike is around 50 lbs. I weight about 150 lbs. I often carry a bag about 20 lbs. So all in, it's about 200 lbs or ~90KG. I think my battery pack can go about 50 miles per charge, but I never went that far on a single charge. I usually charge after 30 miles to ease strain on battery, but that should still be plenty for you to get to work and back.
- tyldum 9y agoI get 40km out of a 400Wh battery with similar weight. About half in cold weather with snow and studded tires. The tires seem to be the main reason for the reduced mileage. This is in sport mode with maximum assistance and going full speed.
- mscb 9y agoSince 3 years and >10.000km I use a self made eBike based on a 250€ bike from Decathlon with a self made controller [1]. It is a sturdy bike with properly functioning brakes - and I have gone up to plenty of mountain passes including the Col de la Bonette (2800m) [2]. The reason to take a low budget bike is that it is less likely to be stolen - and if it happens I'll just buy a new one. The advantage of a DIY eBike is that you can repair it yourself. Plenty of ebike dealers have no knowledge of the electronics and if something stops working, then the bike gets send back to the factory. As it is a seasonal business you may be without a bike for weeks in summer time. [1] https://hackaday.io/project/25337-smart-bldc-controller-for-ebikes-with-ble https://hackaday.io/project/25337-smart-bldc-controller-for-... [2] http://cyclehikemap.eu/mymaps/view.php?id=72 http://cyclehikemap.eu/mymaps/view.php?id=72 http://cyclehikemap.eu/mymaps/view.php?id=71 http://cyclehikemap.eu/mymaps/view.php?id=71
- brianpgordon 9y agoI bought a pretty basic no-frills bike (https://www.feltbicycles.com/USA/2016/Bikes/lifestyle/Urban/brougham-2.aspx https://www.feltbicycles.com/USA/2016/Bikes/lifestyle/Urban/...) and used the same conversion kit that the author of this post uses (Bafang BBS02 from LunaCycle - less than $100 for a local bike shop to install). I've been riding my e-bike to work for several months and the caliper brakes that came with the bike have held up fine. They have enough braking power that it feels safe, and don't seem to be wearing too badly. So I don't think you need disc brakes at all. The only problem I've had with the underlying bike is one incident where I slammed on the throttle from a full stop and the motor wrenched the whole back axle out of its alignment and jammed the wheel at an angle to the body of the bike. I guess the nuts securing the axle had worked themselves loose. Luckily I was close to work and was able to walk my bike in, and bring some tools the next day to loosen and re-tighten the nuts. Overall I think it's been great. I wouldn't go back and buy a more expensive bike if I could. The nearly car-like prices of "good" bikes are too much.
- prophetjohn 9y agoFelt is a legitimate, reputable bicycle manufacturer, though. It is much higher quality than a department store bike.
- CydeWeys 9y agoIt's also steel, which is probably better in an electric bike where you don't care about weight as much but you do care about durability.
- Xylakant 9y agoGood steel frames are not necessarily significantly heavier than aluminum frames but they ride much much better (have more flex). They also can be repaired if required while aluminum is probably toast after anything that damages the frame. In anything that is not a race or cargo bike I’d always prefer a steel frame.
- 9y ago