5 ms·
The Data That Threatened to Break Physics
- troismph 9y agoNonzero mass particles traveling at the speed of light, the very fact itself is astonishing enough.
- danbruc 9y agoNeutrinos are generally expected to travel a tiny bit slower than the speed of light. Nobody really expects them to travel at the speed of light even if we are currently unable to measure the tiny difference.
- analog31 9y agoI was a physics student in 1987, when neutrinos were captured from a far-away supernova. I rushed into my professor's office and asked breathlessly: "Does the timing of the observations give us a limit on the mass of the neutrino?" He calmly replied: Sorry, kid. Somebody already submitted a paper on that.
- peter303 9y agoThe neutrinos arrived 3 hours before the photons. Thats 1/500,000,000 difference. Plenty of things could have slowed the photons.
- analog31 9y agoThat raises an interesting thought: Does interstellar space have a non-unity refractive index? If there's any kind of matter out there, then I suppose the answer has to be yes. But I wonder if it's quantifiable.
- Koshkin 9y agoThe term 'speed of light' is somewhat confusing. Just to clarify: there's the universal maximum speed, c; this is the speed with which light travels in the vacuum; in a medium light happens to slow down, while neutrinos do not, the result of which is their moving not slower, but even "faster than light."
- oldandtired 9y agothe speed of light is based on two specific values of the medium in which the photons are travelling. The permeability and the permittivity, one affects the magnetic the other affects the electric. Hence by the change of these two values, the speed of light (magnitude) changes. Hence, if we are able to create media in which these values are appropriately specified, we can create media in which the specific speed of light is less than c0 or greater than c0. It, therefore, may be possible to create a medium in which light will pass through faster than a vacuum.
- hn_throwaway_99 9y agoThis quote is so very true, and it drives me nuts: > “Society likes black and white,” he answers. But answers in science are not always so cleanly resolved. “We have to be careful because if we give the impression that science never says yes or no, says always maybe, then people say, ‘Well, then I should not trust science.’ It is very delicate how to give this message.” It reminded me of some of the polls before the 2016 US Presidential Election. Nate Silver at the time gave Trump about a 30% chance of winning, and when Trump won, there were lots of "Even Nate Silver got it wrong!" comments. Most people really don't understand the difference between anything less than 50/50 and 0, and it becomes a real challenge to explain things when reality works in probabilities at a fundamental level.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- maxxxxx 9y agoSame for 20% chance of rain. People are surprised when it actually rains.
- mehrdadn 9y agoI'm not sure that's the best example. Probability of precipitation (PoP) is simply a misleading measure by itself. It has a threshold of >0.01 in for what is considered "rain". So if there's only a 20% chance that you'll get a minimum 0.01 in of rain, you'd naturally expect a low chance for it to be be much higher, and hence would expect not to get wet that day. The problem here is that a guaranteed 10 inches of rain over 20% of the area would still give you a 20% "chance of rain", which would still result in a 20% PoP, which is not what you would want for a useful measure of rain.
- orf 9y agoYeah, and then those same people conflate predictions with polls: "urgh are these polls that gave Clinton a 95% chance of winning? I'll just ignore it then". No, /u/MAGATrumpforever96, no they are not.
- deleted 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- everdev 9y agoWhat they discovered after years of testing seems like the most obvious: a few nanosecond delay was found in the timing devices. I understand that it was difficult to time the timers, but that does seem like the first place to start.
- m_mueller 9y agofrom the text it seems like a cable was different between experiment and the validation process. Thing is, they did a further (bunched) experiment two months later, and there it was wrong again? I have a bit trouble believing that chain of events. Seems more likely to me that someone wasn't careful when checking it in between these experiments.
- grigjd3 9y agoI still find the effort at self-examination this team underwent to be heroic, especially considering the public pressure. This, to me, represents the very best science - work that goes to extreme lengths to find their source of error.
- beautifulfreak 9y agoEreditato was worried about giving an interview, but I'd say the author (Ransom Stephens) did a good job of conveying the truth of the story. I feel nothing but sympathy for Ereditato. Imagine the pressure he faced, being in charge of this experiment with results consistently showing faster-than-light neutrinos, having to be the spokesman for such an enormous and expensive project with such crazy results. The potential for embarrassment due to the no confidence vote might have been exploited by a less decent writer, but Eriditato seemed less concerned with his own reputation than the proper telling of how science works. Many scientists hoped that something weird had actually been discovered, some new physics, so it was a big letdown for them when it was all traced to the timing mechanism, and those egos are probably still smarting from hoping for the still-impossible. There must be a lot of people who have an axe to grind, even now. It's good to be able to see into the human side of science, to see how things can go wrong and how it can affect people, especially those who are in charge of organizations. It must be great to be in charge when everything goes smoothly, but otherwise, uh oh.
- tw1010 9y agoWhenever people say that there's new research that threatens to crumble the foundations of mathematics (like Banach–Tarski) or physics, I try to remind myself that this is mostly just academic. Don't get me wrong, it's important work. But bridges and buildings won't collapse as a consequence of accepting or denying the axiom of choice.
- jjoonathan 9y agoTime travel could collapse (or build) a great number of bridges and buildings. Nuclear physics, a comparatively trivial academic accomplishment, did collapse a great number of bridges and buildings, and stood a very real chance of collapsing all of the bridges and buildings. It still might.
- SCHiM 9y agoIt will, it's now simply a numbers game. Let's not kid ourselves, one day a two nuclear powers will escalate and then we'll get to see if our doomsday predictions were correct ;)