3 ms·
Us trying to colonize Mars now would be like the British trying to colonize the Americas with nothing but canoes. It's impractical with our current technology;
by scott_s 19y ago
Us trying to colonize Mars now would be like the British trying to colonize the Americas with nothing but canoes. It's impractical with our current technology; too long and too risky.
- kirubakaran 19y ago+1 but that doesn't mean we shouldn't try anyway.
- scott_s 19y agoI actually think that in this case, "too long and too risky" is prohibitive. This analysis explains why: http://www.astronomycafe.net/qadir/q2811.html http://www.astronomycafe.net/qadir/q2811.html We're not doing it now because our technology is not good enough. It's less likely to fail if we first improve our technology.
- kirubakaran 19y agoAnd we can improve technology to go to Mars by trying to go to Mars, facing obstacles while doing it and overcoming it, right?
- mechanical_fish 19y agoTempting as it is to suggest that those who advocate spending tax dollars to send humans to Mars "try" breathing vacuum for a while to see if they can "overcome" that significant obstacle to Martian colonization... I think it's actually more polite to just say "no, I'm afraid you're wrong". No. I'm afraid you're wrong.
- epi0Bauqu 19y agoI think that underestimates the state of our technology and its potential for growth by orders of magnitude.
- mechanical_fish 19y agoThat is the understatement of the millennium. The Polynesians actually did colonize the remote islands of the Pacific with nothing but canoes. No problem. The difference is that they found fresh water and air on, e.g., Easter Island. To say nothing of the edible plants and the fish. And it took them at least several hundred years to cut down all the trees. By contrast, I estimate that the Martian forests will take approximately 0 years to be totally harvested -- which is just as well, because the Martian lumberjacks will be scared to take out an axe lest they accidentally slice open their pressurized suits.
- scott_s 19y agoI read National Geographic this month, too. Which is why I chose the Atlantic, because island-hopping is not possible.
- mechanical_fish 19y agoNow is when I wish that the real Vikings wore those cool horned helmets. Because I just had this awesome vision of Leif Ericsson, horns and all, glowering at you with the entire population of Iceland, Norse Greenland, the Faeroes, and the Shetlands arrayed behind him and Led Zeppelin's Immigrant Song playing in the background. [1] In other words: I'm guessing that the Atlantic is still five or six orders of magnitude more navigable than outer space. ;) I haven't read National Geographic in years, actually, although I might go check it out just to read about the Polynesians. [1] If you find yourself wondering what I'm talking about, be sure to google "Immigrant Song Kittens".
- scott_s 19y agoNote that I deliberately said "canoes."