3 ms·
>I've hurt myself far less playing rugby than soccer, Respectfully, self-assessment is exactly the wrong approach here. Play soccer, break a leg. Obvious - le
by Havoc 9y ago
>I've hurt myself far less playing rugby than soccer,
Respectfully, self-assessment is exactly the wrong approach here.
Play soccer, break a leg. Obvious - leg is broken. Play rugby, lose 5% mental ability - less obvious especially in a self(!)-assessment of one's mental ability.
>Also, the objective of Rugby
I've been on the receiving side of some nasty rugby tackles...including the type where I don't remember a lot about them. So yes I do understand the objective of Rugby and all that great stuff.
>In fact, we were often encouraged to avoid contact whenever possible and to pass the ball whenever we could.
If everyone plays a clean textbook version then that works out well. In my experience putting a bunch of determined testosterone fuelled guys on a field does not result in textbook clean though. Not even close.
Rugby/Boxing/NFL/whatever...consider this. 99% of NFL post mortems show CTE. Not just a few - 99%. Lets suppose Rugby is way better like literally halves the risk despite both similar contact sports but lets pretend Rugby is way better. Can you really "recommend the sport to anyone young enough" at 49% CTE risk? Telling me about training how to fall is just not going to cut it.
So yes "risky at best" is my assessment of the situation.
http://edition.cnn.com/2017/07/25/health/cte-nfl-players-brains-study/index.html http://edition.cnn.com/2017/07/25/health/cte-nfl-players-bra...