4 ms·
Online banking isn’t a serious attack vector for fraud, it’s just a faster-updating alternative to a paper monthly statement. 2FA is a silly red herring in thes
by closeparen 9y ago
Online banking isn’t a serious attack vector for fraud, it’s just a faster-updating alternative to a paper monthly statement. 2FA is a silly red herring in these discussions. The problem is fundamentally the transaction model where you pull money from someone’s account simply by knowing some widely-shared secret numbers. These systems are sticky due to network effects. There’s no reason to sign up for an alternative to Visa/MC or ACH when your counterparties aren’t going to.
- mindslight 9y agoPerversely, initiating an ACH credit is apparently seen as more risky than receiving an ACH debit. I believe this is ultimately due to the originator being responsible for any transaction that turns out to be fraudulent. In general I think the US is comfortable to limp along putting band-aids on broken systems, because the failings are seen as being intrinsic to the "natural state" of things (see also: common law and court precedent reigning), and the losses are ultimately sustainable. The possibility of a fraudulent transaction can never be eliminated, so therefore it's whatever party facilitates/blesses the transaction that fully bears the responsibility. Meanwhile the EU doesn't seem afraid to create new foundational semantics - eg get rid of the concept of "pulling" money, and then dictate that banks cannot charge customers for the equivalent of initiating an ACH push [0]. [0] Bank of America actually charges for this. They also charge for walk-in cashing of checks drawn on themselves - meaning they are inducing their own customers to write fraudulent checks!
- closeparen 9y agoNo one is eating the risk, it's simply priced in as a 2-3% sales tax paid to the credit card network ecosystem.
- mindslight 9y agoI was referring to ACH, not credit cards. Also, something you said in a related comment: > tiny proportion of the most technologically sophisticated banks provide the ability to transfer money to any arbitrary person My experience is that every US bank has an "external account" transfer feature (for use with your other accounts) that can initiate ACH credits or debits, as well as a "Bill Pay" that will do ACH credits to any routing/account number. But (as I alluded to) banks limit the dollar amount of transactions initiated through them, as they are responsible for cleaning up any mess due to "fraud".
- RandomInteger4 9y agoWhen you say fraud, do you mean theft or identity fraud? 2FA is extraordinarily relevant when it comes to theft with regard to online banking. The purpose of 2FA is mostly to prevent automated attacks or remote account entry via password resets by email or something similar. I'm not sure if you're aware, but Europe has proper 2FA in the form of a dongle type device, and not this SMS BS many companies in the US use out of laziness. They also need to use this device for not just online banking, but basic everyday transactions.
- closeparen 9y ago>2FA is extraordinarily relevant when it comes to theft with regard to online banking If theft through online banking even exists, it's at such a low volume as to be irrelevant. Most online banking interfaces are a read-only view of recent transactions. Some provide the ability to transfer funds between your own linked accounts at the same bank. Fewer still provide bill pay for a specific set of partner institutions, and a tiny proportion of the most technologically sophisticated banks provide the ability to transfer money to any arbitrary person. When they do, adding a new payee is loud (sends a bunch of notifications) and requires SMS verification and/or digits off your debit card. The transfer is loud and takes several days to actually happen (so you can cancel it), and is limited to a couple thousand dollars at most. This is a fringe thing that a handful of people use occasionally. Most peer-to-peer transfers are going to happen through Venmo, which piggy-backs off a debit card, or through paper checks. Most online bill pay is going to happen by giving the biller your account and routing number. The largest vector by far for stealing from a bank account is capturing a debit card number in some legitimate transaction, and reusing it to make fraudulent transactions. The strength of the communication channel between payer's bank and payer is irrelevant, because you don't get to weigh in on debit card transactions (or checks) against your account. They just happen, and then you can dispute them later.
- evfanknitram 9y ago> and a tiny proportion of the most technologically sophisticated banks provide the ability to transfer money to any arbitrary person. In the country where I live all internet banks supports this. And all of course use 2FA. Most if not all banks here let's me do any kind or transactions. Not just viewing my data but transferring money, buying stock, setting up new bank accounts, pension management and everything else. Maybe it's the lack of security at your place which prevents useful functionality.