4 ms·
Ok, so how installing a shunt on a blocked artery can possibly not work? (Not alleviating chest pain is "understandable", not reducing the risk of heart attacks
by raverbashing 9y ago
Ok, so how installing a shunt on a blocked artery can possibly not work? (Not alleviating chest pain is "understandable", not reducing the risk of heart attacks makes no sense to me)
This article makes some "hand waves" about how understanding of the disease was simplified https://www.vox.com/science-and-health/2017/11/3/16599072/stent-chest-pain-treatment-angina-not-effective https://www.vox.com/science-and-health/2017/11/3/16599072/st... but the fact is blocked arteries don't let blood flow.
- jayd16 9y agoMaybe they didn't need it in the first place, maybe the blockage is treated by the medication regemine and not surgery maybe it causes other complications so it's a wash, maybe just because it seems like the mechanism should 'just work' it doesn't.
- davak 9y agoZillions of reasons. If you miss your meds, that stent can abruptly occlude and cause death. Maybe you open one large vessel but the downstream vessels are clogged—even microscopically. Place enough useless stents and you’ll hurt patients from dye, bleeding, infection, etc. On the other hand, studies of procedures are done on very narrow patient populations. Our patients often don’t fit into those perfect boxes. What’s “needless” is difficult. As long as folks get paid per procedure, it adds bias that favors doing instead of not doing.
- joshgel 9y agoSo ya that's what all cardiologists thought. Many still think this. They may even be right. But we don't have EVIDENCE that this does anything to prevent death, heart attacks or even reduce chest pain. To be clear though, they aren't talking about ACUTELY closed arteries as in a heart attack or myocardial infarction, when there is a plaque rupture and a blood thrombus that develops to cut off blood supply suddenly. But rather, when blood flow, which has been slowly narrowing over years, starts causing chest pain on physical exertion, when the heart muscle distal to the narrowing is asking for more oxygen than the artery can supply. We put stents in a lot of these people, because we like to try to help them, but there isn't much evidence that it helps. It may help, but we haven't been able to prove it yet. Or it may help select people, but we don't know which people to select. But many will still keep getting these stents. Medicine is tricky.