3 ms·
>> That ensures an environment where a huge swathe of the player base will never get the chance to play with, say, a Black Lotus or a Time Walk. Weeell, that's
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
>> That ensures an environment where a huge swathe of the player base will never get the chance to play with, say, a Black Lotus or a Time Walk.
Weeell, that's not strictly true. Anyone can "play with a Black Lotus"- just not in a sanctioned game. There is nothing Wizards (or anyone, really) can do to stop you from printing out copies of any M:tG card you wish and play with it against your friends, with similarly copied cards. The only requirement is that your opponents agree to it.
In fact, the practice is quite common among competitive players, common enough to have a name: the practice of copying the cards is called "proxying", the copies themselves "proxies". In the case of competitive players, they are useful because one needs to practice with a deck even when they don't have the necessary cards at hand (competitive players will often borrow their cards from friends, or even trade in the last minute, just before a tournament). On the other hand, although this is completely a guess, my hunch is that casual players would be much more averse to accepting proxies in their game, than competitive players are.
I digress. My point is that perhaps it's not just Wizards' promise to not reprint the cards on the reserved list that is keeping their prices high (and rising), it's also the willingness of the M:tG playerbase to embrace organised play, in the way it's provided as a service by Wizards. Players buy cards, yes, but they also buy a whole set of social conventions regarding their use, including the rules of the game (nothing stopping you and your friends for making up your own rules...) and the rules of Organised Play.
I guess I'd go as far as to say that what's important to the players is not really the physical cards themselves -the Power Nine and so on- but the opportunity to take part in more or less organised events, with clearly defined rules, enforced by an impartial authority (who happens to be the same people who sell the game).
In that sense, the cards will only ever go out of fashion when the game itself does- and that will happen when Wizards is no longer able to support it financially.