3 ms·
> We live in a culture where it has been rubbed into us that to die is a terrible thing. Not nearly enough, or we'd do more about it on a systematic basic. It'
by JoshTriplett 9y ago
> We live in a culture where it has been rubbed into us that to die is a terrible thing.
Not nearly enough, or we'd do more about it on a systematic basic. It's an abstract kind of professing of it being terrible (leaving aside people who don't even manage to do that much), without any of the concrete action that could take place if it was actually treated as a horrific tragedy on a species-wide scale.
- ivm 9y agoI'd say it has more to do with our overall poor long-term planning capabilities.
- JoshTriplett 9y agoI'd argue it has more to do with widespread cultural taboos about what it's "acceptable" to challenge and what deviates too far from the norm.
- drb91 9y agoWell, it's certainly acceptable to challenge it, but fear of death is rather dogmatic and polarizing. Many people, from diverse backgrounds of philosophy, have submitted world views where the quality of life and your impact matters more than your length of time. Others, like many on this forum, I suspect, have argued we should be investing in fighting death and aging, using war and financial metaphors, without establishing why this is such a worthwhile fight and/or investment. Why length of life and not quality of life? For sure, they're related, but how you frame these questions will dictate the response and interest in the conversation. I doubt humans as a whole will ever feel strongly that death is a negative force. However, improving quality of life is one of the easiest pitches to make, and doesn't necessarily disproportionally value the rich. In fact, the least worthwhile place to spend improving the quality of life would be people with enough money to dictate it already. But hey—the idea of living for centuries is cool, I always wanted to be an elf.
- TeMPOraL 9y ago> without establishing why this is such a worthwhile fight and/or investment I'd say it's fundamental, and on the short-term, we all understand that as a civilization. That's why every society protects its member from threats, including crime, fire, natural disasters, famine, war. It's not just about quality - you may live the happiest of lives, up until the point a bullet enters your brain[0]. I think there are three main moral reasons for fighting death: - suffering in the process of death itself - existential suffering of knowing your time is limited, and that of knowing you're about to die - suffering of those who you leave behind Efforts against #1 connect to quality of life, and with progress on that field, it could be resolved. #2 and #3 won't go away until we achieve (effective) immortality, and for many (myself included) they are the reason to support life extension. But maybe you're right, that a stronger pitch along #1 would help gather extra support. Then there are economic debates about whether our societies could survive sudden doubling of expected lifespans, or whether we'll be able to offload people fast enough to off-world colonies. I say, we'll figure it out as we go along - it's a nice problem to have, as opposed to death. -- [0] - probably one of the most humane ways to die; one can hardly leave this world without suffering during the process of departure.
- drb91 9y ago> existential suffering of knowing your time is limited, and that of knowing you're about to die In my experience, this is largely limited to the young and sheltered. Mature people can proces death in healthy ways.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoThat's not healthy. That's a coping mechanism. It's society legitimizing what's essentially a case of Stockholm syndrome.
- drb91 9y agoWhat would a world without death LOOK like to you? How would people vie for this immortality treatement? For food? Seems like something only an absurdly rich person would want for the world.