5 ms·
Calling the Bolsheviks "an apocalyptic sect" is wrong, because they were full of what we might call "the social optimism". They tried to build a "new, happier"
by Koshkin 9y ago
Calling the Bolsheviks "an apocalyptic sect" is wrong, because they were full of what we might call "the social optimism". They tried to build a "new, happier" society on the ruins of the imperial Russia which was rotten to the core. Too bad they chose the "Red Terror" as the means to that end.
- AnimalMuppet 9y ago"Apocalypse" literally means "unveiling", but it refers to the biblical book of Revelation. Revelation describes the total destruction of the existing world, but ends with the creation of a new, better one. In the same way, the Bolsheviks were about the total destruction of the current social, economic, and political order, in order to build the new. So "apocalyptic" is a fairly accurate term.
- mamon 9y agoYeah, it's funny that the world "apocalyptic" become more or less synonymous to "catastrophic", when in fact the book of Revelation is a story with happy end :)
- thriftwy 9y ago> which was rotten to the core It was still in all senses better that anything Bolsheviks had at any point of their rule. It's too easy to kick a fallen giant.
- anigbrowl 9y agoIn fairness, their options in the civil war were either 'red terror' or a swift defeat, since the White forces (led by the aristocracy and financed and supported from abroad) had no qualms about initiating a 'White terror' to raise manpower. Forced conscription and hostage-taking among the peasantry was the historical norm and the Red Guards (the all-volunteer force that was the product of the soviets and supported the Bolsheviks) was simply too small to serve as an effective defense force. I don't know what other options they had. Mind, I'm not excusing subsequent totalitarianism, Stalinist purges etc. if you meant to include that in your post; I'm just commenting on the strategic conditions that obtained during the civil war.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoIt's not quite that they had no other options. They just had no other options to remain in power. "We must either become murderous thugs, or lose" does not necessarily imply "therefore we must become murderous thugs". It only does so if you believe "we must not lose" (or "we must remain in power") more strongly than you believe "we must not become murderous thugs". But "we must either become murderous thugs, or be murdered" does at least allow the justification of self-defense...
- anigbrowl 9y agoWell, that's my point: self-defense is generally considered a fundamental right. Having taken power with a bare minimum of violence and attempted to govern in accordance with lofty ideals (multiple parties, all-volunteer militias) the Bolsheviks quickly found themselves confronted by a coalition of antagonists - some monarchists, some capitalists, some unhappy about the large concessions made to gain armistice in WW1, and so on. Their attempts to defend against that quickly devolved into adopting the violent and often atrocious methods of their opponents. But what else should they have done - become martyrs and hope their defeat would induce some sort of guilt trip in others? That would have been to sell out the working class that they had taken up arms to liberate in the first place. And of course the horrific human cost of the Great War suggested that the ruling classes of the various western powers were unbound by any such moral considerations in the first place. I don't think self-sacrifice has any actual mileage as a political strategy.