2 ms·
we're just being good Strunk-and-Whiters and omitting needless words. What if the title was 'The Greatest Show on Earth'? The two titles have a slightly diffe
by pvg 9y ago
we're just being good Strunk-and-Whiters and omitting needless words.
What if the title was 'The Greatest Show on Earth'?
The two titles have a slightly different flavour - calling one linkbait is silly (hyperbolic, even!), as is claiming this is being 'good Strunk-and-Whiters' (beside whether 'Strunk and White is really that great a writing standard to begin with).
HN editing leans strongly towards desaturating, flavour removal and tone flattening. That's fine, but it's a preference and you should own it as such - it's not some sort of stylistic virtue. Nothing awful would have happened if you just left in the original. You just didn't like it.