5 ms·
This will sometimes result in clinicians performing painful and pointless procedures on a dying child as weeping parents stand by, watching their child’s final
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
This will sometimes result in clinicians performing painful and pointless procedures on a dying child as weeping parents stand by, watching their child’s final moments in horror, having not understood what they were signing on for.
My father had cancer in his late 60s. He wasn't expected to live. He did live about 2 more decades. But following his surgery, he spent considerable time in ICU.
At the same time, another elderly patient spent the last two weeks of their life there in ICU. They repeatedly coded and had massive intervention. Doctors routinely did things like drain a gallon of fluid from the lungs, restart their heart, etc.
My mother was pretty disgusted. She felt the family knew this woman was never going home again and these torturous treatments were not extending life. They were merely dragging out her death horrifically because the relatives were not yet ready to accept it.
In many cases, this is the better answer:
...they tell us that attempting resuscitative efforts that are likely to be futile is not consistent with their values. In these situations, rather than asking for intubation and chest compressions, parents just want to hold their child and find meaning in those final moments of contact.
- magicalhippo 9y agoMy dad had cancer in a lymph node that spread to the lungs, significantly reducing his lung capacity. After a few years of steady decline, he caught pneumonia. After a day of treatment, he knew it was all downhill from there. Doctors said further treatment would likely make him recover from the pneumonia, but that could take months, and scar tissue from the pneumonia would reduce his lung capacity further. Even before the pneumonia he was reliant on oxygen supply at home just to sit in a chair. So in the early hours of the second day, he requested they turn off the oxygen supply. A doctor got called in to ensure he knew what the consequences could be, which he did, and then they turned off the oxygen. He passed away peacefully a few hours later. Painful as it was to lose him, I'm so glad they respected his decision.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- williamdclt 9y agoIn which country did this happen? This sounds illegal in quite a lot of countries that I know of (nothing judgemental in this comment, I'm genuinely curious)
- magicalhippo 9y ago> In which country did this happen? In Norway. The cancer he had did not respond to chemo, and radiation therapy was out since it was small clusters spread all over the lungs. So there was really not much they could do. To be fair, I was a bit surprised myself, but as I said I really appreciate that he got the chance to make his own choice in the matter.
- drewbug01 9y agoIt’s not illegal to refuse treatment.
- astura 9y agoYou're wrong and/or confused, it's certainly not illegal to refuse treatment in any free country as long as the patient has all their mental facilitates and there is no danger to public health. Nobody can force you to stay attached to a machine if you don't want to be. In fact, preforming medical treatment against someone's expressed will is assult or battery and could land the doctor in prison. I think you're confusing voluntarily withdrawing of life sustaining treatment with physician assisted suicide, they are nowhere near the same thing.
- vichu 9y agoThis reminds me of a particular article[1] I read on HN on how doctors themselves prefer to approach end-of-life care and the disconnect between the treatment patients and their families usually opt for. [1] http://www.zocalopublicsquare.org/2011/11/30/how-doctors-die/ideas/nexus/ http://www.zocalopublicsquare.org/2011/11/30/how-doctors-die...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]