4 ms·
The malpractice insurance issue would be much reduced if doctors, hospitals and medical organizations wouldn't stonewall legitimate claims. I know someone whose
by maxxxxx 9y ago
The malpractice insurance issue would be much reduced if doctors, hospitals and medical organizations wouldn't stonewall legitimate claims. I know someone whose surgeon messed up a surgery. First they denied everything, then they refused compensation, then they hired private investigators to look for evidence that would discredit her. She had several other surgeons tell her verbally that the surgery was incredibly botched but no one would testify in court because they seem to have a code of silence if one doctor snitches on another he will get ostracized.
When you look at airplane crashes the investigation gets done in public and the focus is on improving procedures and not assigning individual blame. This is a much better way to handle problems.
- pdelbarba 9y agoThis is a really interesting point you bring up. I think the issue is that we look at air travel as inherently risky and as such want to do everything to reduce risk. Over the past 100 years we've come to deeply understand risk management in the space and as such are careful to only assign blame in cases of blatant negligence (he wasn't IFR rated but flew into the side of a mountain while in a cloud) while treating other accidents as learning opportunities (Ok, the pilot fucked up but the MU-2 handles differently than most planes, we should require more training in type...). The industry also had it's fair share of litigious behavior but it was generally recognized that it wasn't productive and legislation has since attempted to keep it at bay with varying degrees of effectiveness It makes me wonder why similar practices aren't followed in the medical field...
- maxxxxx 9y agoIn my view the medical boards should have a nationwide malpractice insurance that investigates, pays out quickly to the patient and then decides if procedures need to be improved or the doctor needs to be reprimanded. But as with everything else in the US medical system there is a lot of money to be made with the current status quo so nothing will change.
- pdelbarba 9y agoCouldn't agree more. The FAA-NTSB-NASA relationship doing the same thing works extremely well in the aerospace sector. The FAA creates the rules, NTSB investigates accidents and NASA handles "near miss" reporting, all working to eliminate conflict of interest. All of this creates a nice closed feedback loop. It's not without it's flaws but the fact that you can hurl yourself through the stratosphere in an aluminum tube and essentially be statistically assured survival is nothing short of miraculous, especially when compared to the early days of aviation.
- tialaramex 9y agoNote that accident investigators, including the FAA are NOT interested in blame. They are about preventing future harm which is different. As a result the accident report is specifically protected in law so that you can't use it as evidence for a lawsuit. Medics have a mechanism for preventing future harm too, it's called a mortality & morbidity conference or M&M. Again it isn't interested in assigning blame and mustn't be used as evidence in a lawsuit.
- 111_1_111 9y agoSo in summary you're saying people wouldn't sue for malpractice as often if doctors didn't defend themselves? That's completely counterintuitive. You better have some sort of evidence to back that up.
- pasbesoin 9y agoFar too much of the medical "system" in the U.S. is adversarial. All the harder to remain or get well, whilst in the middle of a fight. Sometimes doctors. Insurance (and, any number of types of insurance, depending on what's happened). Institutions (hospitals et al.). Lawyers. Then slap non-disclosure on top of it all, to make it all the more likely the next guy enters, unaware. That's my "word for the day", with respect to health care in the U.S. "Adversarial". I'm going to stop writing and just reflect on that, for a while. (And even when it's not, it can/could be. Something that hangs over the head of every clue-ful patient, as they go through the system. Maybe it's easier to be someone who doesn't follow the news and keep up on this, who goes through the system blissfully unaware and happens by chance or whatever to avoid the major pitfalls. I feel a bit guilty, writing about this when a lot of the world struggles to achieve basic coverage. But, I've had the U.S. system screw me over, significantly, more than once. I used to be more trusting. Now, I delay and delay -- which creates its own problems.)
- maxxxxx 9y agoAdversarial is a good description. I would also add "intentionally opaque"
- roenxi 9y agoIt does seem clear to me that if hospitals & medical practices were run with the same culture as the airlines (ie, a high-integrity approach to risk) the results would be measurably better. However the political processes surrounding hospitals will block this. For example, there are lobby groups in the community that literally scream blue murder if decisions like "it isn't rational to live" are made in public. In Australia, we've been fighting the good fight to get euthanasia legalised for as long as I can remember. It is slow, hard going. A system that can't let people go is simply never going to allow public investigations - it hasn't accepted that quality of life takes primacy or that death is sometimes inevitable. Medical care is very political and they cannot support the results-oriented culture of the airlines.