3 ms·
That's the prerequisite for every loan. No one is loaning anyone money with the expectation that they're going to lose money on it. The expected value of a loan
by CydeWeys 9y ago
That's the prerequisite for every loan. No one is loaning anyone money with the expectation that they're going to lose money on it. The expected value of a loan from the issuer's point of view is always positive. Around these parts, that's often because, even though the chance of losing it all is 99%, there's a 1% chance of making it back 1000X (to use an example). We're talking about profit to the issuer here, which in VC usually comes from selling the company at a greater amount later even if the company itself isn't yet profitable.
That doesn't apply to lending money to money-losing small businesses. There's no small chance of making a much larger return than what you lent. The risk is still high for such a loan, but without the possibility of a much greater return. The interest on that loan is what it is; it's not like you're buying ownership in a company like with typical VC equity.
- pjc50 9y agoEquity is very different from a loan.
- CydeWeys 9y agoAnd yet that's clearly what the person I was responding to was referring to when they said "Since when is being able to turn a profit a prerequisite for getting loaned money here?" Also, the principle I'm talking about, that of positive expected value, applies equally to equity and to loans.
- saas_co_de 9y ago> money-losing small businesses The original quote from the article said that the business was profitable, just not profitable enough to justify the owner's investment. In other words, they need capital to scale in order to be profitable enough to justify the owner's time spent on the business. It is only the poster who made the broad sweeping and wrong statement that small town businesses in general can't make money. That statement has no empirical support whatsoever and is just an unfounded assumption, which you are repeating, and seem to be basing your thinking on.
- realicysm 9y ago> No one is loaning anyone money with the expectation that they're going to lose money on it. The expected value of a loan from the issuer's point of view is always positive. Well put. But I also find wisdom in the expression "Banks will always be there for you when they need you. They will never be there for you when you need them." The psychology of loss aversion dominates the behavior of lenders big and small. I've seen people I otherwise consider quite smart expect that they can convince holders of capital in various forms (from credit unions and community banks to the giants) to lend to solid small businesses unable to grow due to cash flow constraints. As you point out, the VC world will place bets on expansion, but only with the prospect of exponential growth and exit. Banks increasingly seem uninterested in business lending at all, when they used to lend with the expectation of a reasonable but not extravagant return. I guess payment processing and retail fees are more lucrative and carry less downside risk - until the retail customers dry up and blow away because all the small businesses that used to use credit are gone. But I'll be retired by then, so who cares, right?