3 ms·
When my kids were beginning to read, we brought out the books by Laura Ingalls Wilder (Little house on the Prairie etc). For our international readers, the book
by analog31 9y ago
When my kids were beginning to read, we brought out the books by Laura Ingalls Wilder (Little house on the Prairie etc). For our international readers, the books are autobiographical, and she grew up in the North Woods of the central US in the late 19th century.
Reading them as an adult really impressed me that her family was remarkably close to the "landholding peasant" model that you describe. As the family moved from one settlement to another, the description of possessions that they brought along suggests that they were accumulating basically zero wealth, for quite a time period.
And at that point, the industrial revolution was already running full steam (literally) in the eastern US and in Europe.
- eesmith 9y agoIt is autobiographical, but also fictionalized. Bear in mind that Laura Ingalls Wilder had help from her daughter, Rose Wilder Lane, who is one of the founders of the American libertarian movement. Quoting from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rose_Wilder_Lane https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rose_Wilder_Lane : > In late 1930, Lane's mother approached her with a rough, first-person narrative manuscript outlining her hardscrabble pioneer childhood, Pioneer Girl. Lane, using her sense of what was marketable, took notice. She recognized that an American public weary of the Depression would respond warmly to the story of the loving, self-sufficient and determined Ingalls family overcoming obstacles while maintaining their sense of independence, as told through the eyes of the spunky "Laura". What you read was therefore likely selected to appeal to that vision of independent landholding peasants. That said, the Wilders did depend on markets to live. They depended on a rifle, and on metal tools (including sewing needles), and tin pots. Nor do they make their own cloth. I'll quote some lines from "Little House in the Big Woods": > The nearest town was far away. Laura and Mary had never seen a town. They had never seen a store. They had never seen even two houses standing together. But they knew that in a town there were many houses, and a store full of candy and calico and other wonderful things--powder, and shot, and salt, and store sugar. The calico, powder, and shot were essentials. Likely salt too, though it may simply be much easier to get from the store than naturally, rather like store sugar vs. maple sugar/snow sugar. You can also see some of the "compelled competition, where they must extract constantly increasing productivity from their laborers in order to maintain their status" in Chapter 12: "The Wonderful MACHINE", when the threshers come with machinery which in one day with four men and eight horses can harvest as much wheat as four men could in two weeks. This is seen as progress, but once everyone does it, the prices will drop, and future farmers must then seek out ever more productivity. It is the Osage, in "Little House on the Prairie", who best fit efficax's description of a people who were not dependent on market dependence.
- analog31 9y agoThanks for those notes. I assumed that they had some contact with markets, but I didn't know about the fictionalized aspect of the books. Well, they were still entertaining. ;-)
- eesmith 9y agoDon't get me wrong. Many of the events are real, or based on real stories. There is an avid amateur historian/fan community which has tracked down the details, including newspaper articles from the time that specifically mention some of the events which occur. For instance, Mary's illness is mentioned in the local paper twice, according to this paper which argues that it was likely meningoencephalitis, not scarlet fever, which caused her illness and subsequent blindness. Interview at https://www.npr.org/2013/02/07/171413261/laura-ingalls-sister-may-not-have-lost-eyesight-to-scarlet-fever https://www.npr.org/2013/02/07/171413261/laura-ingalls-siste... and paper at http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/pediatrics/early/2013/01/29/peds.2012-1438.full.pdf http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/pediatrics/ear... .