3 ms·
It's worth pointing out that a situation like this is often the endgame of anti-corruption rules. It always starts simple: you put in a rule, say, that a contr
by ubernostrum 9y ago
It's worth pointing out that a situation like this is often the endgame of anti-corruption rules.
It always starts simple: you put in a rule, say, that a contract can't be awarded to a contractor who has some relationship to the person making the decision. Then someone quite reasonably objects that a bureaucrat from a different department might try to influence the decision-maker to award to their friend for a kickback. So now you add a rule that there are multiple entities, ideally adversarial, involved who all have to agree before the contract gets awarded. Then you pile on yet more rules as people come up with ever more creative ways to get around them.
And then one day you wake up and realize you have a literal maze of reports and applications and audits and inspections and committees that all have to be fulfilled for even the simplest project, and it's grown so complex that only a couple of companies put in the (extreme) effort of figuring out how to navigate it; everybody else has given up. Now those have a guaranteed lock on future contracts, and no longer have any incentive to be honest or control costs, since who else are you ever going to legally be able to give a contract to? Plus, the system is so complex that even the people in charge of it don't always know how to manage or enforce it. And then the costs start going up and up and up...
- thebiglebrewski 9y agoI guess I see what you're saying but...how about people are just reasonable and not greedy? But I suppose that goes against basic human nature, or something.
- cmurf 9y agoMany cultures make this work, including Japan. They also have very involved, ritualized, negotiations. I don't know whether the contracts are any longer, or if they depend substantially on long standing norms. What I see in America's big projects right now is a lot of selfish narcissism. Greed stems from that. It's, "I am a whore, and you should go right ahead and treat me like one because I'm gonna treat you like one." It's really adversarial. There is no pride in anything other than making money. Contrast with the big industrial boom period of the 20th century, when massive public and private infrastructure was built, with really high taxes on the high end - I think they took a lot of pride in their work, the fact that so many people, a civil society, were going to use and benefit from using that infra - and it was going to make everyone richer.