2 ms·
Ok well there you go. I was basing it on your earlier definition. So define the word contemplate. But do you see how defining things and using the subject and
by EGreg 9y ago
Ok well there you go. I was basing it on your earlier definition.
So define the word contemplate.
But do you see how defining things and using the subject and object makes it hard to ask any of the major questions?
- guuz 9y ago> Ok well there you go. I was basing it on your earlier definition. Sorry, but it was my first comment on the thread. You are confusing me with the guy that posted earlier. I apologize for entering in the middle of your conversation. > So define the word contemplate. Contemplate: to observe something and to entertain thoughts about it. Imply that self preservation is an example of self consciousness is not sufficient for me. Plants too react to stimuli and they don't even have a nervous system (edit: neurons are not a sine qua non condition, obviously. I was only pointing to the fact that simpler organisms react to the environment, it is one of the most basic evolutionary strategies). It is necessary something more. As the poster before me said, there are boundaries. They can be not clear, but they exist.
- mannykannot 9y agoGuuz's comment does not change the earlier definition (regardless of who stated it.) What it does do is point out a flaw in your argument from that definition to your claim that crabs are self-conscious.
- EGreg 9y agowhat is it like to be something which experiences and know you are that thing. According to this definition, crabs are self conscious.
- mannykannot 9y agoAs this is one of several places where you have asserted the same claim, one response is sufficient: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16041077 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16041077