6 ms·
In SF a couple of parks needed to have new public bathrooms built. Cost: 2 million.[1] If you had to do it yourself, It'd be about 100k max. It's pure graft a
by mc32 9y ago
In SF a couple of parks needed to have new public bathrooms built. Cost: 2 million.[1] If you had to do it yourself, It'd be about 100k max. It's pure graft and greediness.
Meanwhile in Japan, they convert an above ground line into a subway line in 3.5 hours of coordinated work.[2] It's a startling difference. This is the one time I'd love to be able to bring engineering and crew from overseas and have them do the work for us and dispense with all the local corruption.
200 ghost workers -unbelievable. And they initially wanted to keep that discovery quiet. $1000/day/ghost worker for the taxpayers of New York. $200k waste per day --that's how much The City respects its citizens.
[1]http://hoodline.com/2017/10/golden-gate-park-playground-lands-2-million-for-bathrooms-upgrades http://hoodline.com/2017/10/golden-gate-park-playground-land...
[2]https://youtu.be/wIbZqqLra9k?t=80 https://youtu.be/wIbZqqLra9k?t=80
- olingern 9y agoJapan also has a much different outlook on blue collar jobs, and (from studying the culture and spending ~3 months there) people seem to take genuine pride in their job regardless of what it is. Contrast that with the MTA subway workers I see regularly huddled into groups, shooting the breeze and playing on their phones -- it's a widely different outlook on work. Also regarding you [2] link, I can't remember where I read it, but I believe that operation took years of planning.
- mc32 9y agoI mean, to be sure Japan has institutionalized pork too[1]. They offer contracts to build retaining walls where no one lives. But damn, when they have to do something they are experts in they do it right. And given the JRs are private orgs, they can't just ask for another bond measure or other tax or more pork from the govt. And of course it took years of planning. In the US you'd have years of "planning" [pork dealing] and then the line shut down for a year or two probably, doing things as slowly as possible. [1]https://www.reuters.com/article/uk-japan-election-concrete/analysis-japan-election-points-to-return-of-construction-state-idUKBRE8BA1AD20121211 https://www.reuters.com/article/uk-japan-election-concrete/a...
- olingern 9y agoSitting in a cafe in Shibuya, Tokyo ( at the moment ), I would say there's a "oneness" to everything they do. Inconveniencing others is the height of moral crimes you can do here ( see your family being fined for your suicide [1] ). I think this permeates their culture to the point where they're more efficient so that they do not affect others, i.e. how on time trains are in Japan [2]. Of course, this is speculative, but it certainly does not feel like a, "I'll get mine, before you get yours culture" here. [1] - https://www.irishtimes.com/news/health/families-fined-for-suicides-in-japan-1.1104002 https://www.irishtimes.com/news/health/families-fined-for-su... [2] - http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-42009839 http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-42009839
- digi_owl 9y agoI ran into a term some years ago, giri. Seems to be a remnant from their feudal times. Something about reciprocal duty or some such, meaning that workers put their honor into their work with the expectation that they get looked after by the boss/lord in return. This also seems to be the background for a lot of "drama" in their entertainment, where a character will struggle between upholding giri and their emotions regarding the task.
- crdoconnor 9y ago>Japan also has a much different outlook on blue collar jobs, and (from studying the culture and spending ~3 months there) people seem to take genuine pride in their job regardless of what it is. The west seems like the weird culture here. The middle class looks down on people who make our coffees in Starbucks, drive the buses and man the trains but realistically they're the ones everybody would miss if they all suddenly didn't turn up to work on Monday morning.
- shubb 9y agoThe was a bankers strike once, in Ireland. For months. The way people busy worked around it is really amazing, because those workarounds are what the system actually needs to do, minus all the abstraction. http://uk.businessinsider.com/pubs-replaced-banks-in-ireland-in-1970-and-the-economy-was-fine-2016-1 http://uk.businessinsider.com/pubs-replaced-banks-in-ireland...
- rayiner 9y agoNot limited to the west. Indians are absolutely awful to people who work those kinds of jobs.
- thunderrabbit 9y ago> that operation took years of planning. Near the end of the 3.5 hour track change video, it says it was the culmination of 80,000 people working for 8 years. 8年間8万人の集大成
- epc 9y agoMinor correction but neither project in the story is managed by New York City. Although the city owns the subway, it's controlled by the MTA state agency (which is also responsible for East Side Access to Grand Central).
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> it's controlled by the MTA state agency Which the state controls because New York City ran itself into bankruptcy in the 70s and needed a bailout.
- epc 9y agoNo. The MTA was formed in the 1960s to take over operations of the then–bankrupt privately owned Long Island Railroad, assuming operations of New York City transit in late 1960s. NYCT had itself been formed in the 1940s after the then-private companies running various subway, elevated and bus routes went under. Specific to today and the article in question: The government of NYC has little to no control over the MTA, including the subways, other than bickering with the governor over funding.
- chimeracoder 9y ago> Specific to today and the article in question: The government of NYC has little to no control over the MTA, including the subways, other than bickering with the governor over funding. The MTA is an independent entity, but the state government has plenty of control over it through the contracts that control both its funding and its expansion projects. However, as the article explains, the government chooses not to exercise that authority of oversight, delegating it instead to the MTA itself (!).
- epc 9y agoRight. My point is that the MTA is controlled by New York State, not New York City. HN comments tend to conflate the two and then gloss into a general "ultra liberal bankrupt NYC" critique. Many things to criticize NYC over, but management of the subways…is a state problem.
- syphilis2 9y agoReminds me of Arlington's million dollar bus stops. (the plan was eventually re-evaluated - links in chronological order) http://www.dailytech.com/Virginia+Builds+1+Million+Super+Bus+Stop/article30283.htm http://www.dailytech.com/Virginia+Builds+1+Million+Super+Bus... https://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/07/19/virginia-million-dollar-bus-stop-heat_n_3624602.html https://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/07/19/virginia-million-d... https://www.watchdog.org/news/fear-not-taxpayers-arlington-bus-stops-to-cost-half-million/article_cb806027-2fa3-5779-942e-76da6aa6e378.html https://www.watchdog.org/news/fear-not-taxpayers-arlington-b...
- WalterBright 9y agoSound Transit is spending $54 billion to build a few miles of light rail. https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/politics/sound-transit-puts-54-billion-light-rail-plan-on-ballot/ https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/politics/sound-tra...
- mooman219 9y agoKeep in mind that's 62 miles of rail, both above and below ground. Not saying it's a good price, but ~$900 million a mile is a bit better than ~$3.5 billion per mile.
- WalterBright 9y agoThe $54 B doesn't include cost overruns which are already happening!
- so33 9y agoConsidering ST3 hasn’t broken ground yet, I find it hard to believe that the cost overruns are due to construction.
- xxpor 9y agoThe cost overruns are because the cost of land and contractors are rising at an astronomical rate. I forget the exact numbers, but they planned for land appreciation of something like 10%, and the real cost has turned out to be double that.
- martinald 9y agoIs it though? Considering it's light rail with 3 or 4 cars max vs 2nd ave subway being heavy rail with far longer trains, I'm not sure how much better it is.
- rayiner 9y agoThat’s mostly above ground rail through suburbs. DC built the silver line for 1/3 that in similar areas. (Still breathtakingly inefficient compared to $450 million for digging under fricking Paris).
- drstewart 9y agoI don't see what those two comparisons have to do with each other. That's like saying "The marketing department spend $10m on new ads last quarter. Meanwhile, the development team released a new feature in one sprint."
- gsnedders 9y ago> Meanwhile in Japan, they convert an above ground line into a subway line in 3.5 hours of coordinated work.[2] It's a startling difference. This is the one time I'd love to be able to bring engineering and crew from overseas and have them do the work for us and dispense with all the local corruption. London did something roughly comparable in fifteen hours during the construction of the Victoria line in the 60s: https://youtu.be/GwRRSJ_wtIg?t=1074 https://youtu.be/GwRRSJ_wtIg?t=1074
- dominotw 9y agoThis is yet another proof against the narrative that govt run internet Monopoly would be infinitly superior to private run internet. We just cannot count on govt with our future.
- jhayward 9y ago> In SF a couple of parks needed to have new public bathrooms built. Cost: 2 million.[1] If you had to do it yourself, It'd be about 100k max. It's pure graft and greediness. I dislike when this sort of disingenuous description is used. It cost a lot of money to do infrastructure work, and entities generally schedule and package work as a bundle, not as individual items. I am quite certain they are not spending $2m on bathrooms. From [1]: "Additionally, the funds will cover new water, electrical and sanitary utilities services to Lincoln Way, as well as [ways] to improve the pedestrian path that would meet ADA access requirements. The construction work, which will adjust the playground's irrigation and add new landscaping, is slated to begin next month."