11 ms·
Agreed. It’s also a waste of human labor to throw away devices when they could still be made useful with some simple repairs. To go further, it is wasteful to d
by TaylorAlexander 9y ago
Agreed. It’s also a waste of human labor to throw away devices when they could still be made useful with some simple repairs. To go further, it is wasteful to design hardware to be disposable rather than repairable and reusable.
People with jobs I wouldn’t want to do work very hard to bring us these devices, and the earth gives up resources to mine, transport, and shape the materials. Throwing things away when they could last 5-10x as long consumes our precious resources and wastes our collective capital.
Finally I’ll say that a lack of open software support contributes to this. If I could flash alpine linux on an old iPhone, Nexus, or Samsung, I could find great uses for the old hardware. Such a project is now underway (Alpine linux for Mobile), but mobile devices are still a morass of unpatchable secret binaries with glaring security holes.
I know we can better use our resources than to throw a two or three year old flagship phone in the trash or let it waste away in an old drawer, but it will take us demanding more of manufacturers and calling them out for their waste before they take action on it.
- goialoq 9y ago> It’s also a waste of human labor to throw away devices when they could still be made useful with some simple repairs. Are you sure? Assembly line production is highly efficient, that's why warranty service usually means "throw way the old one into the refurbish or recycle pile and give you a new one", not "fix your old one"
- mschuster91 9y ago> Assembly line production is highly efficient The highlevel production may be, but rare-earth mining is incredibly dirty (and some of them, if not sourced from fair trade, directly fund warring groups), and IC manufacturing isn't exactly environment friendly too, lots of nasty chemicals used there.
- LaGrange 9y agoThere's quite a bit of work into recycling those, and Apple has already has the means of recovering much of it - pity people don't generally return their used phones to them, though. Your replacement battery is unlikely to be recycled better than when it's done in an automated manner on a fairly large scale. Of course Apple can get away cheap because of that "people don't even try to recycle" thing. Forcing the industry to do the same thing that happened with bottles (everyone has to accept bottles over certain capacity they sell, and _pay for them_ — though right-wing governments are shuttering those programs) would work wonders, and likely be far better than the romanticised "repairability."
- visarga 9y ago> far better than the romanticised "repairability" I decide on my own what I want, which is to fix the damn thing if it's fixable and not spend 1000$ on a new one. And to fix it is "far better" than to recycle it, or to have it artificially slowed without explanation and deceived into buying a new one. Apple is not the company I once admired. Time passes, MS is slightly more ok and Apple is bad. Weird. I wouldn't have guessed in the early 2000's.
- LaGrange 9y ago"And to fix it is "far better" than to recycle it" Because what, because you say so? I mean, I can say it's far better to dress my phone up in a green skirt and hang it outside my window as a Christmas decoration then. About just as relevant. "Time passes, MS is slightly more ok and Apple is bad." You seem to have missed the lesson from the Apple thing: companies ain't your friends.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- loeg 9y agoRecycling old phones in bulk may still be cheaper than individual phone repair.
- new299 9y agoMy guess is it's not really much of a waste of human labor, but it is extremely energy inefficient. Energy used in production is generally many multiples of that used during operation. So extending usable lifetime versus manufacturing a new device is more energy efficient in most cases.
- ndespres 9y agoHow can it not be a waste of human labor to have devices with artificial roadblocks to extended lifetime in place? We have sources of renewable energy, but human potential is the most valuable thing of all. Despite all our advances in manufacturing technology, they seem to be exploited largely to make more stuff faster that needs to be replaced sooner, and the humans never seem to benefit with a reduction in labor.
- TaylorAlexander 9y agoWhich is a more efficient use of our labor? The manufacture of a phone with a removable battery or the manufacture of a phone with a non replaceable battery? Both situations benefit from the efficiency of modern production lines, but in the former case that device can be easily refreshed by a lay person out in the real world while with the other phone, the same amount of manufacturing resources went in to a phone that only lasts two years. No matter how “efficient” our modern manufacturing methods are, using them to make a device that lasts two years uses more resources per unit of delivered utility than using them to make something that lasts 5-10 years. Also the reason why it’s cheaper to manufacture new than to repair is exactly because repair is not engineered in to the design. If you have to de solder a battery and crack a case to replace a LiPo, it’s going to be more costly than if you just remove some screws and pop out a connector.
- gnopgnip 9y agoThere are phones with removable batteries, but consumers largely choose phones without removable batteries, and the market serves them.
- arbie 9y agoIt is possible that ecosystem lockin effectively prevents consumers from displaying affinity for removable batteries.
- garmaine 9y agoWhere can I buy an iPhone with a removable battery? I didn’t realize I had that choice.
- visarga 9y agoYou can have removable battery, or top of the line phone. Choose one.
- walterbell 9y agoFalse choice, some people would pay extra for a removable battery. There's an entire market for external iPhone battery packs, which are heavier than a removable battery.
- djsumdog 9y ago> Such a project is now underway (Alpine linux for Mobile) Check out PostmarketOS. It's made a lot headway into attempting to create a single, semi-universal image that can be used on multiple devices.
- znpy 9y agoWhat bothers me about PostmarketOS is that they are focusing on pretty much everything except 3d data/phone calls/texts. You know, those reason I carry a mobile phone in my pocket in the first place. I hope they don't lose focus. Imho having a popular device being well-supported would be a killer feature. A bit like a flagship model, you know.
- mark-r 9y agoI was surprised to find out my son's robotics team used old phones as robot controllers. No idea what software they used.
- heartles 9y agoIf it's FTC robotics, they typically use an app framework that manages the wireless connection and enforces some game rules (ex: autonomous vs driver controlled period), and they just program in Robot behavior around that. Or at least that's how it was when I left a couple years ago.
- raquo 9y agoIt's because everything is so cheap nowadays, because all the externalities that we worry about (pollution, resources running out, etc.) are left for the public and future generations to bear, with those who actually cause those externalities not paying their dues. Unfortunately, I don't see this changing within our culture of mindless consumerism and a governance system based on what is essentially legalized bribery ("lobbying").
- qaq 9y agoWho are these magical "they" we own Apple we vote in people in congress and on and on.
- freeflight 9y agoThat's quite a simplification of the situation. While shareholders technically "own" a company, they usually don't have that much influence over a companies policies. This holds even more true with matters that will cost the company a lot of money while giving no added value to the shareholders, such as those externalized costs by polluting the environment. Why would any Apple shareholder willingly take a hit to their portfolio just for a "nice feeling in the tummy about having done the right thing"? Not to mention that with most publicly traded companies there's only one "right thing": Increase shareholder value, everything is optimized around that and pretty much only that. And sure you can vote people into Congress, but what leverage do you have that those people actually stick to their word once they are there? Imho that's one of the major flaws with most representative democracies: There's only positive voting, you can't "vote out" people who didn't hold up their end, you can only try to replace them with somebody who got more votes and hope he/she keeps their word. In the end, this is also a question of how do we want our economies to be built: For supposedly perpetual gains and growth or for a sustainability which accounts for the actual scarcity of resources not easily measured and accounted for, like a clean environment.
- raquo 9y agoWhat's your point? Neither you nor me personally can tell Apple what to do, and certainly not congress. That's the point of my pessimism – modifying your own behaviour does not make any difference. Even if millions of people boycotted iPhones that would still be a smaller loss for Apple than changing how they're doing things, because doing things right is suicidally expensive when most of your customers don't care. An even smaller loss would be doing some marketing to make most of boycotters ambivalent enough to forget the whole thing. Using Apple just as an example, could be any company or government.
- pixelbill 9y agoIll echo this statement, don't throw away your devices! I never throw away a cell phone as long as it is still functioning. You can set them up to be a sensor suite or any other application you might need a compact computer. I use an old cell phone for a GPS on my bicycle (offline maps downloaded, phone has GPS built in, so I don't actually need service). Even after they break it can be fun to take them apart and attempt a repair. Worst case it's just an old phone you weren't using anyway