3 ms·
I understand where you're coming from, but the empirical history of America (at least) brings up two problems. The first is that the definition of race/ethnicit
by geofft 9y ago
I understand where you're coming from, but the empirical history of America (at least) brings up two problems. The first is that the definition of race/ethnicity tends to shift based on what's politically expedient for the powerful: consider whether Irish people, Eastern Europeans, Arabs, and Jews count as "white" at various points across American history. Race just isn't a solid enough concept to be a reliable way to ensure a share of power for anyone who doesn't already have a unrelated strong grasp of power.
The second is that in practice this just causes the weak to identify with and have solidarity with the strong, which isn't the direction you want. There's a lot history of public policy in America that's been targeted at getting lower-class "white" people (for whatever the current definition of "white" is) to believe that their self-interest is more aligned with the success of the white race than with the success of the lower class regardless of race. You can see this clearly in the history of things like Bacon's Rebellion, and the establishment of slavery in the US as a racial-superiority thing as a way to avoid a combined revolt by white indentured servants and black slaves against the upper class. But I think you can see the same thing happening in the present day.
- quantumofmalice 9y agoAs I said in a sibling comment, I view race as too broad a concept to usefully generate social identity, and the fluidity of the concept makes it slippery to deal with. Your second point is a good one, I will think more about it. That said, it seems to me that in the long run relatively homogenous populations (really, many smaller politically independent homogeneous populations, as well as politically independent hetrogeneous populations for the smarter folks) is the best way to maximize social identity and minimize conflict. By the way, I appreciate you taking the time to thoughtfully respond to my comment. It is difficult to say what I think may be the truth (with, I hope, no maliciousness) in todays environment, so thank you.