6 ms·
Can we have a conversation about how it can be that Apple, which used to proudly advertise on "It Just Works", is sitting on billions of dollars in cash AND YET
by EGreg 9y ago
Can we have a conversation about how it can be that Apple, which used to proudly advertise on "It Just Works", is sitting on billions of dollars in cash AND YET, at the same time, iOS and MacOS experience some major regressions with every new release?
I mean, Google has overtaken Apple in UI and UX user satisfaction and usability. Steve Jobs would be rolling around in his grave.
Ever since the "skeumorphism" debate, Apple seems to have become a follower. I don't want knee-jerk downvotes but an actual discussion about why Apple isn't spending at least a billion dollars on a best-of-class program on establishing itself as the leader in
Stability
Usability
User Satisfaction
Testing & Regressions
It's clearly abandoned the Mac store, for instance, and twice even forgot to renew its certificate, making apps crash on startup. Crazy!
- jarym 9y agoI can guess - as the corporation grew its culture changed. I bet management are so focussed on their big bets (Apple TV, movie streaming, iWatch, iPad) and enhancing their cash cow (iPhone) that they are totally not focussed on the 'mature and slow growth' areas of the business (Mac). This will undoubtedly bite them in the ass - it already did with the 2013 Mac Pro, the mediocre MBP with TouchBar and on the poor relative quality of the latest MacOS.
- valuearb 9y agoThe mediocre MBP with touchbar is the best selling MBP ever.
- jarym 9y agoSo what? Windows had been the best selling Operating System for a great many years. It turned into a pile of turd and continued to be the best selling OS.
- valuearb 9y agoWindows has a monopoly lock on it's customers. They can't run their applications on Linux or MacOS (or they certainly would) so they keep buying it. Users don't have to upgrade to touchbar MBPs, they can a) still buy newly manufactured old style MBPs, or b) not upgrade Yet they've bought the touchbar MBPs in massive volumes. I've heard lots of anecdotal complaints about the touchbars, the keyboards. But I've also heard lots of people love both. I trust the sales numbers a little more than I do anecdotes.
- mschuster91 9y ago> Users don't have to upgrade to touchbar MBPs They have, if they want anything comparable in performance to the Windows world (even though 16GB RAM tops is just laughable when there are many 64GB laptops in the Windows world, and I guess 128GB is not far around the corner...).
- valuearb 9y ago1) You can still buy a new 2015 MBP with a processer nearly as fast as the 2017 models and 16gb ram. But the vast majority have chosen the touchbar MBP by pure preference. 2) Laptops with more memory don’t have the same transfer speed or power efficiency.
- jarym 9y agoIf the MBP without TouchBar that they are currently selling came with the same SSD/CPU options and 32Gb of RAM I'd buy it in a heartbeat. I also know I'm far from alone in that. Argument #2 is parrotting what Apple said. Laptops that get smaller and smaller tend not have the same power efficiency either. Blaming 'more memory' having lower power efficiency is a weak argument when you look at the whole picture. As for transfer speeds, its not true that more memory = lower transfer speed; it depends on a number of other factors (type of memory, clock rate..)
- tolien 9y ago> Argument #2 is parrotting what Apple said Weak argument or no, it is demonstrably true - the first Intel CPU to support LPDDR4 will be Cannon Lake, expected some time next year. The part that's missing is that Apple could have put a bigger battery in a device that was either the same size as the previous model (or anywhere between the thickness of the previous and current models), or offered customers the choice of trading RAM for battery life.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoThe 'what' is the fact that this doesn't give management an incentive to improve. "It's our best selling product ever" easily trumps "...But a lot of people hate the software and aren't really sure about the hardware." Apple won't change until the entire edifice comes crashing down in some horrendous techno-corporate train wreck - possibly one where lives are lost. Cook doesn't have the imagination or the empathy to understand the user POV. As far as he's concerned, as long as the company is making money everything is fine, even if it's bleeding goodwill from every shiny white polycarbonate pore.
- valuearb 9y agoI won’t downvote you, but this are just a bunch of random assertions. I’ve upgraded to High Sierra, no problems. Done all the ios updates, no problems. Apple was constantly dealing with quality issues while Jobs was alive. Remember AntennaGate? Apple has more products and customers than ever now, meaning more anecdotal complaints than ever. And no one uses the Mac App store, so no problems.
- akulbe 9y agoAt current count, there are 718 people that have reported having these issues with instability on High Sierra. Are you going to dismiss all of them, as quickly as you're dismissing the person you responded to?
- valuearb 9y agoHow many million users does High Sierra have?
- akulbe 9y agoYou're missing the point again, completely. Your experience does not negate that of all the other folks who are reporting issues.
- valuearb 9y agoYou keep swinging and missing. My great experience with High Sierra doesn't negate others negative experiences, but they are both just anecdotal evidence and not meaningful measures. 700 users who suffer from problems are super motivated to speak up, millions of users having a great experience have no reason to create and post on lengthy threads about how great High Sierra is.
- EGreg 9y agoNo one uses the Mac App Store?? First of all many people do. And second, isn't that there aren't MORE people a problem for Apple? How are people supposed to get apps for their Macs? Download from random websites? How do updates happen?
- macNchz 9y agoPresumably they’ve run the numbers on each of these QA failure incidents and determined that they don’t have a lasting impact on sales/customer retention/whatever metric, however unfortunate that may be for the end user. Like many publicly traded companies these days, however, it may be that they’re slowly shooting themselves in the foot by looking through the narrow lens of their quarterly metrics and focusing on near-term shareholder value.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nxc18 9y agoI don’t know why you’re being downvoted. Apple clearly has a quality problem and they also are fortunate enough to have billions of dollars of cash with which to fix it.
- newscracker 9y agoI personally don't think "Google has overtaken Apple in UI and UX satisfaction and usability" in all areas. In services like Maps and a few others, yes, Google was far ahead for a long time and has maintained its lead. On smartphone UI/UX, it's highly subjective, and there's no clear winner there. On desktop OS, it's not an easy comparison since Google doesn't have an equivalent to macOS. But I do agree that the "It just works" slogan can no longer be applied to Apple, due to multiple software related annoyances and experiences that, more than a decade ago, I would've associated only with Windows. The main reason why Apple, with billions of dollars in cash, is unable to establish itself as a leader as well as isn't doing even close to some other mediocre companies is because of its organization structure. Apple's structure doesn't allow having enough people to work on multiple things simultaneously and spread its attention. A much detailed explanation of this is on this article on Stratechery, titled "Apple's Organizational Crossroads". [1] It would do well for Apple's leadership to make changes in how it works, but so far there's not much evidence of anything like that happening on the software front. [1]: https://stratechery.com/2016/apples-organizational-crossroads/ https://stratechery.com/2016/apples-organizational-crossroad...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- stevenh 9y agoIs it possible that the company is being sabotaged from the inside by employees secretly working on behalf of competitors, and Tim Cook is too naive to see through their sycophancy and specious "good" update ideas?
- carlivar 9y agoI think Hanlon's Razor applies.
- strictnein 9y agoInteresting. Didn't know the name for the phrase "Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity." until now, even though I think of it almost daily.
- briandear 9y agoGoogle wins on UI? Material design where you have no idea what an icon does until you hover over it? How UI elements are hidden and, if you don’t know where they already are, you have to hunt to find things? Is Google Hangouts and example tou are referring to? Apple crushes Google on UI.. there’s hardly a worthy debate there.