5 ms·
Two things: > "They find that a significant chunk of the income accruing to the top 1 percent of earners in the United States today goes to the owners of mid-m
by chiefalchemist 9y ago
Two things:
> "They find that a significant chunk of the income accruing to the top 1 percent of earners in the United States today goes to the owners of mid-market firms in a broad range of non-financial industries around the country. In other words, it’s not Wall Street..."
It depends. How are these mid-market firms financed? How are their customers finance? Who/what ultimately drives the decisions and actions of these firms?
- While inequality is one measurement, the other is poverty, lack of opportunity, etc. The issue I see time and again (read: pattern) is once the discussion is tied to the 1% (via inequality) the push back is "there's nothing wrong with being rich (and greedy)" and immediately the war (for change) is lost.
On the other hand, if we focus on the marginalized, their day to day plight, etc. then we are less likely to get distracted. The point being, sure go ahead hoard all the money you want...but in the 21st century do so many _have to be left out_? How advanced are we when such history, a preventable pattern of history keeps repeating?
- heymijo 9y agoI appreciate this suggestion. When reading this I thought "Why do I care if the 1% are working or rentiers?" The outcome, being a growing class of marginalized people who lack equality of income, opportunity, and meaning is the same whether these people are rentiers or not. I'm reminded of this excerpt from a recent article on Dollar General stores that was posted to HN. "Essentially what the dollar stores are betting on in a large way is that we are going to have a permanent underclass in America. It’s based on the concept that the jobs went away, and the jobs are never coming back, and that things aren’t going to get better in any of these places." https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2017-10-11/dollar-general-hits-a-gold-mine-in-rural-america https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2017-10-11/dollar-ge...
- ameister14 9y agoI care because landlords are a type of business that can be passed on whole to children and allows for the creation of hereditary wealth and hereditary wealth maintenance without risk. If the profitability of a business is mostly because of a single person working there who takes most of the profit, when that person dies their children will not be able to easily maintain that income and so are more likely not to be hereditary members of an upper class.
- gbacon 9y agoWhat data do you have to support your concern about creation of hereditary wealth? Why do you believe that property management is somehow special as compared with other businesses whose profitability is tied to a single person?
- ameister14 9y ago>What data do you have to support your concern about creation of hereditary wealth? The history of Ireland, France, and the UK to start. >Why do you believe that property management is somehow special as compared with other businesses whose profitability is tied to a single person? It's quite simple. If you own land and other people manage it, you just collect a paycheck from the land without any impact on its profitability. You can die and pass it to your kids and the profit stays the same and goes to the same place. If you own a company that is completely dependent on you for profit, when you die the company stops being profitable. If you pass it to your kids and they are incompetent, they eventually lose the business.
- kodablah 9y ago> It's quite simple. If you own land and other people manage it, you just collect a paycheck from the land without any impact on its profitability. In many places in the US, due to property taxes and other things, land is a burden that you will spend your paycheck on, not collect it from (until you sell). Granted if you are using the land for something profitable you might collect on it, but rarely is that use passive (often only if you have mineral rights, even e.g. landlords in the multifamily industry have to work to maintain livability conditions). Using others to manage the land rarely maintains an inherent value to keep you wealthy, at least in the US.
- EADGBE 9y ago> Using others to manage the land rarely maintains an inherent value to keep you wealthy, at least in the US. Property maintenance contracts aren't nearly as expensive as you might think they are. Even with a mortgage, property taxes, maintenance cost and equipment upgrades, one can still come out on top with a profit margin. *This experience is based off of single-family units, though I may have misunderstood your "land".
- eevilspock 9y ago> "Why do I care if the 1% are working or rentiers?" Because fairness matters. We are social beings and our well-being is connected to the nature of our relationships and the fairness of our society. Once basic needs are met, most people would choose a poorer but fairer and more loving community than a society richer through cold utilitarianism. Many if not most people who choose the opposite aren't really happy. And there are a host of other problems with such inequality. For example, democracy is undermined (money is power), and the idea of a meritocracy is likewise belied: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15865876 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15865876 (see my 9-point sub-answer).
- heymijo 9y agoHello eevilspock. Fairness seems to be the driving point behind your comment here and your linked 9-point sub-answer about the idea of a meritocracy. I read your comment here two ways: 1. Being a rentier is more unfair than not. and/or 2. Accumulated wealth beyond that needed to meet basic needs is unfair (whether acquired via rent or not). ^This is me parsing your comment to hopefully reply to the point(s) you wanted to make. If I misinterpreted, please correct me. On the merits of, I think there is a great deal of agreement and overlap between what you wrote and this line that I wrote about there being inequality of income/opportunity/meaning between the 1% (whether rentiers or not) and the 99%.
- eevilspock 9y agoYes, I believe we are likely in agreement :) Though what I'd say about "accumulated wealth" isn't exactly as you put it. If there are two people of equal means, and one chooses to work all summer growing and storing tasty food for the winter, and the other chooses to play all summer and survive off of tubers all winter, this is fair. This is freedom of choice. But this sort of fair difference accounts for only a small fraction of the difference in income and wealth in our world today. The authors of the OP also have similar concerns, once you read past the first few paragraphs.
- chiefalchemist 9y ago"...Once basic needs are met, most people would choose a poorer but fairer and more loving community than a society richer through cold utilitarianism. Many if not most people who choose the opposite aren't really happy..." Original commenter here - But I don't see how this is at all true when current reality, if not history, tells us the exact opposite. For for democracy being undermined. Well, this is a language problem we keep making. That is, if it has been undermined to that extent then it is no longer a democracy. I'd add that it might not have been one in the first place. That is, something inappropriate must have allowed the undermining.
- gbacon 9y agoIn my experience, mid-market firms are financed by smaller local or regional banks with whom the owners have built relationships. Certain industries, such as any where the firm has government receivables, are bankable almost immediately, but others are not. The latter give us the stories — that never seem to caution the listener to mind survivor bias — of would-be entrepreneurs scratching together high-risk initial financing with credit cards, borrowing from family, or second mortgages. None of these involve going to Wall Street. The way to winning over business owners is to make a business case. In Thomas J. Stanley’s The Millionaire Next Door, he makes the case that the typical American millionaire gets there by starting a small business and then playing good defense, that is limiting outflows by not living extravagantly as the stereotypical wealthy in popular literature. This defensive mindset also plays in operation of their firms. Business owners deal constantly with people who want more: suppliers, competitors, regulators, the tax man, employees, spouses, kids, brothers-in-law. The noise floor is high. Rising above the noise floor means doing the hard work of showing your proposed model actually works and is not merely yet another visit from the good-idea fairy. Business owners value relationships. Building relationships takes hard work. Connect motivated people from difficult backgrounds — from which many business owners themselves come — with mentors who will see and nurture the spark. Demonstrate that you are helping to provide a hand up, not a handout.
- taway20171214 9y ago> Business owners deal constantly with people who want more: suppliers, competitors, regulators, the tax man, employees, spouses, kids, brothers-in-law this rings true in my experience. i own a successful small business. everyone is suspect. i can't even go out on a date without the risk of an expectation of financing something expensive in the near future (i.e., $800 broadway tickets). every time i open up the mailbox, i could be hit with a $10,000 demand from some authority.
- grasshopperpurp 9y agoI think this is a good perspective. I also think talking about the top 1% is unhelpful and obscures the picture in a different way. Most of the top 1% are remarkably rich compared to the average American, but they are not so rich that they're completely removed from society or so rich that they have the power to buy politicians/laws to benefit themselves to the detriment of society in general. It's not helpful or fair to group engineers, doctors, and lawyers, etc. with robber barons. The framing of 99% vs 1% was a poor decision, and they likely picked those figures because they meme well. As you say, though, if everyone was truly taken care of, this would be a moot point.
- fjsolwmv 9y agoThe "1%" meme has generated a mass of nonsense simply because English has a common word/symbol for 1/100 but not 1/1000. It's the "1 permil" or "1 per decamil" that is the problem of wealth inequality. And also the public and journalists inability ton distinguish annual income from accumulated wealth.
- chiefalchemist 9y ago"The framing of 99% vs 1% was a poor decision..." Yup. This is an understatement. It's the wrong problem. And even if we get a solution, what good is it? As it's not the right problem.