4 ms·
Who cares if you ban an IP that's already unable to access your site? There's no downside, and it sounds considerably simpler than querying exit nodes.
by chc 16y ago
Who cares if you ban an IP that's already unable to access your site? There's no downside, and it sounds considerably simpler than querying exit nodes.
- ElliotH 16y agoBecause you affect the person running the exit node - not just the people exiting from their IP.
- moxiemk1 16y agoHow? If the people couldn't make it to your IP anyway...
- rdl 16y agoThe assumption is that some (crazy) people are running tor exit nodes on IPs shared with other traffic. That is IMO a seriously bad practice; even putting stuff like that on the same /24 as critical servers is probably a bad idea.
- avar 16y agoThe topic of this thread is that if you're running a Tor exit with a limited exit policy you'll get banned by lazy admins who presume that all Tor exit nodes have a promiscuous exit policy. There's theoretically nothing crazy or bad about running a Tor exit node like that, e.g. one that only allows exits to a few sites that you yourself control. But in practice it's bad for you because of people that think "let's just nuke it from orbit" is responsible behavior on the Internet, even going so far as to ban whole /24 networks.
- _delirium 16y agoPart of the goal of Tor is to have a bunch of normal people running Tor nodes on their own personal machines, VPSs, etc., in which case they're almost always shared with other traffic (the person's own traffic).
- philipn 16y agoThe downside is the person who's running the Tor exit node can't, say, upload videos to justin.tv.