3 ms·
Whenever I read about "ignition" my mind goes strait to weapons research. There is a blurred line between those looking wanting to use fusion for purposes of g
by sandworm101 9y ago
Whenever I read about "ignition" my mind goes strait to weapons research. There is a blurred line between those looking wanting to use fusion for purposes of generating power, and those seeking to further nuclear weapons. 'Ignition' generally draws a good line between the two. For instance, the National Ignition Facility isn't doing reactor development. If I were the author, I'd reconsider the title to emphasize that it's focus is the generation of electrical power.
- saguro 9y agoFusion technology of the kind being discussed here is not terribly useful for nuclear weapons. If you want nuclear weapons, build breeder fission reactors.
- throwawayaway12 9y agoIt is not for producing nuclear material, but for reproducing conditions relevant to weapons (although HBE itself may not be useful).
- sandworm101 9y agoAll fusion research has some relevance to weapons. If you are studying ignition, how to get fusion going, that is at the heart of research into building smaller thermonuclear devices. If you study containment, that is useful to increasing the efficiencies of weapons. Fire is fire.
- krastanov 9y agoIf we are going down that path of reasoning you can just as well say "all scientific research has some relevance to weapons". It also happens to have relevance to making life better, saving the planet, and understanding the universe.
- petre 9y agoAll energy discharges could be weaponized. Take the bow and arrow for instance.
- manigandham 9y agoThe title already says "road map to clean energy" - how much clearer does it need to get? Besides ignition is a well understood scientific word and nuclear fusion isn't useful for weapons.
- throwawayaway12 9y agohttps://lasers.llnl.gov/science/stockpile-stewardship https://lasers.llnl.gov/science/stockpile-stewardship "Because it is the only facility that can create the conditions that are relevant to understanding the operation of modern nuclear weapons, NIF is a crucial element of stockpile stewardship. NIF creates conditions—temperatures of 100 million degrees and pressures 100 billion times that of the Earth’s atmosphere—similar to those in stars and detonating nuclear weapons."
- FriedPickles 9y agoFusion is used for boosting, boosting is needed for miniaturization. In the absence of explosive testing I believe a facility like NIF is useful for weapons.
- sandworm101 9y agoBoosting is something that can be done in all sizes of weapons. It just means adding some hydrogen into the primary fission device, as simple as filling the otherwise hollow pit/core. When you read about "dial a yield" technology, that is about adding or removing the boosting hydrogen from the primary. Vent it off and you get a lower yield.
- pdonis 9y ago> Fusion is used for boosting That's one use in a weapons context, but not the only one.
- pdonis 9y ago> nuclear fusion isn't useful for weapons Um, what? All modern nuclear weapons use fusion.
- pdonis 9y ago> Whenever I read about "ignition" my mind goes strait to weapons research. We knew how to ignite a fusion weapon in the early 1950s. The problem is how to ignite a controlled fusion reaction that can provide clean energy. That's what the word "ignition" is referring to in this context.
- badosu 9y agoEven if this research would be used to develop an alternative fusion bomb ignition system, wouldn't it be better as it would avoid using a fission reaction that has a high probability of leaving heavy radioactive material?
- pdonis 9y agoThe fission ignition doesn't make any appreciable difference in fallout; the main factor in fallout is at what altitude the bomb detonates--higher altitude, less fallout. The amount of radioactive material in the fission trigger itself is negligible; fallout comes from radioactivity induced in the materials thrown up from the ground during the explosion.