3 ms·
> It's more about, "how much real-world badness (specifically, many violent, racist, hate-based movements around the world) has been enabled by what we thought
by taneq 9y ago
> It's more about, "how much real-world badness (specifically, many violent, racist, hate-based movements around the world) has been enabled by what we thought were benevolent principles of radically open information and free speech?"
And once you've made the jump from "speech should be free" to "speech (that I condone) should be free", you've made a big step towards fascism.
- jonknee 9y agoFree speech has no requirement that privately owned companies must promote your speech to a mass audience.
- barrkel 9y agoFor sure. But trying to get privately owned companies to clamp down on free speech isn't going to fix the underlying issue; if that worked, sooner or later you'll create a market for fringe right-wing / left-wing social networks and messaging platforms that are even more of an echo chamber, and some people will start agitating for state control over permitted corporate platforms for speech - and that really will be fascism.
- pharrington 9y agoHowever, it does have a requirement that there are large public spaces available to masses to practice free speech. Another important note is that promotion is hardly the same as allowing.
- fragmede 9y agoSomewhere between all possible speech, ever, should be free, and, well, fascism, is a more nuanced and useful classification of speech than "condone: yes/no". A thorough and well thought out treatise on why the Holocaust didn't actually happen, exists in a different class of objectionable compared to a single anti-semitic tweet, which is different to credible threats of bodily harm or death against a specific individual (including street address and phone number). Different still is claims that the Earth is flat or 6000 years old. Expressing like or dislike of current political leaders belongs to yet another class, and the various different kinds of sales pitches could be divided into a few more, as well.