5 ms·
It's an interesting article, finally listing some specific use cases. But I'm curious - why now? What makes blockchain better than using other possibilities bet
by viraptor 9y ago
It's an interesting article, finally listing some specific use cases. But I'm curious - why now? What makes blockchain better than using other possibilities between each pair of banks? I don't expect bank A to care about transactions between banks B and C, so the distributed blockchain doesn't sound very useful. On the other hand, I expect banks to care about guaranteed atomic transactions rather than consensus.
(Transfers between many banks in the UK were instantaneous for a decade or so, so apparently it can be done without a blockchain ;-) )
- bradleyjg 9y agoI don't expect bank A to care about transactions between banks B and C, so the distributed blockchain doesn't sound very useful. Maybe for more efficient netting? If A owes B $100 and B owes C $100 and C owes A $100 then no money has to ever change hands, even in the sense of crediting or debiting accounts at the central bank.
- Analemma_ 9y agoI wonder how many of these banks think they're using blockchain, and put out press releases stating that, because the engineers have lied to management in order to get projects underway. Matt Levine has been speculating on this a lot recently: banks traditionally have hugely underinvested in infrastructure upgrades. I imagine if you're in IT at a bank, it must be awfully tempting to go "blockchain! secret project!" to get management on board because the suits are all caught up in the hype. Then you can just immediately pivot to Apache Cassandra (which is strictly superior to blockchain in pretty much every proposed business use of blockchain I've ever seen) and no one's the wiser.
- vladsanchez 9y agoWould you please share references to your stated Cassandra superiority over Blockchain? Thanks.
- canoebuilder 9y agoCassandra is real world proven tech with many actual, observable implementations "in the wild." What even is a "blockchain," not in the context of something like bitcoin? How does a blockchain even work within a single organization? However it may or may not work, the dynamics involved would seem to make it qualitatively different from something like a bitcoin blockchain. So you're asking for a comparison between something that does exist and something that doesn't. And in fact something that can never exist, if we are going to stick to the convention of treating names as more or less unique identifiers of a certain set of characteristics.
- code_sloth 9y agoTry querying a blockchain.
- jameskegel 9y agoBlock explorers work great. Is that what you mean?
- tCfD 9y agoThis is exactly what is happening. "Blockchainism," a vague and shifting set of shared assumptions about voluntary custodial risk/reward sharing, vs "a blockchain", a particular encoding of a particular subset of these ideas into a white paper and corresponding client software, according to a particular framing of incentives motivating the people who created it, which may differ greatly from those who invest in it or speculate on it. Blockchain is on its way to becoming a hollowed-out incantation, like "green technology" or "democratic" or "brawndo"
- shepardrtc 9y agoEach bank/financial institution will probably have its own blockchain for its own purposes. But if they need to make a transaction to another bank's blockchain, they can use the Interledger protocol [1] to do so. [1] https://interledger.org/ https://interledger.org/
- viraptor 9y agoHere's the point though: if you want to do this, why not have a standard relational database at each bank and a standard for authorised endpoints in each paired bank? This tech was available for decades. Why interledger and blockchains to complicate it?
- DennisP 9y agoYou wouldn't. You use a blockchain when you want one common ledger across multiple companies, and you don't want to pay/trust a single company to manage it. Assuming you know who everyone is, you can use traditional consensus mechanisms like Byzantine Paxos and get much higher transaction rates than public blockchains can do right now.
- canoebuilder 9y agoWith bitcoin, because the participants aren't identified and there isn't any form of traditional trust established between them, there are certain actors in the system that are paid a lot to manage the transactions/blockchain. In your example of multiple companies coordinating on a single blockchain, who would be paid to manage it?
- DennisP 9y agoIt's way cheaper than on Bitcoin because there's no PoW. Each participant would pay to run their own servers that connect to it.
- ucaetano 9y agoYou use a blockchain when you want one common ledger across multiple companies, and you don't want to pay/trust a single company to manage it. Not really, you can have a blockchain managed by a single company. In the most basic definition, a blockchain is simple an authenticated linked sequence of records. It can be public or not, it can be processed centrally, distributed across a single organization, or distributed in a peer-to-peer fashion.
- ucaetano 9y agoAll the transaction stuff is useless. Blockchain is actually really bad for that: it utilizes a centralized ledger. Money today is completely decentralized. There is no central registry of where every single piece of money is, which has to be updated every time anyone makes a transaction. It flows and is converted to goods and vice versa in a completely decentralized and parallel way. Remember: the ledger is completely centralized (there is a single, unique, monolithic ledger). Only processing of the ledger is distributed. It is probably the worst possible way to design a currency.
- flignats 9y agoThis is untrue, where did you learn this?
- ucaetano 9y agoWhat is untrue? That bitcoin has a single central ledger? Duh, it does. If the ledger is processed in a distributed way across many peers doesn't change the fact that there is a single central ledger. If a transaction isn't in the ledger, it doesn't exist. If I give you $10 and we don't tell anyone about it, do you still have the money? Yes. If I give you BTC10 and we don't tell anyone about it, do you still have the BTC? No.
- jameskegel 9y agoIf I give you a paper wallet or something like openDime? You now have BTC and nobody knows about it.
- viraptor 9y agoIf you give someone a paper wallet, then both of you have access to it and both of you know about it. (You can't prove you don't have a copy) If you do it on opendime, then everyone with access to opendime know about it. (Potentially - depends how much you trust opendime)
- amarkov 9y agoWhen two banks transfer money, there's no concrete thing being moved or transmitted. It pretty much just involves bank B telling bank A "You hereby have $100k of my cash". So A needs some kind of global ledger to keep track of how much cash B actually has, and double check whether it's already told C, D, E that they have all of it. There's no reason in principle a blockchain is better at solving this problem than a trusted central bank. But if the existing central bank is moving slowly or has annoying policies, it's much easier to bootstrap a blockchain than bootstrap a new trusted authority.
- gaius 9y agoSo A needs some kind of global ledger to keep track of how much cash B actually has, and double check whether it's already told C, D, E that they have all of it. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nostro_and_vostro_accounts https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nostro_and_vostro_accounts This is a long solved problem. No blockchains necessary. As an aside this is a problem I often see in fintech pitches...
- ucaetano 9y ago"When two banks transfer money, there's no concrete thing being moved or transmitted. It pretty much just involves bank B telling bank A "You hereby have $100k of my cash". So A needs some kind of global ledger to keep track of how much cash B actually has, and double check whether it's already told C, D, E that they have all of it." No, there's no global ledger, and it isn't required. There are checks and balances and regulations that allow money to work in a completely distributed way. Unlike cryptocurrencies that use a centralized ledger (all the 'major' ones, at least).