9 ms·
New California law allows liquor companies to pay for free rides
- mikestew 9y agoI'm more surprised that it wasn't allowed to begin with. I mean, I see where they were coming from with the original law, but we've had drunk driving in the "bad" bucket for how many decades now? Seems like it took them an inordinate amount of time to catch up with the times.
- jvagner 9y agoThe article covers why it might not be a great idea. That said, people not having any options to get home ignores the fact that people are heading out to spend money on alcohol to begin with. Budgeting for a cab ride home seems beyond everyone's thinking, in this article...
- buttersbadams 9y agoSpending wisely + intoxication. You expect strict budgeting under those circumstances?
- slavik81 9y agoThe argument against was basically that drinking is bad, and that if people can safely get home after drinking, more people will do it. If that's the best argument the opposition had, I can see why this bill passed unanimously.
- bsder 9y ago> Budgeting for a cab ride home seems beyond everyone's thinking, in this article... Cabs at the time you need them for this kind of duty are damn near useless except in the largest cities. It's only the ridesharing services that suddenly made hailing a ride home from the bar a useful situation. And we haven't had ridesharing services around for that long, really.
- sithadmin 9y ago>we've had drunk driving in the "bad" bucket for how many decades now? I think you'll find that outside of larger urban areas in the US, drunk driving tends to fall into a gray area of morality, or in some cases (in my experience, very rural locales with very little meaningful road traffic), an accepted norm. Almost nobody I know that lives in an urban US area drives drunk or finds it acceptable. This becomes more lax among my suburban friends and acquaintances. For some of my more rural acquaintances, taking a 6 pack along for consumption during a drive is typical behavior that nobody in their community even bats an eye at.
- bmelton 9y agoI think this has a lot to do with a lot of things. If I'm working in the city, it's easy for me to say "Well, I plan to drink tonight, so I'll cab to the place where I'm drinking so that I'll have to cab from the place after I'm drinking." When that place is more than a $50 Uber/Lyft/Cab ride away from the suburbs I'm coming from, the options are limited, leaving me to the effort of having to curtail the amount that I drink such that it's safe to drive home. The science I've heard mention is that you can metabolize something like 2 drinks per hour, which is a handy guideline, but lacks so much. 2 drinks of what? 3% Miller Lite isn't the same as 10% microbrews, which isn't the same as 40+% scotch or bourbon. Does that 2 drink guideline cover hard spirits in assuming the worst, or is it assuming the most common scenario of beer? I have no idea. For me, I tend to prefer drinking at home, or at Uber/Lyftable distances from my home, so that I can be safe, but yeah, everyone's guidance differs slightly, and as someone downthread mentions, relying on choice of drinking safely as judgement is impaired by the alcohol they're drinking is fraught with peril.
- sithadmin 9y agoIt's definitely a multifacted issue. I suspect that income distribution between urban centers and other areas definitely plays a major role, as does a person's risk calculus associated with performing the act itself. As far as 'drinks per hour' guidelines go, that's usually standardized as a single unit of alcohol (e.g. 1 1.5 oz shot of 80 proof liqour OR 12 oz of a macrobrew lager OR 6 oz of a typical wine).
- sedtrader 9y ago> Thousands attending Super Bowl 50 in Santa Clara in 2016 didn't have options to get home safely after drinking Pardon my humor, but do designated drivers exist anymore? or was that just a fad that went out of style?
- diafygi 9y agoI suspect that designated drivers are economically worse than sponsored rides. A designated driver is a person not buying drinks and yet still taking a spot in your capacity. If you can sell $1000 more drinks by sponsoring rides, and those rides cost $500, it's totally worth sponsoring rides.
- oceanswave 9y agoSoon, analytics will find the teetotalers that are buying tickets and automatically tack on a surcharge so that their non-drinking spot is amortized at a rate that is determined by the average revenue generated by a drinker. Past ticket holders who have shown themselves to be exceptional at both consuming alcoholic beverages may be eligable for a reduced price ticket.
- Eridrus 9y agoYou make this seem like a bad thing, but as someone who doesn't drink a lot, I would prefer to pay a surcharge rather than deal with a 2 drink minimum.
- kodablah 9y agoI've often wondered why this wasn't the case before, though I understand many state alcohol agencies (i.e. TABC where I live) discourage drinking incentivization. Ride sharing companies should now be falling over each other to sign exclusive deals with bars. "Come to Kodablah's Bar. We'll pick you up in a Lyft and send you home in one at no extra cost. Restrictions apply: only applies to those within 18 miles, minimum tab of $40."
- gnicholas 9y agoFun fact: at Giants Stadium in SF, you can get a wristband for a free soda if you are a DD. Just swing by Guest Services and they'll give you a wristband. Not-so-fun fact: you cannot redeem the wristband for water. You literally have to get soda.
- nugator 9y agoThis is so US for me. Soda i easier and cheaper than plain good tasting water.
- rconti 9y agoAt a place with a soda fountain you can usually get water cups for free, BUT at a concession stand type setup, often the only water on offer is bottled, which is probably why they'll give you free soda but not (more expensive) bottled water. It ain't right, but.. it is.
- ranqet 9y agoI have never seen a soda dispenser that didn’t have a switch for water and/or carbonated water.
- DrScump 9y agoSome lack one or both. It's optional. A fountain has no inherent need for non-carbonated water unless they serve uncarbonated drinks like orange or punch.
- mikeash 9y agoAre they not legally required to offer water for free? I thought that was pretty common.
- singlow 9y agoThere is certainly a free water fountain with tap water, but bottled water is not free.
- freeloop3 9y agoI don't think it would help much. If someone is considering whether to drive to an event or get a ride, a coupon isn't going to sway them. They may want to show off their new car, or have the ability to take someone home with them, etc. For people who drove to the event and drank too much there, they'll worry about their car. Also they'll take offense at being offered a ride. Alcoholics often have a lot of arrogance and would rather risk it than use a coupon to take a ride because they're "out of control", and take that hit to their pride. This would only work if the law would allow for free transportation to the event, as controversial as that may be.
- sundaeofshock 9y agoDepends on where you live. In a place like San Francisco, people will drive to events because mass transistor starts to suck after midnight. A person who knows they will get a free or discounted ride home may take Bart (as an example) to the event.
- ArlenBales 9y ago> It’s an all-too-familiar scene in Sacramento. A group of friends heads to midtown for a night of partying and drinking, but one friend has to miss out on the fun and stay sober to be the designated driver. > A new law that takes effect Jan. 1 may not only let everyone join in on the fun, but it’ll also mean more money for the bubbly. The problem here is the whole party may be too drunk to make the wise decision of getting a ride. The designated driver isn't just a driver but the overall sober final say for the group.
- gumby 9y ago> Vouchers or codes can be given to alcohol sellers or directly to consumers, but cannot be offered as incentives to buy a company’s product. How can you possibly tell the difference? And I’m sure the vouchers will prominently feature advertising. Don’t get me wrong, I think this is an excellent idea (though I only drink 1-2 drinks a month). But some of the rules around alcohol are fantastical.
- baddox 9y agoYou wouldn’t be able to prove or disprove the existence of incentive, but I’m sure the rule means that you can’t offer vouchers contingent on alcohol purchases, as in “buy at least 3 drinks and we will give you a voucher.”
- SilasX 9y agoAnyone else annoyed at the article’s title? “Too drunk to drive? New California law could give you a free ride” It wouldn’t “give” you a free ride, it would undo the previous law that stopped the business from giving you a free ride. They’re framing it like “not doing the stupid thing anymore” is some kind of gift from the state.
- ada1981 9y agoPeople still drink alcohol?