4 ms·
I understand what he's saying. And I don't think it's a zero sum game. That's just a phrase people like to use to sound smart. People in poverty today are a
by reaperducer 9y ago
I understand what he's saying. And I don't think it's a zero sum game. That's just a phrase people like to use to sound smart.
People in poverty today are a hundred times better off than those in poverty in the 1500's. If it really was a zero sum game, then for all the iPhone X-toting SF hipsters, there would be thousands of people living in conditions worse than the Middle Ages.
- ComputerGuru 9y agoNo, because living conditions have nothing to do with being rich or poor. I’m not arguing that quality of life has not gone up; it’s has undoubtedly done so. The richest of kings of yore didn’t lead a more comfortable or luxurious life than a middle class citizen of any country today. But they were “richer.” But disparity in wealth (which is the definition of being rich/poor) has nothing to do with that.
- Robotbeat 9y agoDisparity in wealth is not the definition of rich/poor in this context, clearly. (And IMHO, viewing the economy and wealth in strict zero sum terms is depressing, counterproductive, and incorrect.)
- nostrademons 9y agoDisparity of wealth isn't how most people define being rich/poor. Most people compare themselves to their 5-year-ago self (or their parents, or their childhood, or their expectations), and as long as they're doing better than expected, they're rich. It's just that people who compare themselves to others tend to be disproportionately loud. If you compare yourself to yourself and come up short, you have nobody to blame but yourself, so of course you're not going to crow about it. If you compare yourself to the people you hear about on the news and come up short, obviously they must have cheated.