3 ms·
Imagine your annual income is $200k, and you expect your iPhone X to last 2 years. Imagine you're very busy with work and parenting, and it's very valuable to y
by rahimnathwani 9y ago
Imagine your annual income is $200k, and you expect your iPhone X to last 2 years. Imagine you're very busy with work and parenting, and it's very valuable to you to be able to take high quality pictures of your baby and share them with family and friends. A smartphone is the most convenient way to do that. A smartphone that costs ~$1000 takes much better pictures, and faster shutter response, than a smartphone that costs $250.
Is the iPhone X worth an extra $375 per year for the person described above? Of course.
Does it need to provide 4x the utility to be worth 4x the price? No. The marginal utility just needs to be cost-effective, vs. the other ways to 'buy' utility with the same amount of money.
- Certhas 9y agoWhat's the marginal utility over a 500$ Galaxy S8?
- rahimnathwani 9y agoLet's assume the cameras (hardware and software) are equally good. If the person I described already uses iOS (and has done for the last few years), then I expect they'd find switching to Samsung-flavoured Android would cause at least a few hours of inconvenience up-front to get most things they need set up, and then little annoyances here and there for a long period afterwards. At least that was my experience switching my primary mobile device from iOS to Android. And I'd have the same amount of inconvenience if I were to switch from Android to iOS. Some people value their time highly, and don't find it enjoyable to find solutions to technical or usability problems. So switching to/from iOS has significant disutility.
- Certhas 9y agoSure, so you pay for having locked yourself into a particular ecosystem. Even then, the relative utility of an X over an 8 is not utility.
- rahimnathwani 9y agoAn iPhone X doesn't provide a better user experience to my hypothetical user than an iPhone 8?
- CRConrad 9y agoNope. For some reason a myth of the iPhone's superiority persists -- perhaps mainly among iPhone owners? -- but according to most reputable reviews I've read over the years (and a few people I know who have owned both), that hasn't been true any more for about half a decade now.
- voidmain 9y ago"Does it need to provide 4x the utility to be worth 4x the price? No." Exactly! This fallacy of comparing ratios rather than differences in price is extremely common, totally unjustified, and causes people lots of harm from bad spending decisions in both directions. $100 extra is $100 extra whether attached to a small purchase or a big one. The correct comparison is (as you say) between the benefit/cost of the extra spending and the benefit/cost of other marginal purchases you would consider. Comparing to the benefit/cost of the "base" purchase (the basic smartphone in this case), which may be very high because that purchase is not marginal for you, is just wrong.